Dutch mezzo-soprano Christianne Stotijn has become one of the finest
Lieder performers on the international stage and I felt I ought to
comment on this album, released on Onyx back in 2006. In this collection of
fifteen Mahler
Lieder Christianne Stotijn has the valued
accompaniment Julius Drake.
Mahler’s association with
Lieder is different to that of the best
known
Lieder composers such as Schubert, Schumann, Wolf. He
composed only a small number of works in the genre; which were the
Drei
Lieder for tenor and piano (1880), the
Lieder und Gesänge the
collection of fourteen songs in three volumes with piano accompaniment
(1880/89) and the
Lieder eines fahrenden Gesellen (
Songs of a
Travelling Journeyman) for voice with piano (1883/85), often translated
as
Songs of a Wayfarer. Mahler’s other compositions for the voice
were generally written directly for orchestral accompaniment rather than for
the piano:
Des Knaben Wunderhorn (
The Youth’s Magic Horn)
a collection of settings of anonymous German folk-poetry (1888-1901),
Kindertotenlieder (
Songs on the Death of Children)
(1901-04), 5 orchestral songs
Rückert-Lieder (1901-02) and the song
cycle-symphony
Das Lied von der Erde (
The Song of the
Earth).
The first two songs chosen by Stotijn
Frühlingsmorgen (
Spring
Morning) and
Erinnerung (
Memory) are also the first
two songs from the first volume of
Lieder und Gesänge. These songs
are settings of texts by the German poet Richard von Volkmann under his pen
name of Richard Leander. The next eleven appear to be taken
ad hoc
from the various volumes of the
Des Knaben Wunderhorn collection.
The final two songs
Um Mitternacht (
At midnight) and
Ich bin der Welt abhanden gekommen (
I have lost touch with the
world) form part of the five songs of the
Rückert-Lieder -
settings of the German poet Friedrich Rückert.
The first song on the release
Frühlingsmorgen (
Spring
Morning) sounds like a gentle lullaby with Stotijn’s calm and
restrained singing.
Erinnerung (
Memory) is a love-song and
it is clear that the liaison is not running smoothly as there is an
unsettling and agitated undercurrent here. I was disappointed with Stotijn’s
uncomfortable screeching through the high notes between points 1:21-1:26;
which came as quite a shock.
Zu Strassburg auf der Schanz (
On
the ramparts of Strasburg) is a marching song complete with bugle-like
effects from Drake’s piano. Here it seems a young soldier is pleading to be
spared the bullet for deserting his post which Stotijn interprets with
poignancy and rapt concentration. The
Der Schildwache Nachtlied
(
The Sentinel’s Night Song) sounds like another marching-song with
a soldier on duty at midnight. Here Stotijn sings sturdily and expressively.
I was impressed with her gentle and tender interpretation of the boy’s love
for an Innkeeper's daughter in
Wo die schönen Trompeten
blasen (
Where the shining trumpets blow). The hurt of
separation and bidding farewell is impressively portrayed in
Scheiden
und Meiden (
Parting is sorrow). Her mid-register is displayed
here to great effect. She is buoyant and jolly in the
Rheinlegendchen (
Rhine Legend) and in
Wer hat dies
Liedlein erdacht? (
Who thought up this little song?) we hear
an excitable and brisk interpretation.
Stotijn provides an outstanding and enthralling performance of the rather
gloomy character of
Ich ging mit lust durch einen grünen Wald
(
I walked with joy through a green forest). The song
Nicht
Wiedersehen! (
Never to meet again!) is about death before its
time and the mezzo beautifully communicates the sorrowful mood through her
impeccably mellow mid-register. In
Des Antonius von Padua
Fischpredigt (
St. Anthony of Padua’s sermon to the fish) one
is struck by the magnificence of the extended theme from the
Wunderhorn setting that Mahler also employed in the
Symphony
No. 2 ‘
Resurrection’. In awesome voice here Stotijn brings the
score to life with jaunty, light-hearted singing. The title song, the
memorable and highly moving
Urlicht (
Primeval light), is
another
Wunderhorn setting used in the ‘
Resurrection’
Symphony. Stotijn imparts in this dark and reflective score just
the right amount of sadness and poignancy. In
Das Irdische Leben
(
Earthly life) she easily convinces you of anguish contained in the
bitterness and misfortune of this setting. The heart-felt sadness of the
Rückert setting
Um Mitternacht (
At midnight), a
true masterwork of the genre, is performed with grave beauty and genuine
sensitivity. The final work of the album is the sorrowful and shimmering
Rückert setting
Ich bin der Welt abhanden gekommen - another Mahler
masterpiece with Stotijn conveying an abundance of emotion and regret.
Throughout one cannot help but be impressed by Stotijn’s engagingly
natural warmth and mellow timbre. Helped by crystal clear diction her
personality and expressiveness makes a vivid impression. This stunning
Lieder recital has only one ineffectual episode of control with the
song
Erinnerung (
Memory) that rather soured the
setting.
Naturally the singer takes centre-stage in this
Lieder recital
but the piano accompaniment from Julius Drake is peerless. The sound team
have provided vividly clear and well balanced sonics. It is good to see Onyx
providing full German texts with English translations in the booklet.
Michael Cookson
Track-Listing
1. Frühlingsmorgen (Spring Morning) (c.1880) [2.03]
2. Erinnerung (Memory) (c. 1880) [2.49]
3. Zu Strassburg auf der Schanz (On the ramparts of Strasburg) (c.1890)
[4.15]
4. Der Schildwache Nachtlied (The Sentinel’s Night Song) (1892) [6.25]
5. Wo die schönen Trompeten blasen (Where the shining trumpets blow)
(1895) [7.21]
6. Scheiden und Meiden (Parting is sorrow) (c.1890) [2.42]
7. Rheinlegendchen (Rhine Legend) (1893) [3.14]
8. Wer hat dies Liedlein erdacht? (Who thought up this little song?)
(1892) [2.11]
9. Ich ging mit lust durch einen grünen Wald (I walked with joy through a
green forest) (c.1889) [4.18]
10. Nicht Wiedersehen! (Never to meet again!) (c.1891) [4.59]
11. Des Antonius von Padua Fischpredigt (St. Anthony of Padua’s sermon to
the fish) (1893) [4.33]
12. Urlicht (Primeval light) (1892-94) [5.20]
13. Das Irdische Leben (Earthly life) (1893) [2.49]
14. Um Mitternacht (At midnight) (1901) [6.20]
15. Ich bin der Welt abhanden gekommen (I have lost touch with the world)
(1901) [6.34]
Previous review: Göran Forsling
