(Symphony No. 3) (2013) [34:32] (The Tidepools & the 
    Boy [6:14]; One Shore [10:13]; The Black Gondola [6:16]; Redemption [11:49])
    
  (2010) [9:10] (From the Sea [3:37]; The Falling 
    Star [1:36]; There Will Be Stars [3:57])
    
    Aram Barsamian (baritone), John St Marie (tenor), Kellee King, Lorraine Joy 
    Welling (sopranos)
     Pacific Chorale (symphony, Earth Song, There will be rest), John Alexander 
    Singers (The song within, Constellation, Flower)
    rec. Renée and Henry Segerstrom Concert Hall, Segerstrom Center for the Arts, 
    Costa Mesa, California; 1 and 3 June 2013; Meng Concert Hall, Clayes Performing 
    Arts Center, California State University, Fullerton, 4 June 2013
 I first encountered the music of Frank Ticheli on a 
      splendid Naxos CD of wind-band music called 
Landscapes (
review). 
      The piece in question was 
American Elegy, a profoundly moving response 
      to the Columbine High School massacre of 20 April 1999. I was struck by 
      its ‘quiet dignity, panoramic sweep and hymn-like passages’, 
      so when this new Delos album appeared I was impatient to hear it. The poets 
      represented here are unfamiliar, but the Pacific Symphony and Chorale certainly 
      aren’t; I much admired their recent Daugherty disc, which remains 
      fresh and vital even after many outings (
review).
       
      The works on that CD were conducted by Carl St Clair, but here the Chorale’s 
      artistic director, John Alexander is in charge. Indeed, 
The Shore 
      was commissioned to celebrate his fortieth anniversary with the group. This 
      ‘choral symphony’ is built around the highly evocative poetry 
      of Fresno-born David St John. The scurrying prelude to 
The Tidepools 
      & the Boy is followed by equally animated singing from the Chorale. 
      Ticheli’s writing, spare but never desiccated, is flecked with lovely 
      instrumental colours. The playing is clean and characterful.
       
      
One Shore finds the chorus in a quieter, more contemplative mode, 
      their inward utterances punctuated by the simplest of accompaniments. Most 
      striking is the originality of Ticheli’s score, which avoids the usual 
      watery clichés. Even those rippling harp figures don’t seem at all 
      hackneyed. Climaxes – sparingly used – have tremendous body 
      and bite, and like everything else in this well-crafted work they are appropriately 
      scaled. The chorus’s gently rocking phrases at the close are a joy 
      to hear. They also offer a spirited counterpoint to the rolling/tolling 
      of 
The Black Gondola, an evanescent, dream-like episode that isn’t 
      only draped in black. Ticheli’s sound-picture is deftly drawn, and 
      the ‘sea’s melody’ in 
Redemption – with 
      the atmospherically distant baritone Aram Barsamian – is an ever-changing 
      but always beguiling one.
       
      The intellectual thrust of 
The Song Within, with its emphasis on 
      hope, peace and what Ticheli calls ‘a crisis of faith’, is all 
      too familiar in this age of anxiety; that said, it’s an 
a 
      cappella piece of surprising sinew and strength. The John Alexander 
      Singers are a lusty lot, yet in quieter moments they sing with a pleasing 
      line and unanimity of tone. The tenor John St Marie, who is placed too far 
      forward, is secure, but the high-lying choral parts are prone to fierceness. 
      For all it felicities, though, 
The Song Within isn’t 
quite 
      as memorable as I’d hoped.
       
      
Constellation, Ticheli’s 
a cappella settings of 
      three poems by Sara Teasdale (1884-1933), is yet another commission, this 
      time from the California chapter of the American Choral Directors Association. 
      
From the Sea is nimbly sung by both the chorus and soprano Kellee 
      King. 
The Falling Star flares with a quick, transient 
      light, and 
There Will Be Stars is a simple meditation on the immutability 
      of the heavens. The agile John Alexander Singers acquit themselves well 
      although the recording gives King’s voice a cutting edge.
       
      In that Naxos review I linked Ticheli and Copland, both of whose output 
      is quintessentially American in its sounds and sources. Both seem to draw 
      strength from Shaker melodies, which embody simple but abiding virtues. 
      That’s certainly true of Ticheli’s arrangement of the gift song 
      
Here Take This Lovely Flower, which finds the John Alexander Singers 
      in radiant concert; soprano Lorraine Joy Welling’s delivery has an 
      artless purity that’s utterly right in this context. A sliver of sustained 
      loveliness, well sung and recorded.
       
      How do you follow that? With 
Earth Song, based on a poem Ticheli 
      wrote to fit a pre-existing score. A quiet affirmation of the sustaining 
      power of song it’s given serene and splendid voice by the Chorale. 
      So often composer-penned texts are less than compelling, but Ticheli is 
      as adept with words as he is with music. The final Teasdale setting, 
There 
      Will Be Rest, is a perfect coda to this fine collection. In this piece, 
      another Chorale commission, the poet’s awe of the heavens is translated 
      into a long-breathed benediction of aching loveliness. Goodness, what a 
      choir, and what a piece.
       
      This is a very rewarding album that lovers of contemporary choral writing 
      should hear. Not all the music or singing is of the highest quality, but 
      it’s a measure of Ticheli’s considerable craft – and Alexander’s 
      conducting skills – that even the less appealing pieces hold the ear 
      from start to finish. As live recordings 
The Shore and 
There 
      Will Be Rest have an added spontaneity, a subtle 
frisson, 
      that makes them rather special; remarkably, 
Here Take This Lovely Flower 
      is blessed with the very same qualities.
       
      The recording is good, although it’s a little bright at tomes, and 
      balances are generally fine. Also, the composer’s brief liner-notes 
      – which include the sung texts – are very readable. I have one 
      gripe though; the gaps between tracks are much too short. I suspect this 
      is a problem with the download rather than the CD, in which case it’s 
      one that can be fixed easily enough.
       
      Strong choral writing, persuasively presented; well worth your time and 
      money.
       
      
Dan Morgan
      twitter.com/mahlerei