This is an intriguing disc. It is not often that you hear world premières
of newly discovered music by such a well known and major composer as Fauré.
This is exactly what we have here.
These Vocalises date from between 1906 and 1916, when Fauré, as director
of the Paris Conservatoire, sought to rethink the way singing was taught. In
came the study of the Mélodie or French art-song supplanting second rate
grand-opera which had been the mainstay of teaching there for decades. As
part of this new emphasis, Fauré composed a series of Vocalises which would
be used as part of the sight-reading exams. These short pieces eventually
fell out of use some years after Fauré’s death and the scores were then
stored in the French National Archive. There they lay for over fifty years
before being edited by
Roy
Howat and Emily Kilpatrick for Peters Critical Edition of the composers
complete songs, which was published in 2013. So the question is raised: why
should these essentially vocal works be performed, especially in their
première recording? In his booklet notes, Roy Howat argues that these pieces
“were deliberately designed to test vocal technique to the limit …”, and
that they can be appreciated more comfortably on the trumpet. Whatever the
argument they work quite well on the trumpet. Yes, it would have been nice
to hear them in their original vocal edition, but in lieu of this, the
present recording makes an interesting introduction to the music. This is,
after all, only what normally happens to popular vocalises in the end.
The Vocalises are short and range from 0:24 to 2:23 in length but even in
the shortest a degree of dexterity is displayed that would tax any
performer, whether it be on the trumpet or the human voice. The music is by
one of the finest of all French composers of the art-song, and Fauré brings
to these short pieces all the skills that he employed in his songs. In this
respect the performance of Jonathan Freeman-Attwood is excellent as he
produces a subtle and pleasing tone. He is also well partnered by Roy Howat,
who shows that he is a fine accompanist as well as editor and essayist.
My only other question is: why fill the second half of the disc with
pieces taken from Freeman-Attwood’s previous discs? Surely some new
recordings of sympathetic works could have been included, or better still,
recordings of the vocalises performed by various vocalists. As it is the
second half of the disc, however well performed, is merely a sampler of what
has gone before. While it shows the skill of the performers, it hardly
endears anyone to those who have already bought the recordings.
Stuart Sillitoe
An interesting and well executed première performance.
Full Track-List
Gabriel FAURÉ
Lydia in F Major, Op. 4 2:00]
La beauté
Vocalise No. 9 [0:29]
Vocalise No. 15 [0:46]
Vocalise No. 16 [0:42]
Vocalise No. 12 [0:49]
Vocalise No. 1 [0:32]
L'envie
Vocalise No. 28 [2:23]
Vocalise No. 6 [0:46]
Vocalise No. 26 [1:02]
Vocalise No. 20 [1:34]
Vocalise No. 5 [0:43]
Vocalise No. 14 [0:39]
Vocalise No. 23 [0:53]
Vocalise No. 2 [0:41]
Vocalise No. 24 [1:16]
La cour
Appendix No. 3 [0:24]
Vocalise No. 7 [0:35]
Vocalise No. 17 [0:39]
Vocalise No. 13 [0:46]
Vocalise No. 25 [0:41]
Vocalise No. 21 [0:36]
Vocalise No. 22 [0:47]
La tendresse
Vocalise No. 8 [0:54]
Vocalise No. 4 [0:42]
Vocalise No. 11 [0:42]
Vocalise No. 18 [0:41]
Appendix No. 4 [0:41]
Les regrets
Vocalise No. 10 [0:52]
Vocalise No. 29 [1:33]
Vocalise No. 12 [0:39]
Vocalise No. 19 [0:40]
Appendix No. 7 [0:37]
Les souvenirs
Vocalise No. 27 [1:13]
Vocalise No. 3 [0:49]
Appendix No. 14 [0:40]
Appendix No. 15 [0:48]
Lydia in G Major, Op. 4 [2:00]
Emmanuel CHABRIER
5 Morceaux No. 1, Aubade [4:01]
10 Pièces pittoresques No. 7, Danse villageoise [3:36]
Camille SAINT-SAËNS
Cello Sonata No. 2 in F Major, Op. 123- III. Romanza. Poco adagio
[7:44]
Reynaldo HAHN
À Chloris [3:10]
Jean-Philippe RAMEAU
Naïs Suite: I. Overture [4:09]; III. Gavotte pour les zephyrs [1:05]
François COUPERIN
Messe pour les couvents Cromorne en taille [2:33]
Louis MARCHAND
Pièces d'orgue, Livre III - Grand Dialogue [6:01]
Gabriel FAURÉ
Violin Sonata No. 2 in E Minor, Op. 108 - I. Allegro non troppo [7:35]
