rec. 11-12 October 2012, First Presbyterian Church, Springfield, Ill., 
            USA. DDD
            
 This is the seventh volume in the Naxos series 
              devoted to the organ works of Heinrich Scheidemann. He is considered 
              the father of the North-German organ school and played a key role 
              in music life in Hamburg. He was the son of David Scheidemann who 
              was first organist in Wöhrden in Holstein and moved to Hamburg 
              in 1604 where he had been appointed organist of St. Katharinen. 
              It is not known exactly when Heinrich succeeded his father, but 
              he was acting as organist from 1629 at the latest. He held this 
              position until his death. From 1611 to 1614 he studied with Sweelinck 
              in Amsterdam, like so many of his colleagues. His teacher's 
              influence is clearly discernible in his organ works, for instance 
              in the use of echo effects. Sweelinck brought him also into contact 
              with the music of the English virginalists. Their influence comes 
              especially to the fore in his variations, which are mostly for manuals, 
              and are probably written for the harpsichord in the first place. 
              Julia Brown has included some of them in the programme of this disc, 
              as with previous volumes in this series.
               
              The present disc delivers a survey of the various genres in Scheidemann's 
              keyboard oeuvre. It begins with a setting of the 
Magnificat 
              which comprises four verses in various textures. This is an 
alternatim 
              composition; the other verses are to be sung. It is a little disappointing 
              that these have been omitted; their inclusion would have given a 
              good impression of the liturgical function of this setting. Obviously 
              the Lutheran chorales played an important part in the liturgy, and 
              this explains the large number of arrangements of various kinds 
              in the German organ literature of the 17th and 18th centuries. Scheidemann 
              was a particularly fruitful composer of such arrangements. He treats 
              the chorale melody in different ways, sometimes as it was written 
              and sung by the congregation, sometimes highly embellished. Many 
              arrangements comprise two verses, and the chorale melody can appear 
              in various voices, mostly the upper voice or the bass, but sometimes 
              also in the tenor. The number of voices deployed is either three 
              or four. Although the art of playing the pedals was highly developed 
              in North-Germany, Scheidemann also composed variations for manuals 
              alone.
               
              Organists in those days were expected to improvise. Organ music 
              was very seldom printed, and the fact that a relatively large number 
              of compositions from Scheidemann's pen has been preserved 
              is due to its dissemination by his colleagues and pupils. It bears 
              witness to the fact that he was held in high esteem. The chorale 
              arrangements give insight into the way organists in those days prepared 
              the singing of the congregation. They also played free organ works, 
              for instance at the beginning and the end of services. The 
praeambula 
              and 
fantasias give us some idea of their improvisatory 
              skills. These are mostly pieces in free style, often influenced 
              by the 
stylus phantasticus which had its roots in Italy. 
              Some pieces look backwards, so to speak, to the era of the 
stile 
              antico: at the time polyphonic motets as they were common in 
              the 16th century were regularly sung, and sometimes also played 
              instead. This explains the transcriptions of motets by, for instance, 
              Hassler (
Dixit Maria ad angelum). Scheidemann doesn't 
              add that much to the original texture, but treats the motet in such 
              a way that it turns into a real organ piece. It allows the performer 
              to display the colours of the organ.
               
              Julia Brown also plays a number of secular pieces. There is no basic 
              objection to playing such pieces on the organ. Sweelinck played 
              during weekdays the organ of the Oude Kerk in Amsterdam, and it 
              is certainly conceivable that he also included variations on secular 
              melodies. However, it is not easy to imagine such a situation in 
              Hamburg. I wonder on which occasions Scheidemann and his colleagues 
              might have played such pieces in church. It is more plausible that 
              they were written for domestic performance or in social gatherings 
              of the upper echelons of society. In that case a performance on 
              the harpsichord or comparable instruments would be preferable. For 
              some reason this part of Scheidemann's oeuvre is largely 
              neglected. Those who would like to hear some of them on the harpsichord 
              should turn to a disc by Pieter Dirksen (Harpsichord Music; Et'cetera, 
              2007). The variations show, in particular, the influence of the 
              English virginalists.
               
              The instrument Julia Brown plays here is a modern organ, built by 
              John Brombaugh & Associates (Eugene, Oregon) and completed in 
              2004. It is a nice instrument which is well suited to the repertoire. 
              However, the tuning is not ideal. According to the booklet it "is 
              tuned in Herbert Kellner's 'Bach', a mild unequal 
              temperament suited to music from all periods". The latter is 
              true from a technical point of view: no organ music may be unplayable, 
              although I wonder whether it is suitable for romantic or contemporary 
              music. In regard to interpretation a meantone temperament would 
              be preferable when playing works by Scheidemann and his contemporaries. 
              Now and then I noticed passages where the harmonic progressions 
              were a shade ineffectual. In a meantone temperament they would have 
              been more spicy and would have made a stronger impression.
               
              This issue didn't prevent me from enjoying this disc. Scheidemann's 
              organ oeuvre is versatile and compelling, and Ms Brown delivers 
              fine performances, even though I would have liked a little more 
              imagination, with stronger touches of improvisation. I don't 
              know how many more discs we can expect. It would be great if at 
              the end of this project all of Scheidemann's keyboard works 
              were made available on disc. He thoroughly deserves it.
              
              
Johan van Veen
              http://www.musica-dei-donum.org
              https://twitter.com/johanvanveen