One of the most grown-up review sites around

54,416 reviews
and more.. and still writing ...

Search MusicWeb Here



International mailing

Founder: Len Mullenger                                    Editor in Chief:John Quinn             


alternatively   AmazonUK  


Georges BIZET (1838-1875)
Carmen (1875)
Raymonde Visconti (mezzo) – Carmen
Georges Thill (tenor) - Don José
Marthe Nespoulous (soprano) – Michaëla
Louis Guénot (baritone) - Escamillo
Andrée Vavon (soprano) – Frasquita
Andrée Bernadet (soprano) - Mercédès
Robert Roussel (tenor) - Dancaïre
Téo Mathyl (tenor) – Remendado
Chorus and Company of the Opéra-Comique Paris
L’Orchestre Symphonique de Paris/Elie Cohen (except The Flower Song. conducted by Philippe Gaubert in 1927)
rec. Paris 1928 with one take in 1929 and The Flower Song in 1927
DIVINE ART 27809 [60:30 + 51:37]

Sometimes a reissue comes along to make one think; well, have I heard this or not? The conductor is a recording regular, Elie Cohen, an experienced and practised executant on the rostrum. And then there is Thill the Magnificent. Surely one thinks to oneself one must know it, if not just for Thill. Oddly however this is a recording that has seemingly escaped the clutches of wholesale restorers. So the simple answer is no, I’ve not heard it before.
Thinking of early Carmens reminds one that a light discographical truffling might be of interest. The earliest Carmen was the 1908 German language recording with Emmy Destinn, Karl Jorn, Minnie Nast and Hermann Bachmann and it’s has been restored by Marston. The next version was Parisian and made in 1912 with Marguerite Mérentié, Aline Vallandri, Marie Gantéri, Jeanne Billa-Azéma and Agustarello Affre (see review of Malibran’s transfer, though a more recommendable transfer is also on Marston). Then came an Italian Columbia set in 1920, followed by a recording directed in 1927 – the first electric - by Coppola with Perelli, Brothier, Trévi and Musy (on another Malibran CD). Then came this one with Cohen, followed sharply by a Sabajno-led Italian set in 1931 and another by Molajoli in 1933 with Pertile, Buades, Tellini and Franci.
So we have never lacked for Carmens, and even in pre-First World War days there were two very recommendable cast recordings if one could afford it.  This second electric recording has strong claims on the collector. Its star is Thill, who tends to eviscerate, in emotive terms, his fellow cast members. Thill’s versatility encompassed the ringing and declamatory as well as the gently caressing – and all stops in between. His is an impersonation of the fullest richness and the close attention to consonants and vowel production of a native French speaker brings its own inestimable colouristic advantages. The text is ringingly alive when Thill is on hand. He is elegant and he is charming, he is suave and commanding.
His Carmen is Raymonde Visconti, seven years older than Thill. She’s perfectly acceptable but only really comes alive as the opera reaches its close. The earlier scenes find her just a touch metrical and overly straightforward. When she and Thill share their Seguidilla and duet in the First Act one finds too much of a buffer between his kaleidoscopic humanity and her studiedly neutral competence.  Michaëla is Marthe Nespoulous, a soprano of considerable girlish refinement. Hers is a typically French voice and I find it very persuasive. It’s well supported, unaffected and has theatrical presence, though I wondered momentarily as to its carrying power on stage. I also liked the Escamillo of Louis Guénot who also, in his own very different, blustery way – has an effective stage persona that manages to transcend the grooves. It wouldn’t do to suggest that he has the most imperishable of voices but he’s enjoyable and gives good value. So I think it would be wrong to limit this to a one-man set. True, Thill is by some considerable distance the most marvellous singer here but there are at least two other performances of some stature.
The transfers sound very well.  Andrew Rose seems to have done something similar to his restoration work on E.J. Moeran’s symphony; he seems to have strengthened string tone, maybe by strengthening the bass line – though without access to the original set it’s difficult for me to make any kind of meaningful comparison. He notes the original recording was “thin” and this was “corrected by reference to a modern recording.” The results, on a stand-alone basis, sound very acceptable.
The recording obviously is not complete – there are no recitatives and no dialogue - but this was an almost invariable corollary of recording at the time. We do have texts, a plot summary and artist biographies. So all in all that early Carmen discography is taking on an increasingly healthy look on CD, greatly helped by this most worthwhile addition to the catalogue.
Jonathan Woolf


Return to Index

Untitled Document

Reviews from previous months
Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the discs reviewed. details
We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin Board
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to which you refer.