It is not necessary to add to the vast amount of scholarship
on the organ music of J.S. Bach. It would be pointless of me to try
to discuss, criticise or analyse the seven works presented on this disc.
No comments from me are needed about the life and work of the composer.
This recording by Danacord has the expected high quality
and the performance by Hans Helmut Tillmanns is immaculate and moving
to say the least.
However there are two key points about this disk that
make it an excellent purchase. Firstly the varied programme and secondly
the fact that this programme is played on three different organs. As
a package it makes a fine introduction to the organ music of the master
- but also it is an accomplished recital which most Bach aficionados
will want to add to their large collections!
I had not heard any recordings by Dr Tillmanns before
reviewing this CD. However, his is a name that is familiar to me through
browsing in CD shops. And this is hardly surprising. Dr Tillmanns has
some thirty discs to his credit. His repertoire extends across the entire
gamut of the instrument - from renaissance to the present. He has involved
himself in the recording and production of music for radio and television.
Not being content with this activity he also teaches at the Academy
in Remscheid in Germany.
I have a few minor concerns about this disc. Firstly
the programme notes are not helpful. Danacord, possibly correctly, assume
that organ buffs will know the repertoire and do not need copious analysis.
Secondly there is a preponderance of the keys of C major and e minor
in this recording. This is not a big problem in itself but perhaps one
of the big works in an unrelated key may have added a little something
to the programme!
The sleeve notes give the organ specification for all
three instruments. However only one, the Klausing organ allows us to
know the date of construction. I understand the Hammer organ at Eschwege
was built in 1966, but this is only hearsay.
All three organs are bright in their registrations
and are ideally suited for music of this era - full of mixtures and
mutations. Certainly these organs would not be appropriate for Messiaen,
Widor or Basil Harwood.
Altogether a good selection of Bach's organ music -
interesting and impressive works but avoiding the temptation to include
any pot-boilers for the sake of selling CDs.
A fine introduction to the work of J.S.B: well played,
great sound and nicely presented.
John France
Hans Helmut Tillmanns,
organ