Valse-Impromptu, S213/R36 (1850-1852, rev. 1880) (arr. Jenő Hubay, 1858-1937) 
    [6:38]
    Grand duo concertant sur la Romance de M. Lafont ‘Le marin’, S128/R462 
    (1835) [15:30]
    rec. 3-4 March, 15-17 July, 5, 7-8 August 2013, Witold Lutosławski Concert 
    Studio of Polish Radio, Warsaw, Poland
    
 In Franz Liszt’s long career he wrote a great 
      deal of piano music, songs, choral and orchestral works but relatively little 
      chamber music. This new release is therefore especially welcome in introducing 
      some infrequently-heard music of the genre to a wider audience.
      
      The first track, the 
Duo Sonata based on Polish themes, was written 
      relatively early in the composer’s career. The work is, in fact, a 
      tribute to Chopin, who had made his Paris début in 1832 and, befriended 
      by Liszt, was gradually drawn into the latter’s social circle. The 
      four movements are based around Chopin’s Mazurka in C sharp minor, 
      Op. 6 No. 2, with an injection of other Polish material along the way. The 
      listener’s attention is first grabbed, and then maintained from the 
      very outset. 
Chopin’s original 
      theme is initially heard in the second movement, where it is treated in 
      theme and variations manner, which show moments of display from both performers. 
      The violin’s music tends to dominate the third movement, sometimes 
      lyrical, sometimes virtuosic, and culminates in a cadenza. A final Rondo 
      brings the work to a close with a typically grand Lisztian climax.
      
      The 
Epithalamium for the Wedding Celebration of Eduard Reményi 
      was written for the violinist’s marriage to Gizella Fay. Reményi, 
      who had chosen a Hungarian name rather than his original surname of Hoffmann, 
      had been involved in the Hungarian disturbances of 1848. He was forced to 
      take refuge abroad, where he joined the young Brahms in a concert tour that 
      took them to Weimar, where Liszt held court, and from whom Reményi received 
      great encouragement. Brahms, on the other hand, gained greater benefit from 
      meeting violinist, Joseph Joachim, and then the Schumanns. Liszt’s 
      musical wedding-present is a piece of elegant allure and ends with a short 
      violin cadenza, perhaps a hint of what might have been, had Liszt written 
      the violin concerto for Reményi that he had once intended.
      
      
Die drei Zigeuner (The Three Gypsies) was first a setting of a 
      poem by Lenau in which a weary traveller sees three gypsies resting in a 
      field, one playing the fiddle, one smoking and the third sleeping. It was 
      in fact Lenau’s ‘Faust’ which supplied the musical stimulus 
      for one of Liszt’s best-known piano solos – the Mephisto Waltz 
      No. 1. The Three Gypsies is suitably imbued with ‘Hungarian gypsy 
      style’, to which the violin is particularly well suited, with its 
      easy and natural penchant for varying moods within a composition, for example 
      from the meditative to the rhapsodic.
      
      The first of Liszt’s two 
Elegies heard next, was originally 
      a piano solo, with the explanatory title ‘Schlummerlied im Grabe’ 
      (Lullaby in the Grave). It was subsequently issued in various versions, 
      including the present one for violin and piano. As Keith Anderson, in the 
      concise but informative sleeve-note, points out, Liszt’s use of the 
      falling interval of a semitone instils the piece with appropriate melancholy, 
      save for a final glimmer of hope in the closing bars. The second 
Elegie 
      features a gently lyrical passage marked ‘dolcissimo amoroso’, 
      which concludes in a passionate climax, before finally subsiding.
      
      Hungarian violinist, Jenő Hubay, crafted an idiomatic piece of violinistic 
      invention with his arrangement of Liszt’s 
Valse-Impromptu, 
      an original piano solo first written in 1850-1852 and revised by the composer 
      in 1880. Hubay dedicated his demanding violin and piano version, published 
      in 1932, to American-born violinist and conductor, Yehudi Menuhin, who spent 
      most of his performing career in the UK, where he became a British citizen 
      in 1985.
      
      The closing work on the CD, Liszt’s 
Grand Duo concertant sur la 
      Romance de M. Lafont ‘Le marin’ was written in 1835, and 
      is based on a piece by French violinist Charles Philippe Lafont, who was 
      especially prolific in such ‘Romances’. Introductory passages 
      lead to the theme – itself a rather unassuming ‘Andantino’ 
      – after which follows a series of variations: the first for the violin, 
      and the second mainly for the piano, with pizzicato accompaniment from the 
      violin. The third sees both protagonists involved with some especially demanding 
      writing, ending with a violin cadenza. A suitably virtuosic ‘Tarentelle’ 
      leads to a martial conclusion, where no concessions are made for either 
      player.
      
      Even if this release were on a mid-to-full-price label, the superb quality 
      of the playing, instrumental balance, real flair for, and affinity with 
      the music itself would make it a desirable addition to any collection. Couple 
      this with Naxos’s first-rate recording and budget price, and it surely 
      makes it irresistible, whether you’re interested in expanding your 
      knowledge of Liszt’s chamber-music output, or you’re just a 
      fan of the ever-popular combination of violin and piano. Very good listening, 
      either way.
      
 
       
      Philip R Buttall