This collection is a treasure marred only by
the inadequate notes (yes here’s another of my gripes about bargain
reissues inadequacies). The 16-page, three-language booklet concentrates
only on Vengerov’s recording in Tel Aviv – not even giving a clear
indication of its date! There are no notes to speak of on any
of the pieces only inane remarks about Vengerov’s clothing and
the order in which they chose to record the works. I had always
imagined that bargain issues would be of special appeal to those
new to music. They would learn precious little buying this set
which is a great pity because these are fine performances.
There are many recordings in the catalogue of
the Paganini violin concertos with the Accardo/Dutoit six-CD set
of all six plus smaller works on DG 463 754-2 being particularly
highly regarded. In this early 1990s recording Mehta and Vengerov
approach the First Concerto with commendable bravura. It is brilliantly
and imaginatively played and Vengerov dashes off the showpiece
passages with dazzling fireworks while rendering heartfelt readings
of the more romantically tender passages.
Likewise Vengerov displays impressive virtuosity
and panache in the remaining works that have very definite Spanish
colourings: the two deservedly popular Saint-Saëns pieces
and the devilishly difficult Carmen Fantasie specially composed
by Franz Waxman (better known as a very successful film composer)
for Heifetz.
Excitement and romance - a highly recommended
bargain reissue
Ian Lace
Israel Philharmonic Orchestra/Zubin
Mehta