Thérèse?
 Massenet is chiefly 
        remembered for two operatic works: 
Manon and 
Werther and, 
        perhaps, another four: 
Hérodiade,
 Thaïs,
 
        Don Quichotte and 
Cendrillon. In fact his output in the genre 
        was much larger - running to some 25 stage works. Much of this output 
        has been unjustly neglected and forgotten. On the evidence of this CD 
        and the essays in the accompanying book, 
Thérèse, 
        appealingly
passionate, violent and
fast moving, is definitely 
        due for serious re-consideration. It is largely unappreciated how diverse 
        and original most of Massenet’s operatic works were. He was never 
        one to rest on his laurels and each of his operas demonstrates an eagerness 
        to experiment and to keep abreast of current fashions. 
Thérèse,
set 
        in the turbulent, bloody days of the French Revolution, embraces numerous 
        musical styles. These hark back to 18
th century elegance and 
        refinement, to the dramatic and even to the melodramatic style of Wagner. 
        His gift for naturalism keeps pace with Italian 
verismo (Puccini’s 
        
La bohème) and its French equivalents including Gustav Charpentier’s 
        
Louise, a love story set amongst the Parisian working classes. 
        It may be remembered that Massenet was the teacher and mentor of this 
        Charpentier. 
          
        
Thérèse was premiered, to publicity fanfares, at 
        the Monte Carlo Opera House instead of at the Opéra-Comique in 
        Paris as originally intended. There were many subsequent performances 
        all over France and further afield before its Parisian premiere in 1911. 
        
        
        The story of 
Thérèse is a triangle love story. Act 
        1 opens at the estate purchased, at auction, by André Thorel on 
        behalf of his friend, the Marquis Armand de Clerval who has fled the events 
        of the Revolution. Thorel has married Thérèse and they are 
        living in the Clerval family home to save it from looting and with the 
        intention of restoring it to Armand when peace returns. Thérèse 
        and Armand have been secretly in love and unbeknown to her Armand is now 
        in the grounds of the château hoping to see Thérèse 
        before joining the Royalist uprising. André is a libertarian and 
        a member of the Girondin party. As he is attending to some soldiers passing 
        nearby, Armand meets Thérèse and declares his passion for 
        her but loyal to André, she resists. André joins them and 
        embraces his friend Armand. An official interrupts and half recognises 
        Armand but André vouches for his friend saying he is his companion, 
        his brother. 
          
        Act 2 transfers the action to Paris where Armand is being sheltered by 
        André and Thérèse in their apartment. Increasing 
        violence and bloodshed causes them to fear more and more for Armand’s 
        life. Added to all this danger, the mob is now turning on the Girondins 
        placing them in danger of the guillotine. André has organised a 
        safe conduct pass to allow Armand to escape. He hands this over and goes 
        off to join his Girondin friends. Armand begs Thérèse to 
        go with him. At length she weakens but then Morel their janitor tells 
        them the dreaded news that André has been arrested. Thérèse 
        persuades Armand to leave promising to join him later. Then looking out 
        of the window she sees to her horror André is in a tumbrel passing 
        on the way to the Conciergerie and to his doom. Wifely duty now dominates 
        her feelings. She opens wide the window and cries out - “Vive le 
        roi”. She is taken away and dies with her husband. 
          
        All the artists in this recorded live performance demonstrate dedication, 
        commitment and enthusiasm to show this short opera to its best advantage. 
        Mezzo-soprano Nora Gubisch colours her timbre to voice all the contradictory 
        emotions from torn loves and fears for both men through these turbulent 
        events. Notable are her gentle musings in Act I in the château gardens 
        as leaves flutter down to an ornamental pond, the amorous exchanges with 
        Armand and the extraordinary finale when she abandons singing and in spoken 
        word declaims “Vive le Roi! ... Ô mort! Ouvre tes bras! Marchons!” 
        to Massenet’s dramatic sound-effects of crowds roaring their disapproval, 
        rifle butts crashing to the ground and snare drums rolling. Armand as 
        sung by American tenor Charles Castronovo is superbly ardent and baritone 
        Étienne Dupuis is the epitome of heroic stoicism. 
          
        The 112-page hardback book, presented in French and English in well-designed 
        separate sections not only contains the full libretto and a story synopsis, 
        but also numerous illustrations including pictures of the original Monte 
        Carlo production, and five short essays; one an appreciation of the Monte 
        Carlo production by Gabriel Fauré, no less. The other essays cover 
        the richness and diversity of Massenet’s operatic output, the productions 
        of 
Thérèse,
naturalism in 
Thérèse, 
        and women and revolution in French opera. 
          
        It is to be hoped that this very enterprising set will encourage further 
        productions of 
Thérèse. Inevitably, it would have 
        to be partnered with a short-ish companion. My choice would be for Puccini’s 
        
Suor Angelica another work about feminine self-sacrifice. 
          
        This is the third instalment in Palazzetto Bru Zane’s 
Opéra 
        Français Collection. The other two volumes are 
Amadis de 
        Gaule by Johann Christian Bach and 
La Mort d’Abel by 
        Rodolphe Kreutzer. Volume 4 is 
Renaud by Antonio Sacchini. 
          
        
Ian Lace 
        
        Dedication, commitment and enthusiasm show this short opera to its best 
        advantage. An enterprising issue.