Editorial Board
MusicWeb International
Founding Editor Rob Barnett Editor in Chief
John Quinn Contributing Editor Ralph Moore Webmaster
David Barker Postmaster
Jonathan Woolf MusicWeb Founder Len Mullenger
Buy
through MusicWeb
for £14.30/14.80/15.50
postage paid. You
may prefer to pay by Sterling cheque or
Euro notes to avoid PayPal. Contact
for details
Jef
van HOOF (1886–1959) In Flanders’ Fields – Volume 51 Suite
from “Meivuur” (1916) [14:31]
Divertimento for Trombone and Orchestra
(1935)a [7:11]
Vier Giza Ritschl liederen (1906)b
[7:41]
Lentestemming (1910)b [1:50]
Drei Lieder im Volkston (1907)b
[5:58]
Nanoen in huis (1946)b [1:40]
Volkslied : ik heb u lief (1906)b
[2:20] De Crans es uutghehanghen
(1913)b [4:16]
Symphony No.3 in E flat major (1944/5)
[31:35]
Ann De Renais (soprano)b; Ivan
Meylemans (trombone)a
Pannon Philharmonic Orchestra/Zsolt Hamar
rec. Music Hall, Pècs, Hungary, June 2006
PHAEDRA 92051 [78:28]
Not that long ago, I reviewed
another Phaedra CD entirely devoted to Van Hoof (Phaedra
92044 - see review). I will not repeat the general comments
about the composer and his music. Suffice to say that Van Hoof’s
music belongs to well-behaved Post-Romanticism, although it allows
some light impressionistic touches here and there. He composed
in a warmly Romantic idiom, that may be considered anachronistic
considering that he was roughly contemporary to, say, Bartòk,
Kodaly and Prokofiev. However, his seemingly inexhaustible
melodic fund and the clarity and lightness of his scoring
impart to his music a highly personal touch, light years
away from academic Romantic bombast that one might expect.
This shines clearly through the various pieces recorded here.
Van
Hoof composed a good deal of songs and vocal music in the
early stages of his long composing life. It will not come
as a surprise to realise that all but one of the songs recorded
here are fairly early. Most of them were composed in 1906
and 1907 when he was twenty and still a student at the Royal
Conservatory in Antwerp. He drew on a wide range of literary
sources and none of the poets whose texts he used is known
to me. It may be of interest then to say a few words about
Giza Ritschl (her full name was Giza Zsuzánna Ritschl), who
was born in Budapest in 1869 and died in The Hague in 1942.
This Hungarian-born Dutch poet settled in the Netherlands
when she was seventeen as a circus artist. She published
several volumes of short poems influenced by Hungarian folksong.
These were highly regarded by some of the then eminent Dutch
poets. The Vier Giza Ritschl liederen (“Four
songs after Giza Ritschl”) were composed in 1906 when the
composer was recovering from a difficult period caused by
the early death of his mother. He chose four short poems
dealing with death, parting and solitude. The orchestral
versions were made in 1913 and 1917. These songs make it
clear that he found his voice early on in his career. They
have much in common with the songs of Fauré and Duparc, although
they are generally more straightforward and less sophisticated.
From the same year comes Volkslied: ik heb u lief (“Folksong:
I love you”), a simple but moving love song, one of the finest
in this selection. The Drei Lieder im Volkston from
1907 are something of an exception in Van Hoof’s vocal output,
in that it must be the only work in which he used German
texts, again by somewhat obscure poets. The title of this
short cycle is a misleading, in that the music never suggests
folk song, although Van Hoof composed numerous arrangements
of Flemish folk songs. The “Volkston” rather refers to the
folk-like strophic structure of the poems. Lentestemming (“A
Mood of Spring”) is a fresh, sunny impression, and a real
little gem. In De Crans es uutghehanghen (“The
Garland has been hung”), the modally inflected music perfectly
reflects the archaic text. This beautiful song is – as far
as I am concerned – another little gem, along with Lentestemming and
the much later Nanoen in huis (“Afternoon at
Home”), a beautiful lullaby composed in 1946.
Van
Hoof composed three short operas. Meivuur (“Fire
of May”), his second opera, described as a two-act pastoral
play by the composer, was composed between 1913 and 1915,
while the scoring was completed in 1916. Because of World
War I, the premiered was postponed until January 1924. He
made an orchestral suite using material from the first act,
and the three sections play without a break: Angelus (an
atmospheric evocation of dusk, with bells peeling in the
distance), Kindertonelen (“Children’s Scenes”, a lively
dance-like section) and Stoet (“Cortège”, ending with
a joyous dance around the Maypole).
He
wrote only four fairly short concertante pieces, and the
most unusual of them is the Divertimento for Trombone
and Orchestra completed in 1935. This short piece
falls into two neatly contrasting sections played without
a break: a lyrical Moderato exploiting the singing
quality of the trombone, and a Scherzo calling for
virtuosity and ending in jollity.
The
major work in this generously filled release is undoubtedly
the Symphony No.3 in E flatmajor composed
between 1944 and 1945, a rather difficult period for Van
Hoof. In 1942 he was appointed director of the Royal Flemish
Conservatory in Antwerp. Because of his overtly nationalistic
feelings, some suspected that his appointment was fostered
by the German occupying authorities, which it was not. Nevertheless
he lost his job at the liberation. The first performance
of his Third Symphony in 1949 came as some sort of rehabilitation
for the composer. This said, the Third Symphony as well as
the Second Symphony of 1941, may be said to reflect the composer’s
feelings about war, although both are essentially abstract
pieces. The first movement, opening with an imposing theme
on which the entire movement is built, is a fine example
of “monothematic” thinking, although the movement as such
cannot be described as a theme and variations. The heart
of the symphony lies in the sorrowful, doom-laden slow movement
(Tempo di marcia Funebre), the music of which speaks
for itself. It opens with a sombre slow march theme played
by trombones and tuba underpinned by timpani, side drum and
pizzicati in the cellos and basses - one may be reminded
of Holst. The music gets considerable momentum before dying
away as it began. The following Scherzo fiercely relieves
the accumulated tension. The fourth movement is based on
a forceful main theme derived from the first theme of the
opening movement and is cast in a loose rondo form with a
ritornello derived from the second theme of the preceding
Scherzo. The interplay between the various themes of the
finale unfolds in sometimes unexpected directions. The coda
is decidedly assertive.
I
have only praise for these performances, which are all very
fine. Ann De Renais sings beautifully throughout, and the
Hungarian orchestra works wonders in music that must have
been quite unfamiliar to them. Recording and production are
excellent too.
As
already mentioned earlier in this review, Van Hoof’s music
is firmly anchored in Post-Romantic aesthetics; and anyone
enjoying warmly lyrical, richly melodic Romantic music will
find much to enjoy here.
Hubert Culot
Jef van Hoof’s symphonies
on discs:
Symphonies No.1 and No.4
- Phaedra 92013
Symphony No.2 - Marco
Polo 8.225101
Symphonies No.5 and No.6 - Phaedra
92044
Reviews
from previous months Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the
discs reviewed. details We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin
Board
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to
which you refer.