Tom CUNNINGHAM (b. 1946)
            The Okavango Macbeth – chamber opera 
            (2009)
            Lady Macbeth – Beth Mackay (soprano), 
            Macbeth – Rónan Busfield (tenor), 
            Duncan – Andrew McTaggart (baritone), 
            Lady Macbeth’s friend – Lucinda Stuart-Grant (mezzo) 
            Primatologists – Nicholas Morris, Jamie Rock, Jessica Leary 
            (baritone, baritone, soprano)
            Mr McFall’s Chamber Orchestra/Michael Bawtree
            Edinburgh Studio Opera Chorus
            rec. 22-23 April 2011, Queen’s Hall, Edinburgh
            
DELPHIAN DCD34096 [49:28 + 33:40]
            
            
This is a heartening project, an opera created 
              and performed in Edinburgh, combining the literary talents of a 
              world famous Edinburgh author and the evident musical qualities 
              of an Edinburgh composer who gets on with things quietly. McCall 
              Smith (b. 1948), who spends a lot of time in Botswana, thought that 
              the Okavango delta would be a good setting for an opera, so he re-imagined 
              the Macbeth story to take place within a troop of baboons, all the 
              while observed by a group of primatologists. The premiere took place 
              in a converted garage in the Botswana bush (known as the No. 
              1 Ladies’ Opera House) and was then performed again at 
              the Cambridge Music Festival and in Edinburgh. That led to this 
              recording on Delphian, a Scottish label which does a lot to promote 
              Scottish music and musicians.
               
              Tom Cunningham’s score is eminently approachable and instantly 
              engaging. It’s full of hummable melodies and inventive instrumentation 
              for the chamber forces he uses. It is also carried forward by an 
              infectious rhythm that quietly and unobtrusively suggests Africa. 
              Some of the more intimate scenes, however, have just a tinge of 
              Celtic music to them, suggesting their point of origin. Snobs might 
              complain that it’s too much like a West End show, and maybe 
              it’s a little repetitious at times, but it’s rich in 
              tunes and contrasting dramatic situations in the best manner of 
              musical theatre, and I enjoyed it very much.
               
              The primatologists are initially quite bumbling but they are capably 
              sung and their comments on the unfolding events in the Baboon troop 
              are well observed. Beth Mackay sings Lady Macbeth with a rich sense 
              of imperiousness, and Rónan Busfield, whose voice I have 
              enjoyed in performances with the Scottish Conservatoire, sings Macbeth 
              with clarity and a good dose of heroism. Andrew McTaggart makes 
              a gravelly Duncan, but that fits his more authoritative role, and 
              the singing of the chorus is strong, with all the solos taken very 
              successfully.
               
              McCall Smith’s libretto is also skilfully put together, drawing 
              parallels between human society and that of the baboons without 
              underlining them too severely, though some of the moral messages 
              are a little heavily done. The recording quality is also excellent, 
              perhaps favouring the voices a little too much, but still capturing 
              all the parts well. In short, this is well worth a look.
               
              Simon Thompson