Felix MENDELSSOHN-BARTHOLDY (1809-1847)
Sonata in A major Op. 65/3 (1845) [9:08]
Sonata in D minor Op. 65/6 (1845) [12:12]
Sonata in D major Op. 65/5 (1845) [7:55]
Sonata in C minor Op. 65/2 (1845) [9:49]
Sonata in F minor Op. 65/1 (1845) [14:17]
Sonata B flat major Op. 65/4 (1845) [11:45]
Jan Lehtola (organ)
rec. 8-9 October 2009, Uusikaupunki Church, Finland.
ALBA ABCD
324 [65:34] 
No question, the finest new organ recordings come from Finland. Fuga lead
the way with their excellent series featuring Kalevi Kiviniemi and a marvellous
range of instruments. I’ve not heard as many discs from Alba, but their collection
of Finnish music played by Ville Urponen – review
– impresses in a quiet, unassuming way. No surprise that sound engineer Mika
Koivusalo is behind many of these releases; indeed, I’d say his organ recordings
– both Red Book and Super Audio – are among the most satisfying in the catalogue,
characterised by the widest dynamic range and a detailed, three-dimensional
presence that’s frankly astounding.
That wouldn’t count for much if the programme and players aren’t up to snuff,
but I’ve yet to find a dud amongst these Finnish offerings. Mendelssohn’s
are not my favourite organ pieces – they often bring to mind over-furnished
Victorian parlours – but with a light touch and careful registration they
can be most rewarding. The organ used here is an 1865 Marcussen & Sohn,
which has a pleasing blend of scale and sweetness, the latter most evident
in Mendelssohn’s quieter moments. As for the church, the booklet photographs
suggest it’s a light, airy space as far removed from Gothic gloom as it’s
possible to get.
So, the auguries are good, but what of the music-making? The Finnish organist
Jan Lehtola – who’s had works written for him by the likes of Kalevi Aho and
Naji Hakim – is new to me, but I soon took to his warmly expressive style.
True, there’s a hint of that forbidding front toom in the first movement of
the A major sonata, but the ensuing Andante tranquillo brings with it light
and cooling air. This is playing of rare poise and transparency, most beautifully
recorded. Lehtola also captures the dark gravitas of the D minor sonata’s
Chorale very well – what deft pedal-work – the Fugue weighty but not overbearing,
the low-key Finale judiciously proportioned and infused with a gentle charm.
The D major sonata is no less alluring, the broad – but short – Chorale a
perfect foil to the skittish Andante that follows. Lehtola’s discreet pedal-work
is a joy to hear, the music delectably sprung and airily recorded. Organ discs
don’t get much better than this, a wholly convincing blend of detail, colour,
weight and acoustic clues. Indeed, as I listened to the endearing woodiness
of the concluding Allegro I found it easy to imagine myself sitting in a pew
revelling in the gorgeous swirl of sound from those burnished pipes. Pure
magic.
Pensive is a good description of the C minor sonata’s first movement – Grave
– the Adagio imbued with an inner glow I’ve rarely encountered in the piece.
Indeed, this lovely, sweet-toned organ is just right for this music, whose
infectious charm and bounce can so easily be veiled by weightier, more cumbersome
instruments. Make no mistake though, it’s capable of real heft when required,
the Allegro maestoso as expansive as one could wish for. Even in this panoply
of sound the recording never loses its composure, the Red Book layer every
bit as satisfying and immersive as the Super Audio one. But then one would
expect nothing less from a recording of this pedigree.
The F minor sonata was a high point of Mary Preston’s otherwise disappointing
recital from Reference Recordings – review
– but although Lehtola doesn’t have her floor-shaking pedals he finds more
contrast and character in the opening Allegro. As for his Adagio, it has a
stillness – a deep sense of communion, perhaps – that’s simply breathtaking,
the call and echo of the Andante so finely calibrated. The easy reach and
sheer presence of this recording is particularly evident in the final Allegro.
Lehtola is always clear and communicative, even when it comes to complex textures
– the first Allegro of the B flat major sonata, for instance – the Allegretto
reminiscent of Franck at his most playful. I simply cannot recall a performance
of such variety, of such light and shade, the closing Allegro apt to roar
as if played on a Cavaillé-Coll, albeit without the latter’s lumbering gait.
But then that’s the central virtue of this collection, a sure sense of scale
and balance that never succumbs to empty gestures. A rare achievement indeed.
This is another treasure from Alba’s enticing trove. Lehtola is a first-class
performer, his playing full of ebullience and insight; this organ is pretty
special too, its sweet, even-tempered sound faithfully caught by Koivusalo
and his team.
Quite simply, a recital to relish.
Dan Morgan
Quite simply, a recital to relish.