Having been mentally bashed around a bit by some of the more
intellectually
demanding items on the Cybèle catalogue - no names, no pack-drill - I
find returning to Tournemire’s
L’orgue mystique a
bit like getting back into a nice hot bath after a badly timed incoming phone
call. It’s a cold hard world out there, and the all-year continuity and
sheer volume of Tournemire’s music allows even a lapsed agnostic such as
myself to identify with the sense of security provided by having a place within
such a vast Church - and I don’t mean Durham Cathedral. Appreciating the
mysteries as expressed by Tournemire certainly shines a pretty bright light into
the world of a composer such as Messiaen - not always necessarily in terms of
style or content, but in terms of a kind of familial recognition: membership
of that inner core of genuine believers.
This review covers volumes three and four in Cybele and Sandro R. Müller’s
ongoing complete set of Charles Tournemire's
L'orgue mystique. As I suggested
in the review of the
first
two volumes, there really is nothing to fear from this huge work, which covers
the entire Liturgical year in 51 ‘offices’ or Masses. These are grouped
in three great cycles covering Christmas, Easter and Whitsuntide.
Volume three has three of the offices from Whitsuntide or ‘Pentecôte’.
Office
No.40 presents a musical interpretation of the
Assumptio or feast
day celebrating the acceptance of Mary into Heaven. All of the five movements
are slow, sustained pieces, celebrating what can be seen as a joyous part of
the Christian calendar as a more awed, palpably wondrous but nonetheless restrained
ascension. Only the final vast rising chorale - one of the highlights of the
entire
L'orgue mystique - raises us beyond the more introverted but fascinatingly
dignified previous movements.
The enormous climactic conclusion to the first five-movement set is followed
by the
Office No.34 and the
Office No.35. These are less spectacular
than the Assumption Mass, and use Gregorian melodies which are less well known
as their basis. Gently conceived and relatively simple, the meditative
Offertorium movements
of both take the listener into beautiful, timeless worlds, and the atmosphere
of almost the entirety of this disc is rich in a feeling of piety and devotion.
The sense of medieval ritual is heightened still further in the bells which chime
through the
Elévation of
Office No.35, also appearing later
on as a richly sparking effect in the final moments of that work. As with the
Office
No.40 the
Pièces terminales of each suite provide the greatest
development in terms of musical material and imagery, that of the
Office No.34 concluding
with a majestic
Supplication et Fugue modale, that of the
Office No.35 being
entitled
Paraphrase-Carillon, and excitingly combining the hymn
Ave
maris stella in the treble with
Salve Regina in the bass. It is in
some of the more pictorial moments and exotic tonal relationships of this movement
that you hear the kind of influential sounds which helped the young Messiaen
on his way with his own organ music. This is a gorgeous organ CD in its own right,
and inspires through understatement and sincerely personal religious expression.
Volume 4 continues with three Offices from Whitsuntide, and the
Office No.21 which
belongs to the Easter cycle.
Office No.44 deals with the prophet Daniel.
Both the depths of desolation and grim fortitude among the ruins of Jerusalem
are expressed in reserved, slow moving pieces which unfold into some richly chromatic
harmonies. The
Communion is a fascinating statement, to my ears expressing
a longing to reverse the waste of destruction. The
Pièce terminale bursts
out with a
Chorale Alléluiatique expressing resurrection, as well
as the fragmentary waves of something more apocalyptic.
The
Office No.38 moves us back to the Old Testament, involving and invoking
texts which include the prayers of Moses. Low tones often emphasise a different
kind of mystical background in the earlier stages of this piece, and the
Offertorium winds
for almost half its length around a grimly held pedal tone. With the final
Choral
No.3, Tournemire combines a relevant religious hymn
I shall praise the
Lord forever, with the sounds of nature from his own environment; wheeling
seagulls and turning windmills. The
Office No.21 comes from Paul, and
is also descriptive of the first signs of spring. The
Pièce terminal in
this case is a compelling
Fresque Alléluiatique which defies the
finality of death;
“Knowing that Christ being raised from the dead...
death hath no more dominion over him.”
Office No.49 grapples with the dramatic story of Job, and manages to express
both grief and the defiance of faith. Imposing and intensely convoluted harmonies
are descriptive of anguish and fundamental strength on both sides, both human
and divine. The
Communion is a deceptively simple piece, which stretches
into polytonality and chromaticism in order to express Job’s double prayer
- that in which he prays that his prayers will be heard. The final fugue combines
the hymn
Ave maris stella in the treble with
Salve Regina in the
bass, a piece which seems to reach out, extending a warmth which welcomes, while
at the same time resisting the platitudes of superficial comfort.
Once again, Sandro R. Müller plays with a fine sensitivity to the musical
subtexts, and the Cybele engineers create a superb atmosphere from the Rieger
organ in Marienstatt. These are very well put together programmes which should
stand proudly at the heart of any good organ library. I keep emphasising that
collectors should have no fear of entering this world, but the fact is, good
recordings of these accessible and often wonderfully expressive and beautiful
works are rare. Some critics see Messiaen’s incorporation of religious
faith as an added barrier to their appreciation or non-appreciation of his music;
and with Tournemire’s highest musical goal being the glorification of God
then this may be a consideration for some. I don’t really feel this to
be a problem, bearing in mind that on the strength of that kind of thinking we’d
have to ditch most of J.S. Bach’s music at the same time. With these works’ substance
in the less bombastic aspects of the French organ tradition and their basis in
Gregorian plainchant, it seems to me remarkable that these works should be neglected.
The sheer quantity of this complete cycle is at the same time both its weakness
and its strength of course. It may seem a huge mountain to climb, but I for one
am genuinely delighted that there is so much yet to come.
Dominy Clements