Editorial Board
MusicWeb International
Founding Editor Rob Barnett Editor in Chief
John Quinn Contributing Editor Ralph Moore Webmaster
David Barker Postmaster
Jonathan Woolf MusicWeb Founder Len Mullenger
Ludwig van BEETHOVEN(1770-1827) Middle String Quartets
CD 1
String Quartet No.7 in F, Op.59/1 (1806) [39:58]
String Quartet in F, Op.14/1 (arr. of Piano Sonata No.9, 1798-9)
[13:03]
CD 2
String Quartet No.8 in e minor, Op.59/2 (1806) [34:37]
String Quartet No.9 in C, Op.59/3 (1806) [30:38]
CD 3
String Quartet No.10 in E-flat, Op.74, ‘Harp’ (1809)
[30:44]
String Quartet No.11 in f minor, Op.95, ‘Serioso’ (1810)
[21:01]
Wihan Quartet
rec. live, Convent of St Agnes, Prague, 18 October 2007, 8 November
2007, 6 December 2007, 17 January 2008 and 7 February2008. DDD.
NIMBUS ALLIANCE
NI 6109 [3 CDs: 54:04 + 65:26 + 51:47]
This completes the series of Beethoven Quartets recorded live
by the Wihan Quartet and issued under special licence by Nimbus.
Their concerts mixed works from different periods but Nimbus
have chosen to issue them more logically in sets of the early,
middle-period and late works. The order in which they were performed
live is listed on their website:
18 Oct 2007 op.18/1,op.14/1,op.59/1
8 Nov 2007 op.18/2,op.74,op.131
6 Dec 2007 op.18/3,op.59/3,op.127
17 Jan 2008 op.18/4,op.95,op.132
7 Feb 2008 op.18/5,op.135,op.59/2
13 Mar 2008 op.18/6,op.133,op.130
I reviewed the Early Quartets (NI6105, 2 CDs - see review),
as also did Colin Clarke (see review),
and Patrick Waller reviewed the Late Quartets (NI6100-2, 3 CDs
- see review).
Surveying the available versions of the Middle Quartets in my
April,
2009, Download Roundup, I recommended versions of String
Quartets 7 and 9 by the Borodin Quartet (Chandos CHAN10178),
Nos. 8 and 10 by the Lindsay Quartet (ASV CDDCA1115), Nos.10
and 11 by the Tokyo Quartet (Harmonia Mundi HMU80 7460) and
Nos. 11, 13 and 14 by the Borodin Quartet (Chandos CHAN10269).
I also mentioned the versions of Nos.7-10 by the Takács
Quartet; I should have given that set more prominence, since
it now seems to me the most secure recommendation of all (Decca
470 8472, 2 CDs or download in good mp3 sound from passionato.com).
The Takács Quartet commenced their cycle of complete
recordings with the Middle Quartets in 2002, explaining that
these works are extraordinarily strong statements and that Beethoven
was taking a risk with them. Listening to their recordings it
is quite apparent that this was no off-the-cuff remark: the
relationship between the Middle and Late Quartets is stressed
here to an extent that I have never heard in other performances.
Comparing the Wihans with those recommendations, I have to say
again, as I did in the case of the Op.18 Quartets, that they
stand up well, often very well, but ultimately wouldn’t
come top of my list. If, in the Op.18 set, I missed the last
degree of Beethoven’s out-Haydning of Haydn, the lack
is a little more of a problem in the Op.59 set. Hard as it is
for us today to understand, contemporaries found these works
difficult, not only in the technical sense but also hard to
comprehend. Though Beethoven employs Russian themes in two of
the quartets in honour of the Russian ambassador who had commissioned
them, Count Razumovsky doubtless found them as ‘profound
in conception and admirably written but not generally comprehensible’
as did the Leipzig Allgemeine musikalische Zeitung’s
Viennese correspondent.
Greater incomprehension was to come with the Last Quartets,
Nos.12-16, of course, but an ideal performance of these middle-period
works should be prepared to offset beautiful playing against
a strong sense of drama. The Wihan performances of the Op.59
works don’t quite achieve that: they remind me more of
Symphony No.4, which bears the opus number immediately following,
Op.60, rather than of the ‘Eroica’ Symphony, Op.55,
which immediately preceded them. That doesn’t mean that
I shan’t play and enjoy these performances - after all,
I find myself in the mood to hear the Fourth Symphony, one of
my favourites, though usually less highly regarded than its
odd-numbered companions, at least as often as I listen to the
‘Eroica’ or the Fifth Symphony.
The Op.14 Quartet is something of an oddity - Beethoven’s
own re-working of his Piano Sonata No.10 but not a mere arrangement;
carefully rescored by Beethoven himself, it is well worth hearing
and it receives a good performance - perhaps the best of the
set. The Lindsays include Op.14/1 with Op.18/4 and 5 on budget-price
ASV CDDCA1112, and the Leipziger Streichquartett, like the Wihans,
combine it with Op.59/1 (Dabringhaus und Grimm MDG30707072).
I believe that these are the only other currently available
performances.
The Wihan performance of Op.59/1 neatly characterises the whole
set. There is strength as well as elegance in their playing
and I was often convinced by the interpretation but, in the
final analysis, the sheer beauty of the playing wins over the
toughness to an extent which I thought came down just on the
wrong side of this balancing act.
Op.59/2 is the toughest nut to crack of the three. Listening
to the performance by the Takács Quartet, the pre-echoes
of the late quartets are apparent. The Wihan Quartet open their
performance promisingly with sharply-articulated chords. This
is a good, often very good performance, and the playing of the
Wihans, as throughout, is of the highest order. Their account
of the mixture of jollity and plaintiveness in the third movement,
for example, is very attractive, but overall I missed that last
degree of power which the Takács players achieve.
Of the three Op.59 quartets, contemporaries found the third
and last the easiest to come to terms with. Misha Donat in the
notes suggests that this may have been due partly to Mozartian
undertones in the outer movements. It would, therefore, hardly
be surprising to find the Wihans most in tune with the mood
of this work. Listen to their performance of the third movement,
where they combine gemütlichkeit and seriousness
in just the right measure.
Like the Takács Quartet, the Wihans manage to accommodate
Op.59/2 and Op.59/3 on one CD. Unfortunately, they achieve this
(comfortably, in fact, with a total playing time of 65:26 against
72:18 for the Decca CD) not just by adopting tempi generally
faster than those of the Takács, but also by omitting
some of the repeats.
The third CD couples the ‘Harp’ Quartet, Op.74,
with the ‘Serioso’, Op.95. These, too, are very
well-played, if again just lacking the last degree of the toughness
to be found in the Takács performances. Op.95 is even
more a transitional work than the Op.59 Quartets; it stands
on the very threshold of the Last Quartets. Significantly, the
Decca set includes it with those works and the Takács
performance fully justifies that decision. I don’t mean
to imply that the Wihan performance is backward-looking; both
it and the ‘Harp’ receive very creditable performances,
combing lyricism with strength. I’d just have preferred
a little more of the strength, but the Wihan performances make
perfect sense in their own right.
Since these works were recorded concurrently with the Op.18
and Late Quartets, it’s hardly surprising that the recording
has the same qualities as the earlier volumes. It’s as
clear and sonorous as the playing, with the violins, especially
the leader, prominent in the sound mix. Perhaps the engineers
have been more attentive to getting that mix right this time,
but the slight over-prominence that I noted before is less in
evidence. As before, the only indication of the audience, apart
from occasional extraneous noises, comes from the applause at
the end. The Takács Quartet recording is sharper and
less plush than that accorded to the Wihans; personal tastes
may well dictate preferences here.
As with the other volumes, the notes, by Misha Donat, are excellent
- a model of informative detail and readability comparable with
superb the booklets that Hyperion usually provide with their
CDs.
This series marks the Wihans’ second stab at the complete
Beethoven quartets; they already had a 10-CD set on the Lotos
label. They may have been together for over 20 years, but I
don’t think these will be their last words on the subject,
though many will feel that the virtues outweigh the reservations.
If, as I assume, the set is offered at an attractive price,
like the earlier sets, available here on Musicweb at £12
for 2CDs £16 for 3 CDs postage free World-wide , they
would make a good bargain. Perhaps now they should record Mozart:
Richard
Amey described their recent concert performance of K387
as ‘a reading of grace yet with momentum, with apparent
spontaneity coupled with control’, which is consistent
with my reaction to their Beethoven and rather more in tune
with what is needed in Mozart.
The Italian Quartet performances on Philips used to be my benchmark
for the Beethoven Quartets ever since I discovered their LPs
almost half a century ago. More recently, I find myself turning
to the Lindsays (ASV), the Borodin Quartet, whose performances
have just been reissued as a complete set by Chandos (CHAN10553,
8 CDs for around £34) and, above all, the Takács
Quartet. The Wihans don’t, for me, quite make it into
that pantheon but they come closer in the new set than on their
earlier releases.
If you are looking for a very competent set of the Middle Quartets,
well recorded and offered at a reasonable price, this could
very well be just right for you, especially if you wish to include
the Op.14 rarity and would like Op.95 included with the middle-period
works rather than with the Late Quartets. All in all, however,
I would prefer to sacrifice Op.14 and go for the 2-CD Decca
Takács set, deferring Op.95 to be purchased with the
late Quartets, where the Takács performers are, again,
my preferred option in a very competitive field. Those looking
for an even better bargain than the Wihans’ CDs might
like to check out the DVD set of their Beethoven performances,
available at an even more generous price direct from Musicweb-international.
Brian Wilson
Ludwig
van BEETHOVEN(1770-1827) Early String Quartets (1798-1800)
CD 1
String Quartet in F, Op.18/1 [28:59]
String Quartet in G, Op.18/2 [23:59]
String Quartet in D, Op.18/3 [24:39]
CD 2
String Quartet in c minor, Op.18/4 [23:28]
String Quartet in A, Op.18/5 [28:47]
String Quartet in B-flat, Op.18/6 [24:33]
Wihan Quartet
rec. live, Convent of St Agnes, Prague, 18 October, 8 November,
6 December, 2007, 17 January, 7 February, 13 March 2008. DDD
NIMBUS ALLIANCE NI6105 [77:43 + 76:44]
£12 postage Paid
Ludwig
van BEETHOVEN (1770-1827)
Late String Quartets
CD 1
String Quartet in E flat Op.127 [35:54]
String Quartet in C# minor Op.131 [38:48]
CD 2
String Quartet in B flat Op.130 (with Grosse Fuge Op.133 as
the finale) [46:49]
CD 3
String Quartet in A minor Op.132 [45:29]
String Quartet in F Op.135 [24:59]
Wihan Quartet
rec. Convent of St. Agnes, Prague, 6 December and 8 November
2007 (CD 1), 13 March 2008 (CD 2), 17 January and 7 February
2008 (CD 3). DDD NIMBUS ALLIANCE
NI6100-2 [3 CDs: 74:45 + 46:49 + 70:32]
£16 postage-paid
Reviews
from previous months Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the
discs reviewed. details We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin
Board
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to
which you refer.