Editorial Board
MusicWeb International
Founding Editor Rob Barnett Editor in Chief
John Quinn Contributing Editor Ralph Moore Webmaster
David Barker Postmaster
Jonathan Woolf MusicWeb Founder Len Mullenger
Andrzej PANUFNIK (1914 – 1991) Homage to Polish Music Old Polish Suite (1950, rev. 1955) [10:16] Concerto in Modo Antico (1951, rev. 1955)a [14:13] Jagiellonian Triptych (1966) [8:47] Divertimento after Janiewicz (1947, rev. 1955) [11:31] Hommage ą Chopin (1949, orch. 1966)b [13:10]
Igor Cechoco
(trumpet)a; Hanna Turonek (flute)b
Polish Chamber Orchestra/Mariusz Smolij
rec. W. Lutoławski Concert Studio, Polish Radio, Warsaw,
June 2005 NAXOS 8.570032 [57:58]
During
the difficult years of the Stalin era, composers who were
unwilling to comply with the regime’s dictates had to find
other ways to express themselves if they wanted to remain
true to their artistic ideals. Lutosławski turned to
Poland’s folk music and composed a number of works either
based on folk-tunes or using folk-inflected tunes. That period
of Lutosławski’s composing life culminated in the superb Concerto
for Orchestra. Panufnik, too, had to find his own
way out. He began exploring Poland’s more recent but largely
unknown musical past: music composed between the 14th and
18th centuries. That is what all but one of these
pieces set out to do. The sole exception is the Hommage ą Chopin based
on folk music from Mazowsze where Chopin was born rather
than on themes by Chopin. Moreover, all but one of these
pieces were composed in the years following the end of World
War II. All these works were revised or re-composed in 1955,
and thus belong to Panufnik’s early career. Panufnik went
into some detail about the reason he composed these works.
He witnessed the reconstruction of 16th and 17th century
houses in the old part of Warsaw, which had been destroyed
during the uprising at the end of World War II. “I felt a
strong desire to undertake a similar task with fragments
of Polish vocal and instrumental music of the same centuries
which had suffered near oblivion.”
The
earliest work here is the Divertimento after Janiewicz based
on string trios by Felix Janiewicz (1762–1848) who as a young
violinist came to England and became a founder member of
the Royal Philharmonic Society. These lovely arrangements
are for strings only.
In
both the Old Polish Suite (“Suita Staropolska”)
and the Concerto in Modo Antico, Panufnik does
more or less the same thing as Warlock in his Capriol
Suite or Respighi in his Antiche Arie e Danze per
Liuto, although Panufnik’s scoring for small forces
is rather more subtle than Respighi’s sometimes opulent palette.
In fact, Old Polish Suite is scored for strings; Concerto
in Modo Antico is scored for trumpet, timpani, two
harps, harpsichord and strings. Though composed several years
later, in 1966, the Jagiellonian Triptych is
roughly based on remaining material from that gathered for
the Old Polish Suite. It was written for a
London concert celebrating the Millennium of Polish Christianity
and Statehood. It is thus in much the same vein as the earlier
works and is a quite different piece than the much better
known and considerably more ambitious Sinfonia Sacra.
Hommage ą Chopin is
the orchestration for flute and strings made in 1966 of an
eponymous piece subtitled Five Vocalises for soprano
and piano, first performed in Paris by Irene Joachim and
Paul Collard. As already mentioned, the music is deliberately
based on folk music from the part of Poland where Chopin
was born rather than on themes by Chopin. This gives the
music a most welcome healthy rustic flavour.
It
would be idle to claim that these pieces greatly deepen our
appreciation of Panufnik’s lifelong achievement, but these
arrangements are all done with taste, subtlety and – most
importantly – affection. Some are little known, and three
had never been recorded before, which is enough for this
release to be a must for all Panufnik admirers. Others will
of course find a lot to enjoy here. Performances and recording
are very fine. A lovely disc.
Hubert Culot
Reviews
from previous months Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the
discs reviewed. details We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin
Board
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to
which you refer.