Piano sonata no.2 in g sharp minor op.19 'Fantasy Sonata' (1897) [12:33]
    
    rec. no details given
 For her solo CD debut disc Ukrainian pianist Violina 
      Petrychenko has chosen piano works by Scriabin and fellow Ukrainian Viktor 
      Kosenko. Kosenko remains little known or recorded though the declared world 
      première recording of his second piano sonata is in fact erroneous 
      since its debut on disc was by another Ukrainian pianist Natalya Shkoda 
      on 
Centaur 
      Records CRS 3109 back in 2011 on which all three of his piano sonatas 
      are presented. That said this disc is interesting because of the similarities 
      between the two composers: one born in Moscow, the other in St Petersburg, 
      both of them admirers of Chopin, Kosenko also of Scriabin, and both of them 
      dying at tragically young ages robbing us of so much more that they might 
      have written.
       
      Petrychenko’s programme is one that encourages comparisons with her 
      playing similar works by each composer. The otherworldliness that characterises 
      Scriabin’s music is immediately apparent in the first of the 
2 
      Poèmes op.32. Its simple lines transport the listener away from 
      the cares of the world while the second is much more powerful. The first 
      of Kosenko’s two poems also embodies a dreamy quality with the second 
      again a more striking affair.
       
      We then have three mazurkas by each of them, both sets being their op. 3, 
      in which Chopin’s influence is marked. That said, each of them stamps 
      his own very different personality upon them even if Kosenko’s mazurkas 
      are especially Chopinesque. The latter recall an age well before that of 
      their composition.
       
      Scriabin’s two movement piano sonata, dramatic and dreamlike by turns, 
      is ‘classic’ Scriabin. Kosenko’s three movement work could 
      also be thought to come from the same stable if we were not told of its 
      composer’s identity. However, similar in nature though it may be to 
      his idol’s work, Kosenko’s sonata has an originality that would 
      surely have been further developed had he lived longer than his 42 years. 
      Its central slow movement is an extremely affecting song without words.
       
      The title of the disc — 
Slavic Nobility — refers to 
      the fact that both composers came from noble families. It also alludes to 
      the music which has a noble quality. I can take as much Scriabin as record 
      companies can throw at me and now I find that Kosenko’s music is just 
      as infectious. I’m hopeful we’ll have more such discs coming 
      our way. From what I’ve read there’s plenty more to explore 
      from this little known composer.
       
      Petrychenko who has made her home in Germany is perfectly at home with all 
      this music and plays it with both commitment and affection. The disc is 
      very well recorded.
       
      I counted three different spellings of Scriabin on this disc: Scriabin, 
      Scrjabin and Scriabin. The latter is the one ARS put against the track listings 
      but I prefer Scriabin.
       
      
Steve Arloff