This collection of recycled waltz recordings is issued just as
a slew of Andre Rieu albums new and old appear on the market,
surely the reason for this double CD set from Naxos. Almost all
of these recordings date from the earliest days of Naxos (though
no dates are given), from a time when their issues featured
unknown conductors with East European orchestras in variable
recording conditions. There's no shame in Naxos's humble beginnings,
but an issue like this really brings home how far the
hugely successful Hong Kong based giant has come in the
twenty three years since its creation.
The good news first: Alfred Walter and the Slovak State Philharmonic
are characterful and stylish in the four Waldteufel items, and
in reasonable sound to boot. The Skaters is included
alongside some of the less famous waltzes, though proximity
to Johann Strauss II marks out Waldteufel as the less distinctive
and melodically gifted of the two. Lehár'sGold and
Silver and Ivanovici's The Danube Waves benefit from
the best production - the latter particularly well recorded
including a harp of unusual presence.
The disparity of recording quality is a problem, though, and
can change markedly from track to track. The opening chords
of Waldteufel’s Estudiantina burst forth alarmingly
after the relatively quiet volume set by the engineers for the
Waltz from Eugene Onegin. The extracts from Tchaikovsky’s
ballets are rendered in particularly thin sound and the performances
are no more than ordinary: anyone wanting the ballet suites
would be better off with Rostropovich’s glorious Tchaikovsky
collection with the Berlin Philharmonic, still available as
a DG Original (4497262).
The usual Straussian suspects are here, mostly under the solid
but uninspiring direction of Ondrej Lenárd. There’s
no real magic to the codas of The Blue Danube or The
Emperor Waltz, for example, and the playing of the Strauss
Festival Orchestra lacks the finesse we’d expect from
a modern Naxos recording.
The set as a whole might have been more successful if the net
had been cast a little wider: It’s the golden age of the
Viennese Waltz that is really celebrated here, and while the
Masquerade and Rosenkavalier waltzes included
at the end of the second disc extend the remit a little, surely
a Chopin waltz (to refute the booklet’s claim that Johann
Strauss II is ‘the undisputed grandfather of the waltz’)
or Ravel’s seminal genre deconstruction La Valse
would have made for a more rounded collection.
Variable performances and too narrow a selection make this a
disappointing collection.
Andrew Morris
Details
Franz LEHÁR (1870-1948)
1. Gold and Silver [8:39]
Pyotr Il'yich TCHAIKOVSKY (1840-1893)
2. The Nutcracker Suite - Waltz of the Flowers [6:52]
Johann STRAUSS II (1825-1899)
3. The Blue Danube [9:25]
Émile WALDTEUFEL (1837-1915)
4. The Skaters [7:31]
Franz LEHÁR
5. The Merry Widow Waltz [6. 27]
Pyotr Il'yich TCHAIKOVSKY
6. The Sleeping Beauty - Act 1 Waltz [4:44]
Johann STRAUSS II
7. Emperor Waltz [11:16]
Pyotr Il'yich TCHAIKOVSKY
8. Serenade for Strings - II Moderato, tempo di valse [3:56]
Johann STRAUSS II
9. Tales from the Vienna Woods [11:57]
Johann STRAUSS II
10. Voices of Spring [6:09]
Émile WALDTEUFEL
11. Très jolie [8:38]
Pyotr Il'yich TCHAIKOVSKY
12. Swan Lake - Waltz [5:49]
Iosif IVANOVICI (1845-1902)
13. The Danube Waves [8:39]
Adolphe ADAM (1803-1856)
14. Giselle - Act 1 Waltz [6:23]
Pyotr Il'yich TCHAIKOVSKY
15. Eugene Onegin - Waltz [6:23]
Émile WALDTEUFEL
16. Estudiantina [6:47]
Émile WALDTEUFEL
17. Solitude [9:52]
Johann STRAUSS II
18. Wine, Women and Song [6:02]
Aram KHACHATURIAN (1903-1978)
19. Masquerade - Waltz [4:19]
Richard STRAUSS (1864-1949)
20. Der Rosenkavalier - Waltz Sequence no 1 [12:06]
Budapest Strauss Ensemble (13)
Slovak Radio Symphony Orchestra (1, 2, 14, 15, 18)
Slovak State Philharmonic Orchestra, Košice (4, 6, 11,
12, 16, 17)
Strauss Festival Orchestra (3, 7, 9, 10)
St. Petersburg State Symphony Orchestra (19)
Vienna Chamber Orchestra (8)
Alfred Walter (4, 16, 17)
Andrew Mogrelia (6)
István Bogár (13)
Michael Dittrich (1)
Michael Halász (12)
Ondrej Lenárd (2, 3, 7, 9, 10, 14, 15, 18, 19)
Philippe Entremont (8)
Richard Hayman and his Orchestra (5)
Zdenĕk Košler (20)
rec. no recording dates or venues supplied.
NAXOS 8.578041-42 [70:51 + 76:53] 
