Classical Editor: Rob Barnett                               Founder Len Mullenger:

The Martyr of Antioch

Catherine Foster (sop); Gillian Knight (contr.);
Stephen Brown (ten.); Gareth Jones (bar.);
Stephen Godward (bass); Clive Woods (organ);
Northern Chamber Orchestra and Sullivan Chorus
Conducted by Richard Balcombe
Recording of performance at Gilbert and Sullivan Festival, Buxton, August 2000
SYMPOSIUM 1289 [78.41]
Crotchet   AmazonUK   AmazonUS

The Martyr of Antioch is a 'Sacred Musical Drama' composed for and first performed at the Leeds Triennial Musical Festival in October 1880. It was conducted by Sullivan himself, who had just been appointed Musical Director of the Festival, which position he held until his death. The words were taken from the drama of the same name by the Rev. H.. H.. Milman, with changes by W. S. Gilbert.

The work itself is very enjoyable and most of it is written in a style more akin to his operettas than to the religious style of Sullivan's cantatas. The reviews of the original performance comment that Sullivan seemed more interested in the songs and rites of the pagan rather than in the Christian aspect; this seems fair comment; much of the work is light and lyrical rather than emphasising the drama suggested by the title.

All the soloists sing well, the only criticism is that neither of the two ladies enunciate their words in a way which allows easy comprehension (this is a pity, because one of Sullivan's great strengths is the ability to write songs which are both lyrical and perfectly matched to the English language). The orchestral playing and choral singing are both excellent and Richard Balcombe conducts with style and vigour.

The performance and recording were sponsored by the Sir Arthur Sullivan Society and by the International Gilbert and Sullivan Festival. The result proves that the revival was well worth while. Thanks to support by Professor George W. Hilton, a new set of band parts is now available, and further performances will be possible (by contacting the Society).

The descriptive booklet is graced by a photograph of Sullivan together with the soloists and orchestra at the original performance. There is a fascinating account by Selwyn Tillet relating to the original performance and the events leading up to it. A copy of Sullivan's preface to the work is also included but unfortunately something has gone wrong with the typesetting and the text is mangled. A copy of the libretto or even a summary description of the individual numbers would have helped tremendously.

So far as the recording is concerned this is excellent and, although described as a recording of a public performance, no audience noises or applause is present to prevent enjoyment.

Overall, the disc is most enjoyable and can be recommended to anyone who has enjoyed the Sullivan operas or enjoys not too solemn Choral music.

Arthur Baker.

Return to Index

Reviews from previous months
We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin Board.  Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to which you refer.This is the only part of MusicWeb for which you will have to register.

You can purchase CDs, tickets and musician's accessories and Save around 22% with these retailers: