Between the wars, Gaubert 
                was at the epicentre of French musical 
                life, professor of flute at the Paris 
                Conservatoire and principal conductor 
                of both the Paris Opéra and the 
                Société des Concerts. 
                As a composer, Gaubert’s reputation 
                is far less central. An assimilator 
                rather than an innovator, his charming 
                music is redolent of the world of Franck, 
                Ravel and Debussy. As a flautist by 
                training, the flute features heavily 
                in Gaubert’s oeuvre and his fourteen 
                works for flute and piano remain some 
                of his best known works. 
              
 
              
This disc is promised 
                as Volume 1 of his complete works for 
                flute and piano. For this first volume, 
                flautist Fenwick Smith and pianist Sally 
                Pinkas are joined by a number of other 
                artists to perform a group of Gaubert’s 
                flute-centred chamber works. In addition 
                Smith and Pinkas perform two of Gaubert’s 
                flute and piano works. 
              
 
              
The disc opens with 
                the short Madrigal for flute 
                and piano, an example of one the charming 
                miniatures at which Gaubert excelled. 
                The Trois Aquarelles are the 
                first of Gaubert’s trios for flute, 
                cello and piano – each movement a delicately 
                etched tone-picture (Par un clair 
                Matin; Soir d’automne; Sérénade). 
                The last movement evokes echoes of the 
                Middle East. Fenwick Smith has an attractive 
                warm tone and Pinkas is a responsive 
                accompanist. Between them they make 
                a fine case for these works, seeming 
                to play them from love. Joined by Andrew 
                Pearce on cello, for the trio, the three 
                of them make a fine ensemble. 
              
 
              
The Divertissement 
                Grèc expands on the traditional 
                coupling of flute and harp by adding 
                a second flute. Both flautists (Jacques 
                Zoon and Fenwick Smith) play on wooden 
                flutes, adding to the atmosphere in 
                this lovely little piece. The song, 
                Soir Païen is the only song 
                on the disc. Charmingly sung by Jayne 
                West, it made me wish that more vocal 
                works had been included. 
              
 
              
The Tarantelle 
                for flute, oboe and piano, was Gaubert’s 
                first published piece and it is dedicated 
                to Gaubert’s flute professor, Paul Taffanel. 
                For this trio, Smith and Pinkas are 
                joined by the oboe of John Ferrillo. 
              
 
              
Another trio, for flute, 
                violin and piano, follows. Médailles 
                Antiques comprises a pair of neo-classically 
                inspired tone pictures (Nymphes à 
                la fontaine and Danses) with 
                some very Ravel-inspired moments. The 
                final piece on the disc is the most 
                substantial: the Suite for flute 
                and piano. The four movements of this 
                work mix neo-classical images with further 
                exotic, middle-eastern moments. 
              
 
              
These works are all 
                captivatingly charming and are delightfully 
                played by Smith, Pinkas and their friends. 
                No-one would claim Gaubert for a lost 
                genius of French music, but his undoubtedly 
                civilised talent is work exploring. 
                I cannot help feeling though, that if 
                this disc had been called Soirs Païens 
                – Romantic chamber music by Philippe 
                Gaubert rather than the prosaic 
                ‘Complete Works for Flute – I’, it might 
                have tempted more people to explore 
                Gaubert’s world. 
              
 
              
Robert Hugill 
                
              
see also review 
                by Colin Touchin