Classical Editor: Rob Barnett


Music Webmaster
Len Mullenger: Len@musicweb-international.com


Reviews from other months
LUDOLF NIELSEN Symphony No. 1 in B minor Op. 3 (1902-3) From the Mountains - Symphonic Suite Op. 8 (1903-5) Danish PO/Frank Cramer. MARCO POLO - DA CAPO 8.224093 [71:25]

 


Crotchet




Ludolf Nielsen will predictably labour under the great shadow of his illustrious namesake. To my knowledge his second symphony (CPO) is perhaps his strongest suit. The big (almost 45 mins) four movement first symphony rises in Brahms and ascends towards Wagner's Siegfried idyll. The trumpets at 9.35 play a lovely unwinding melody but the movement, rather like the other three, is far too long for its material. The second movement has tranquillity and is slightly maudlin. Nice consistent mood music without any oppressively impressive moments to break the spell. The third movement is a very countrified dance and by itself might made a lollipop. The finale crashes in with a continuation of the dance festival. The music is in the same league as the lesser known symphonies of Saint-Saens, Bizet and Goldmark (whose Rustic Wedding Symphony is a better piece than this).

With the suite we are in Glazunov territory; not so much the style but the concentration of the ideas. There is nothing here terribly striking although there are some striking Elgarian passages in the first movement (Castle Ruin). In the second The Shepherd the charming music conjures a walk through the fields with birds singing. The third uses a hymn tune to picture The Mountain Chapel and the finale is jolly and chipper, all gurgling woodwind and village dancing. There is a momentary touch of Tchaikovsky in this.

Charming and undemandingly picturesque music are valuable but expect to have this on in the background rather than commanding your attention continuously. Recommended accordingly.

Reviewer

Rob Barnett

Reviewer

Rob Barnett

Return to Index