Classical Editor: Rob Barnett


Music Webmaster
Len Mullenger: Len@musicweb.uk.net


Reviews from other months
MOZART: Overture: 'Die Zauberflote'. Concerto for Flute and Harp, Serenade No. 2, Symphony No. 27.    René Le Roy, Lili Laskine, Dennis Brain, Royal Philharmonic Orchestra Sir Thomas Beecham The RPO Legacy Volume 4 Dutton Labs CDLX7039 74m ADD (Rec. 1947-49).

 


Crotchet



REFINED MOZARTIAN TREASURE

 

This is a peach of a disc. After reading a recent hot debate in the pages of 'Gramophone' regarding Beecham's Mozart credentials, I was inclined to refer doubters along to this disc for an experience that will not easily be forgotten. As a compendium of impeccable RPO playing, it is indispensable, also as a souvenir of Dennis Brain's unmatched horn halloos, surely his death can be counted as one of the supreme musical tragedies of the century. Beecham's flair and vivacious wit are underlined in this brisk and breezy reading of 'Die Zauberflote'.

Comparing it with his earlier 30's account with the LPO, I detected much greater presence and of course the sound is greatly improved in this recording. It is a pity that EMI never deemed it fit to be reissued so let's thank God for Dutton! The Concerto for Flute and Harp is perhaps just a little more well-known. This cheerfully breezy 1948 version brings together two exquisite French soloists of whom I was ignorant although it would be pertinent to set the reader's mind at rest that this is playing of the highest order throughout.

René Le Roy's charmingly seductive flute playing compliments Laskine's cultured and mannered harp, it is indeed a marriage made in paradise! Beecham's magic way with this, one of Mozart's most delicate works comes off with quite seductive wizardry especially in that timeless Adagio. More tricks are to be found in the hilarious romp that Dennis Brain and Beecham make out of the rarely heard Divertimento No. 2. This hugely entertaining work is given a highly characterful reading throughout and Dennis Brain's horn solos are simply out of this world.

As if this was not enough, Dutton choose to conclude the disc with a hilarious rendering of the short Symphony No. 27. Beecham had a special affection for the late Mozart symphonies but he still shows himself a dab hand even in this relatively early style. Indeed this recording brings almost half of the Mozart canon available under his baton. The playing is virtuosic and refined although the rusty recording does not help matters, one almost wonders where EMI's engineering was almost five years after 'ffrr'. As usual notes and presentation are impeccably authentic and I await Volume 5 of this classic RPO legacy with huge anticipation.

 Reviewer

Gerald Fenech

Performance:



Sound:

 Reviewer

Gerald Fenech

Performance:



Sound:

Return to Index