This highlights disc is taken from a complete recording of the
ballet that was highly recommended by the Penguin Guide. Running
for the best part of 80 minutes it represents very good value
indeed but it does beg the question - why not just buy the complete
3 CD set and be done with it? The Naxos team obviously feels
that there is a market for a truncated single CD release for
people who don’t want to sit through two and a half hours
of glorious music. On that basis, it should sell very well and
good luck to them. Personally I will stick with the complete
version. Mogrelia’s is certainly one of the best recordings
currently available. The Sleeping Beauty is a fabulous
score and it’s very difficult to decide which particular
80 minute selection actually constitutes the highlights. On
the whole, Naxos has done a good job with their decision-making
and at least the music is presented in the order in which it
appears in the complete score. My only major criticism is the
very short selection from Act 2 but if that’s a problem
just buy the full version and enjoy it. The track-listing is
shown below by way of guidance.
Mogrelia takes a very relaxed approach to the music. There’s
nothing barnstorming here, just some fine musicianship. It’s
almost as if the orchestra is accompanying a production of the
ballet rather than playing it through as an orchestral work
in its own right. Tempi are generally on the slow side but this
is of no detriment to the music whatsoever - slow is different
to lethargic and cautious. Mogrelia’s chosen tempi allow
for some relaxed music-making in the best sense and everything
is very fresh and nicely pointed. The Rose Adagio sounds
especially glorious.
Was the high praise in the Penguin Guide warranted? On the whole
the answer is yes. The orchestra plays with precision and clearly
enjoys the music and the conductor’s vision of it. The
recording is clear, warm and easy on the ear. All the solo work
shines through and the stereo image is convincing. The sound
quality is typical of what Naxos was achieving in Eastern Europe
in the 1990s - super sound at a bargain price. I can certainly
recommend the complete ballet on Naxos 8.550490-2. In terms
of where it stands in the pecking order, Previn
has the advantage of having the LSO at his disposal on EMI.
The Slovak players are in top form but the LSO has the edge.
My own top recommendation is still the BBC Symphony Orchestra
set with Rozhdestvensky. The
sound quality isn’t particularly flattering and there
are a few slips here and there but this recording is full of
gripping, edge-of-the-seat stuff that can’t be found elsewhere.
So there we have it. Three fine recordings and the Naxos is
up there with the best of them. If you buy it you won’t
be disappointed.
John Whitmore
see also review by John
France
Track-listing
Introduction [3:21]
Prologue:
Marche - Entrée du Roi Florestan et sa cour [5:20]
Scène dansante - Entrée des fées bonnes
[4:46]
Pas de six: Adagio [4:47]
Coulante, Fleur de Farine (Variation II) [0:33]
Fée aux Miettes (Variation III) [1:13]
Le Canari qui chante (Variation IV) [0:36]
Violente (Variation V) [1:02]
Fée des Lilas (Variation VI) [1:20]
Coda [1:51]
Act 1
Valse [4:42]
Pas d'action: Rose Adagio [6:36]
Coda [2:43]
Finale [7:56]
Act II
The Vision: Entr'acte et Scène [3:02]
Panorama [3:40]
Entr'acte symphonique (Le Sommeil) et Scène [1:34]
Finale [2:28]
Act III
The Wedding: Marche [3:30]
Polacca - Cortège des Contes de Fées [4:20]
Pas de quatre: Introduction [1:57]
La Fée - Argent (Variation II) [0:53]
La Fée - Diamant (Variation IV) [0:48]
Pas de quatre - Adagio [2:46]
Cendrillon et le Prince Fortuné (Variation I) [01:00]
Coda [1:36]
Apothéose [2:39]
Slovak State Philharmonic Orchestra/Andrew Mogrelia