Editorial Board
MusicWeb International
Founding Editor Rob Barnett Editor in Chief
John Quinn Contributing Editor Ralph Moore Webmaster
David Barker Postmaster
Jonathan Woolf MusicWeb Founder Len Mullenger
Gottfried August
HOMILIUS (1714-1785) Ein Lammlein geht und tragt die Schuld – Passion
Cantata HoWV.I.2 (published 1775)
Monika
Mauch (soprano)
Bogna Bartosz (mezzo)
Markus Brutscher (tenor)
Hans Christoph Begemann (bass)
Basler Madrigalisten
Neue Düsseldorfer Hofmusik/Friz Naf
rec. Reformerte Kirche Arlesheim, March 2006 CARUS 83.262 [59:30
+ 34:17]
Gottfried August Homilius was a pupil of J. S. Bach, whose
influence abounds in this notable
work first published in 1775. It’s written to a text by E.A.Buschmann
which is newly written and not taken directly from the Passion
narrative – though it is certainly based on scripture, often
the Old Testament. The text, and thus the work, is contemplative
in the main, reflective, and it encouraged from Homilius
a suitably warm and simple homophonic style framed by some
appetising and highly effective instrumental devices. It’s
clear that both types of Passion – the strict and the more
diffuse – existed in Dresden at the time Homilius set to
work on his Passion Cantata Ein Lammlein geht und tragt
die Schuld. Given the vast amount of choral music from
this period it should not come as so much of a shock to realise
that this is its first ever recording – though the quality
of the music is such that it makes its appearance highly
desirable (see also the review of the St John Passion by
Homilius).
The
writing is simple, direct and unaffected. Chorales are shorn
of artifice and spurious decoration. But Homilius was certainly
not a composer devoid of flair or the power of dramatic pointing. The
tenor aria Wie tödlich schrecken die Gerichte is genuinely
dramatic. Similarly the prayerful simplicity of the choral
writing, the solo arias and recitatives is matched by subtlety
of instrumental voicings and voice placement. The uplifting
winds in the bass aria Ich bete, zürnet nicht add
another layer of colour and significance to the writing.
In general though the dramatic is kept within bounds. The
crowd’s curses are relatively downplayed – not exactly decorous
but mild.
There
are times, especially in the later stages when one perhaps
feels the lack of absolute melodic distinction in some of
the arias but Homilius is certainly a master of the deployment
of recitative, which never linger or court boredom. He employs
fugal passages sparely. There’s an excellent one however
– Drana ist erschienen – that reveals a totally accomplished
unflorid and textually astute composer at work. There are
no fripperies in this setting – and the wonder is that austerity
is easily circumvented.
The
soloists do vary in accomplishment. The tenor has a very
prominent bleat and soprano Monika Mauch sounds very occasionally
taxed by some of the more difficult writing but she’s otherwise
impressive. The bass and mezzo are similarly excellent. The
choir sounds to have been on absolutely first class form
as well, with singing that fuses sympathy with refinement;
instrumental strands are always audible and in scale. The
direction of Friz Naf is clearly paramount in all this and
the ensemble and choir have been most attractively recorded
as well. This is a hybrid SACD and comes in a gatefold-type
double CD box. It makes its appeal through the most refined
and sympathetic of means.
Reviews
from previous months Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the
discs reviewed. details We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin
Board
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to
which you refer.