Editorial Board
MusicWeb International
Founding Editor Rob Barnett Editor in Chief
John Quinn Contributing Editor Ralph Moore Webmaster
David Barker Postmaster
Jonathan Woolf MusicWeb Founder Len Mullenger
Peter SCULTHORPE (b. 1929) The Fifth Continent Port Arthur: In Memoriam (version with trumpet) (1996)a,
b [3:31] (first recording) Djilile (1988/1996)c [4:13] (first recording
of version for cello and small orchestra) The Fifth Continent (1963)d, b, e, f, g, h,
i [30:20]
Lament (1976/1991)c [8:50]
Little Suite for String Orchestra (1983) [6:48] Night-Song (1976) [5:43] Port Arthur: In Memoriam (version with oboe) (1996)h,
b [3:15] (first recording)
Mark Skillington
(trumpet)a; Barbara Jane Gilby (violin)b;
Sue-Ellen Paulsen (cello)c; Peter Sculthorpe (speaker)d;
David Pereira (cello)e; Vanessa Souter (harp)f; Bruce Lamont
(trumpet)g; Joseph Ortuso (oboe)h; Mark Atkins (didgeridoo)i
Tasmanian Symphony Orchestra/David Porcelijn
rec. The Ballroom, Government House, Hobart, 24-28 June 1996; 15 March 1997 (Port
Arthur; In Memoriam)
DDD
Notes in English ABC CLASSICS
476 5922 [63:24]
Peter Sculthorpe is a Tasmanian through and
through. He can trace his family in Launceston back to 1841
when his great-great-grandfather was transported from Lambeth,
south London, for larceny. In 1946 Sculthorpe travelled to
study in Melbourne and Sydney and, in 1958, he went for postgraduate
study at Wadham College, Oxford where he rubbed shoulders
with Edmund Rubbra, Egon Wellesz and Wilfrid Mellers. He
returned to Tasmania in 1960 when he learnt his father was
terminally ill and wrote Irkanda IV in 1961, “written
upon the death of my father”, which was subsequently slightly
modified to form the second movement, Outback, from The
Fifth Continent. Some may be familiar with some of Sculthorpe’s
music through the excellent Naxos CD (8.557382) reviewed
by Rob Barnett three years ago and will be familiar with
the composer’s original, accessible and reflectively melancholy
music. This current superlative disc appears to be a straight
re-issue of the ABC Classics 456 363-2 CD reviewed by Hubert
Culot in 2002 and now under the TSO Australian Composers
Series banner. It offers a fascinating snapshot of Sculthorpe’s
composing career, through both original and re-cycled music.
The results are never less than attractively intriguing.
The Fifth Continent was written in 1963 and was
based on D.H. Lawrence’s Australian novel Kangaroo from 40 years
earlier. Sculthorpe had first turned to Lawrence in his early
song-cycle Sun in 1958. In The Fifth Continent Sculthorpe
chose extracts from Lawrence’s novel to introduce each of
the five sections of the work. Words and music are carefully
matched for mood and design and Sculthorpe himself reads
the Lawrence passages eloquently in his Tasmanian accent.
A Prologue sets the scene both literally and musically,
the works main musical thematic material being set out in
essence. The second section, Outback, the one incorporating Irkanda
IV, is introduced by words by Lawrence but also the faint
and evocative sounds of a didgeridoo. Small Town is
an affectionate portrait of the shanty township of Thirroul,
south of Sydney, as discovered by Lawrence. This movement
features some beautiful oboe and cello playing from memebers
of the TSO. Taped wind sounds accompany the fourth section, Pacific;
this is a lonely and desolate picture underpinned by the
Lawrence extract from Kangaroo. The final Epilogue contains
some very beautiful and touching music, the sound of the
lonely didgeridoo being the last sound that is heard. I enjoyed
this piece more and more on repeated listenings and warmed
to the moods skillfully evoked by the composer.
The other works on this disc are all much
shorter. There are two versions of the most recent piece
on the CD, Port Arthur: In Memoriam, a work remembering
the 35 victims of a lone gunman who went on the rampage in
Port Arthur historical park on 28 April 1996. The CD opens
with the version for trumpet which invokes in me memories
of Copland’s Quiet City, while the version for oboe,
with a strangely altogether different atmosphere with the
changed solo instrument, closes the programme.
The Aboriginal chant ‘Djilile’ (‘whistling
duck on a billabong’) was first used by Sculthorpe in a 1974
film score for an ABC-TV film and later transplanted into
the string piece Port Essington three years later.
The chant reappeared in Kakadu (1988), heard on the
Naxos CD mentioned at the beginning of this review. The first
work bearing the name Djilile appeared in 1986 in
versions for piano solo and cello and piano. This work seems
to be Sculthorpe’s answer to Arvo Pärt’s Fratres,
existing in several arrangements – including one for a consort
of four viols. The arrangement presented here was written
especially for this recording and receives a persuasive performance
by Sue-Ellen Paulsen. She also plays very poignantly in the Lament – originally
written for string orchestra in 1976 and here presented in
the 1991 arrangement with solo cello. The music is unremittingly
beautiful and intense, with the harmonic language sometimes
reminding me of the early Messiaen of L’Ascension.
As it is easy to see, Sculthorpe is not backward
in cross-fertilising his music with re-used material. Lament had
borrowed material from a theatre score Rites of Passage and
the Little Suite (1983) reworks music from his earlier
years as a composer; Sea Chant from 1962 in the first
movement and the Little Serenade, from a 1968 film
soundtrack Age of Consent, in the second. It re-uses
a bass line from the song Heart and Soul, previously
heard in the Small Town movement of The Fifth Continent.
The final movement, Left Bank Waltz, uses music also
found in yet another film score Found in a Cave.
Night-Song was written in 1976 for the newly-formed Australian
Chamber Orchestra and again uses borrowed material, this
time from a song The Stars Turn, with words by Tony
Morphett, which had been a 1970 ABC Proms commission for
the project Love 200, celebrating the 200th anniversary
of Cook’s landing in Australia. Its lyricism is evident from
the outset, with jazz-tinged harmonies adding to its appeal.
The Tasmanian Symphony Orchestra is the smallest
of Australia’s symphony orchestras with a full-time complement
of only 47 musicians. However, the scale of the orchestral
forces perfectly suites the works on this CD and they are
uniformly excellently and sympathetically performed, sensitively
led by David Porcelijn. The sound captured by the engineers
in the Government House Ballroom in Hobart can occasionally
seem a little distant but no real loss of detail is perceived
and the warm bloom to the sound often adds positively to
Sculthorpe’s redolent textures.
Reviews
from previous months Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the
discs reviewed. details We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin
Board
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to
which you refer.