As I listened to the opening bars of this magnificent performance of
Elgars In the South, I was continually asking myself
why did Decca leave this true Elgarian testament unissued for over five decades.
There is a certain ebullient warmth about Boyd Neels bold and romantic
performance that eluded those before and after him, excepting perhaps those
historic records the composer himself made. I make no bones about this,
Alassio is my favorite Elgarian work, and nothing written from that
majestic pen comes so close to the Mediterranean warmth and joie de vivre
that positively implodes the score.
Dutton have conveniently split the work into four distinct sections, the
one at fig. 34 is slightly difficult to conceive but the music does retain
the natural edge. Deccas fabled FFRR engineering was at the forefront
and one can imagine the hit this recording would have made with its
life-breathing violin playing and the various woodwind instrument solos
permeating the vast Italian canvas. Boyd Neel is close to Sir Yehudi
Menuhins excellent Tring account, but that suffers from some over gorging
in the slower pieces.
Here the various passages of the work are fused together with a remarkable
sense of elan and most of all, a humanity that eludes most conductors. There
is no need to make any excuses for the sound, as I said earlier this is
sensational Decca at its brilliant best. If Sir Malcolm Sargents recording
of the Enigma Variations is similarly full rounded and
brilliant, one must take issue with him for some interpretative points that
are slightly controversial. First of all, the performance sounds like a rushed
job from the outset with the beautiful Theme lacking in mystery at the swift
tempo.
However there are definitely advantages to be had especially in the genial
Ysobel and Troyte, both models of Elgarian picture
painting. Nimrod is a fleeting glimpse from a motor bus; here
one almost weeps for the pompous majesty that is to be found in Elgars
unsurpassable account. Still, all in all, Sargents performance is
serviceable, but with such a plethora of versions available, he is definitely
hard pressed to match the best. The recording is a souvenir of the fantastic
National Symphony Orchestra at their brilliant best, one must not forget
that there were artists of the like of Dennis Brain in its ranks.
The enticing filler to the original 78rpm set of Enigma was the
swaggering Pomp and Circumstance March No. 5, this is an ideal and
fascinating addendum to the 1953 Decca recordings of Nos. 1 & 4 now available
on Beulah (1PD13). Malcolm Walker tells us that the original dates of the
actual sessions do not survive, thus continually enhancing the enticing nature
of this release. Boyd Neels Chansons are earlier September
1945 recordings, and in them one can feel the authentic touch that the String
Orchestra was able to give to British music. In fact, the soft and silky
sweet nature of this salon music has rarely sounded better.
Dutton have chosen to end the compilation with an early, rare pressing of
the young Sir Charles Groves in two songs from The Starlight
Express. Henry Cummings clearly enunciated and deeply felt renderings
are given sympathetic accompaniments by this much missed character who was
to imprint such a firm name on Elgars music in the years to come. A
treasure trove of a disc, with its authentic front cover featuring
one of those long lost Decca 78s and as usual, superbly remastered
by Michael Dutton. I still hear those magnificent bars of In the
South ringing in my ears!
Reviewer
Gerald Fenech
Performance:
Sound: