These days the choice
of compact discs celebrating the festive
season is vast. So where does one start?
I would suggest that in the case of
choral music the choice is likely to
come down to quality of performance
versus repertoire. There are numerous
discs available by some our finest choral
groups, some of which explore contemporary
or more unfamiliar musical territory.
There is even greater choice if looking
for something along more traditional
lines, including recreations of the
Festival of Lessons and Carols by the
Choir of Kings College, Cambridge and
others.
In this particular
case the Truro Cathedral Choir have
clearly tried to provide a sensible
balance between the well known and the
deserving, with perennial favourites
nestling alongside what for some may
well be new discoveries. Herbert Howells’
gem, Here is the little door
is a welcome inclusion but what a shame
that room could not be found for the
even more beautiful Sing Lullaby.
The touching simplicity of Britten’s
gently rocking New Year Carol
is equally enjoyable although the decision
to include John Tavener’s widely recorded
The Lamb, could be considered
unnecessary given the quality of numerous
recordings that exist elsewhere. Like
the Howells, Warlock’s Bethlehem
Down is a beautiful creation and
I particularly enjoyed Warlock’s lesser-known
Benedicamus Domino, worlds apart
in its boisterous good spirits.
A number of the arrangements
are also worthy of mention, amongst
them Philip Ledger’s treatment of the
Sussex Carol, written for King’s
College Cambridge and complete with
resplendent organ accompaniment. An
amusing version of I saw three ships
by Philip Marshall contrasts with Stephen
Jackson’s imaginative and highly effective
Noël nouvelet. Simon Morley’s
lush harmonisation of Silent Night
gives the well-known tune a slightly
more popular feel than is normal and
is sung with feeling by the Truro choristers.
Christopher Thomas