Flonzaley Quartet - Pristine PACM068 [JW]: Classical Music Reviews

Collectors will know - and transfer engineer Mark Obert-Thorn reiterates the point in his jewel-case notes - that many of the Flonzaley Quartet’s electrical recordings were issued by Biddulph in the 1990s. He has recently transferred the quartet’s Christmas Carol sides for Pristine Audio - which I reviewed recently - and has now completed the job with this fine disc.

The focal points are the Smetana and Dohnányi quartets, but the lighter side of things should on no account be overlooked. The London’s abridged acoustic recording may be earlier and the Bohemian’s may be more famous, but the Flonzaley’s 1929 recording of the Smetana E minor possesses wonderful and salient qualities of its own. Foremost among them is the light, wristy, subtle approach which, allied to the sparing use of vibrato, adds a Gallic patina to the music making. This is, to be sure, very different to the modernity of the London Quartet, or to the echt-Czech qualities of the Bohemian, but no less exciting. It exudes, in short, French lyricism, artistry of delightful lightness and also fine intonation. The recording was a good one and the Victor ‘Gold’ used to transfer was evidently in fine heart; we can hear the inner voices perfectly and thus appreciate the old adage of a quartet only being as good as its second violin (the Bohemian Quartet’s second violin for example was the composer Josef Suk). The unison playing in the slow movement is sonorous without becoming inflated or over-saturated in the Russian way, and the scherzo has requisite rhythmic brio. The tremolandi and sense of drama in the finale are well conveyed.

The companion work is Dohnányi’s Second Quartet of 1906. This was recorded a little earlier, in October 1927 in the same venue, Victor’s Camden studio No.1. It’s a resonant and attractive three movement work that is a fine vehicle for the Flonzaley. Its lissom freedoms are attractively explored and the marvellously rapid articulation of the central movement attests to the technical adroitness of the foursome. They play the hymnal-leaning melodic lines with great finesse and care over bow weight and tonal matching. Similarly the finale’s counterpoint and return to hymnal seriousness are compellingly presented. It’s no wonder that the upper voices remained so strong; by this point Adolfo Betti and Alfred Pochon had been performing together in the quartet for over twenty years.

The ‘fillers’ are delightful. The spirituals perhaps remind one of violinist Maud Powell’s pioneering transcriptions in this arena. Refinement and elegance are the watchwords, and a certain nobility of utterance too. Pochon’s Irish Cradle Song possesses an elfin artfulness and prefaces the traditional Irish Reel - recorded a year apart. Both this and Sally in our alley were without question London String Quartet territory, the Flonzaley’s friendly rivals who recorded for Columbia. The Victor riposte is highly engaging.

There is some inherent mechanical noise on some tracks but it’s pretty insignificant stuff. Treble frequencies have been retained and room ambience is very much audible. Splendid work all round, and a fitting conclusion to the run of the Flonzaley’s electric discs.

Jonathan Woolf

2023 Approaching 60,000 reviews and more.. and still writing ...	Search MusicWeb Here