Manuel da FALLA (1876-1946)
The Three-cornered Hat (1919) [37.40]
El amor brujo (1915) [24.14]
Colette Boky (soprano: Hat)
Huguette Tourangeau (mezzo: Brujo)
Montreal Symphony Orchestra/Charles Dutoit
rec. St Eustache, Montreal, July 1981
DECCA PRESTO CD 410008-2 [61.54]
This was one of the very first CDs ever issued by Decca, and
it was provided by their star team of Charles Dutoit at the head of his Montreal
Symphony Orchestra. The Three-cornered Hat, Falla’s score written for
Diaghilev and his Russian Ballet, had for many years been a staple showpiece
for international orchestras. Decca already had a long-established analogue
recording in their catalogue featuring Ernest
Ansermet and his Suisse Romande players but the Swiss orchestra, always
fallible, were no match for Dutoit’s superbly disciplined forces. The
digital recording effectively superseded Ansermet as a flagship of the new
Decca CD listings. It remains even today, over thirty years later, a formidable
achievement and one of the best recordings of the score ever made.
However in their early CDs Decca made one fatal mistake, one that is unfortunately
faithfully reproduced in this Presto re-mastering of the original disc. They
completely failed to take advantage of one essential difference between LPs
and CDs: that while in the older format providing separate tracks for individual
sections of a continuous score involved the always risky procedure of placing
down a pickup arm directly onto a vinyl surface, and quite possibly scratching
it in the process, the movement of a laser over the disc obviated any such
possible damage. Accordingly, in a number of their early CDs, no track breaks
at all were provided where the music was continuous or semi-continuous. This
means that on this disc anyone wanting to hear just The Miller’s Dance
from the full-length ballet, or the Fire Dance from El amor brujo, has no
choice but to locate the appropriate track and then fast-forward through the
music to find the relevant point where they wish to begin listening. There
are just three tracks on this CD: two for The Three-cornered Hat, and one
for the shorter work.
In their reissues of these early CD recordings, Decca have usually taken the
opportunity to insert relevant cues at such points; but anyone purchasing
this reissue should be aware that they may not be able with ease to locate
a favourite movement. Nor are these individual movements listed with an indication
of timing - although full texts and translations are provided. All of this
is a pity, because the performances themselves are excellent. Huguette Tourangeau
is a full-throated gipsy girl in El amor brujo, much more musically effective
than the very ‘ethnic’ Ginesa Ortega who took on the role in a
video production also conducted by Dutoit which I reviewed
for this site last year. Colette Boky in the longer ballet has less to do,
but does that little very well and is properly distanced. The choral shouts
of “Olé!” in the introduction to the score are, I presume, supplied
by members of the orchestra. The church acoustic may slightly blur the incisiveness
of the well-pointed rhythms, but the microphones pick up everything of importance.
The playing under Dutoit is simply marvellous, highlighting not just the rhythms
but also the impressionist washes of delicate sound that Falla writes in such
sections as the Neighbours’ Dance at the beginning of Part Two. The
solo bassoon in The Three-cornered Hat is well and characterfully played (and
separately credited) by Richard Hoenicht, but he is allowed to make a cut
of four bars in Part Two which may or may not have been authorised by the
composer; it is made in a number of other recordings.
Of the rival versions in the CD catalogue, Ansermet’s recording of the
two scores comes coupled with an additional bonus in the form of the Spanish
Dance from La vida breve. Ansermet had conducted the first performance of
The Three-cornered Hat, but his recordings – as I have observed –
suffered from some fallibility in the playing. A two CD EMI box conducted
by Rafael Frühbeck de Burgos comes with the complete La vida breve and a number
of smaller works (review
review),
but although the playing is more secure the recordings from the 1960s sound
rather dated now. These same Dutoit performances have also been reissued by
Decca as part of a 2 CD collection entitled “The essential Falla”
(review)
which excludes La vida breve but does include Nights in the gardens of Spain,
omitted by EMI Classics. There are in all 25 recordings currently listed on
Archiv of The Three-cornered Hat, but only two which offer this two-ballet
coupling on a single disc. One of these is a real antique with the Vienna
Symphony Orchestra under Edouard van Remoortel, which hardly bears comparison
with Dutoit in terms of either sound or playing. The other is a version now
available at bargain price on Regis conducted by Eduardo Mata, which I have
not heard but was highly regarded in some quarters when originally issued
on RCA (review).
Nonetheless, and despite the lack of individual tracks, the restoration of
this disc to the catalogue from Presto Classical is most welcome.
Paul Corfield Godfrey
|
Support us financially by purchasing
this from
|
 |