SHOSTAKOVICH Syms 7, 9, 10 Rozhdestvensky BRILLIANT CLASSICS 9273 [PCG]: Classical Music Reviews

In the early days of CD, and before the fall of the Iron Curtain, Gennady Rozhdestvensky recorded the complete Shostakovich symphonies and these were issued on the long-defunct Olympia label. These recordings were only challenged in the catalogues at that time by Bernard Haitink’s Decca cycle, and they formed a startling contrast to Haitink’s much less characterful and more symphonic approach. Rozhdestvensky brought out all the puckish elements in Shostakovich’s writing, aided and abetted by a Russian studio recording that closely microphoned all the individual instruments and emphasised their contributions in a highly artificial and sometimes startlingly manner. After the demise of Olympia these recordings drifted in and out of the catalogues in a number of guises, but currently appear to be once again unavailable.

On initial inspection it would seem that this 3 CD set would be a further reissue of those 1980s recordings, but although some of the performances are again given by the USSR Ministry of Culture Symphony Orchestra these are not the same versions as before. They are derived from concert performances and also including a number of readings by Rozhdestvensky’s earlier orchestra the State TV and Radio Symphony Orchestra with whom he made a number of recordings in the 1970s. The actual style of the performances however remain much as in Rozhdestvensky’s studio readings: lively and sometimes entertainingly eccentric, with for example a very slow approach to the infamous ‘march’ section in the first movement of the Leningrad Symphony. The recordings are however very different in the approach of the engineers. The Ministry of Culture Symphony Orchestra concert recordings are much more straightforward than in the contemporary studio readings, with none of the spotlighting of individual lines that many may find irritating in the Olympia issues or their successors. The supposed portrait of Stalin in the second movement of the Tenth Symphony has all the demonic fire that Rozhdestvensky captured in his studio version, but the orchestra is given a more natural concert hall acoustic which lacks the artificiality of the studio balance.

The older recordings with the TV and Radio orchestra, however, are rather less successful, lacking the sheer punch of the sound that Rozhdestvensky obtained in the studio. The recording quality in the Leningrad Symphony is decidedly inferior to Rozhdestvensky’s later version with the Ministry of Culture players. The recording of the Michelangelo Suite with Evgeny Nesterenko is nevertheless valuable, because these songs have never subsequently been re-recorded by the conductor. This suite was Shostakovich’s last major orchestral work, and it has all the heavy solemnity of the death-laden songs in the Fourteenth Symphony. It has not been much favoured on disc, and the only currently available rivals to this release are a 2006 Chandos issue sung by Ildar Abdrazakov and a version from Anatoli Kotscherga on Capriccio. The latter is very much better recorded and also considerably better played by the BBC Philharmonic under Gianandrea Noseda. Nesterenko’s singing of these pieces is really something rather special - it was he who gave the first performance of the suite in its orchestral guise some six months before this recording was made. This is sufficient to make one overlook the decidedly inferior quality of the actual sound captured by the engineers, with the voice very forwardly placed. Nesterenko’s plangent declamation of the words has a sense of black foreboding which almost makes one forgive the fact that the booklet supplies no texts or translations.

Chandos also made a recording of the complete ballet The Bolt with Rozhdestvensky conducting the Royal Stockholm orchestra (CHAN9343(2)). This indeed remains the only current CD recording of the complete score. He has great fun with this suite, however, and the Russian players are decidedly more idiomatic than their Swedish counterparts. The recording is crisper, too.

We really need to have Rozhdestvensky’s complete studio cycle of the symphonies restored to circulation, but many listeners may nevertheless prefer the more natural sound of the orchestra as captured here in the Ninth and Tenth Symphonies. The less satisfactorily engineered Leningrad Symphony is however decidedly outclassed by the later studio recording, and the suite from The Bolt is lightweight even if welcome. No, this set is principally valuable for the Nesterenko performance of the Michelangelo Suite, and it would be welcome if this could be released separately. However, even here, still more desirable would be a reissue of the studio recording Nesterenko made in 1977 with the Moscow Chamber Orchestra under Rudolf Barshai, which does not appear to have been available for many years.

Paul Corfield Godfrey

Masterwork Index: Shostakovich Symphony 7 ~~ Symphony 9 ~~ Symphony 10

2023 Approaching 60,000 reviews and more.. and still writing ...	Search MusicWeb Here