This DVD is short at just 55 minutes, and
there are no ‘extras’ at all. So it’s not particularly good
value, retailing as it does at around £13.00 in the UK. That
said, it is entertaining and informative, with strong performances
of some of the best songs from Leonard Bernstein’s ‘New York’ musicals, On
the Town, Wonderful Town and West Side Story. There
is also some superb, if slightly tantalising, archive material,
and some distinguished ‘talking heads’ to give personal witness
accounts and historical/critical perspective. These include
Humphrey Burton, the author of the principal biography of
the composer so far, music critic Jonathan Schwartz, producer
Harold Prince, and the conductor of the music on the DVD,
Eric Stern.
There are some irritating moments; after
the opening ensemble, New York, New York from On the
Town, we have one of those embarrassing ‘spontaneous’ scenes,
as singers get together in Mandy Patinkin’s flat - he’s one
of the singers - to rehearse their numbers. Very ‘grass
roots’ as one of them slightly mystifyingly describes it! And
then there’s the mandatory ‘back of the taxi’ interview,
which has become another cliché. It seeks to impart a sense
of urgency and gravitas to the interviewee’s apparently impromptu
thoughts, but just comes over as pretentious.
The singers are good, though. Some were
well known to me, such as Dawn Upshaw and Audra McDonald;
but the others were new, though I’m certain they’re all distinguished
US stage performers. The women are all outstanding, particularly
Judy Blazer, whose tracks are the highlights of the set for
me. She also has a fabulously expressive face, with huge,
beautiful eyes. Her version of one of Bernstein’s loveliest
songs, Story of my Life from Wonderful Town,
is really moving, and she talks interestingly about its content
too. Even so, why do directors feel the need to introduce
voice-overs in the middle of a song like this? It’s so insensitive,
when the music is ultimately the subject matter of the film.
Donna Murphy is splendid too, if not quite
so compelling as Blazer. Audra MacDonald sings two of Maria’s
numbers from West Side Story, One Hand, One Heart and Tonight,
but confusingly with two different Tonys, Richard Muenz in
the first and Mandy Patinkin in the second. Not to worry;
McDonald is stunning, surprisingly saying in interview that
she doesn’t expect to get asked to sing Maria on the stage. Yes,
she’s an African American, and Maria is supposed to be Puerto
Rican; but that really shouldn’t matter a great deal, and
I for one would love to see her in the part. For now, we
shall have to make do with these two ‘appetisers’.
Dawn Upshaw is a fine artist, and she brings
a sense of authority to everything she does. However, I
don’t particularly enjoy her version of Lonely Town from On
the Town. It’s a powerfully emotional song, but she
seems to rather overcook it. More likely, it just doesn’t
really suit her - it is a man’s song in the show anyway.
Talking of men, the two guys on this film
are less impressive than their ladies. Richard Muenz (a
baritone) sings well enough, but is a little wooden, while
Mandy Patinkin is a good stylist but has an unattractively
soppy vocal tone for the gentler numbers, such as Some
Other Time from On the Town or One hand, One
Heart, where he partners McDonald, but is outshone by
her. I will commend, however, his lively version of that
brilliant number Wrong Note Rag.
Personally, then, I’m thrilled at having
been introduced to the work of Judy Blazer, an exceptional
talent. And for aficionados of the Broadway stage, this
will be an enjoyable enough package, though most will eventually,
I imagine, tire of the overwhelmingly reverential tone.
Gwyn Parry-Jones
BUY NOW
AmazonUK
(PAL, Region 2)
AmazonUS (NTSC, Kultur Video)
Dawn Upshaw;
Mandy Patinkin; Donna Murphy; Audra McDonald; Judy Blazer;
Richard Muenz; 
[55:00] 
