Editorial Board
MusicWeb International
Founding Editor Rob Barnett Editor in Chief
John Quinn Contributing Editor Ralph Moore Webmaster
David Barker Postmaster
Jonathan Woolf MusicWeb Founder Len Mullenger
Buy
through MusicWeb for £12 postage
paid World-wide.
Baroque Cello Illuminations - shedding new light
on old favourites Henry ECCLES JUNIOR(1675/85-1735/45) Sonata No.11 in g minor, second
movement transcribed from Francesco Antonio
BONPORTI (1672-1749) Op.10/4/iv) [7:41] Willem de
FESCH (1687-1757?) Sonata in d minor Op.8 No.3
[11:23] Antonio
VIVALDI (1678-1741) Sonata No.5 in e minor, RV40
[11:25] François
COUPERIN 'le Grand' (1668-1733)Pièces
en Concert (from Les Goûts Réunis, arr.
Paul
BAZELAIRE (1886-1958) / Angela East) Prélude [2:14] Sicilienne [2:06] La tromba [1:33] Plainte [1:59] Air de Diable [1:40] Giuseppe (?) SAMMARTINI(1695-1750) / Martin BERTEAU
(1700-1771) Sonata Op.1a No.3 in G major [14:00] Johann Sebastian
BACH (1685-1750) Suite No.1 for solo cello in
G major BWV1007* [19:40]
Angela East (baroque
cello); Ruth Alford (baroque cello, continuo); Howard Beach (harpsichord)
rec. St John's Church, Loughton, Essex, UK, 17-19 May 2008,
* François-Bernier Concert Hall, Domaine le Forget, Saint-Irénée,
Quebec, May, 2001. DDD.
* Also available from Red Priest Recordings as part of the complete
Bach Cello Suites. RED PRIEST RECORDINGS
RP005 [73:42]
Buy
through MusicWeb for £12 postage
paid World-wide.
Red Priest - Pirates of the Baroque: Stolen Masterworks
and Forgotten Musical Jewels Jean-Marie LECLAIR(1697-1764) Tambourin [2:22] Giovanni Paulo SIMONETTI(alias Winfried MICHEL,
b.1948) Sonata in C minor Op.5 No.2, La Burrasca [8:23]
Tomasso ALBINONI(1671-1751) Adagio adapted by Remo
GIAZOTTO (1910-1998) [8:05] François COUPERIN(1668-1733)
Suite from Ordres assembled as 'Pirates of the Baroque'
by Howard Beach [18:05] Antonio VIVALDI(1676-1741) Concerto Grosso in d minor RV 565
[8:39] Tomasso VITALI(1665-1717) Chaconne [8:38] Giuseppe TARTINI (1692-1770) Senti
Lo Mare [3:43] Antonio VIVALDIConcerto in G, La Tempesta di Mare RV 433 [6:23]
Red Priest (Piers
Adams (recorders); Julia Bishop (violin); Angela East (cello); Howard
Beach (harpsichord))
rec. Champs Hill, nr Petworth, UK, November 2006. DDD RED PRIEST RECORDINGS
RP004 [65:02]
Though this is just as much about casting new light
on the baroque repertoire as Red Priest's other recordings,
I doubt that it will prove quite as popular as its predecessor
Pirates of the Baroque (RP004) - see above, also Robert
Hugill's review
- or Priest on the Run (RP001), Nightmare in Venice
(RP002) and The Four Seasons (RP003) - see Jonathan
Woolf's review
of the complete set. Indeed, as Angela East's website makes
clear, it is primarily intended for teachers and their students:
This really useful CD, full of pieces that teachers
love to teach:
- Brings together on one disc the most popular baroque works
played by young cellists
- Provides an opportunity to hear these works played by one
of the world's leading baroque cellists who is also an experienced
teacher
- Applies creativity to a base of knowledge about historical
performance practice in both the solo and the continuo cello
lines
- Will soon be available in sheet music format showing both
original and ornamented versions
All of which would seem to warrant that favourite word of students
everywhere - 'boring'.
So what, if anything, is there here for the general listener?
In fact, plenty. To begin with the most obvious, Angela East's
performance of the Bach solo Cello Sonata at the end of the
recital (trs. 22-27) augurs so well for her complete recording
that you may prefer to wait for that to appear separately. The
illuminations of the title are certainly present here, in that
she makes music which can sometimes sound merely intellectual
and academic genuinely affective. Of course, she isn't the
only performer to do so, but her performance deserves to ranked
with the best which, for my money, include Pierre Fournier (DG
Archiv 449 7112 or 477 6724, both at lower mid-price) and Paul
Tortelier (EMI GROC 5628782, mid price, or Classics for Pleasure
2283582, budget price). I haven't heard Steven Isserlis's
highly praised performances on Hyperion (CDA675412, full price),
which Dominy Clements made Recording of the Month in May, 2007
- see review
- but I can't imagine that his version of No.1 surpasses
East.
I can't pretend that the rest of the music approaches anywhere
near the quality or the familiarity of the Bach; to specialists,
this will, however, be corn in Egypt. The 'old favourites'
mentioned in the title are really only so for cello teachers
in much the same way that I might refer to Old English poems
such as The Dream of the Rood or the works of the early
15th-century poet-priest John Audelay as old favourites
- and leave everyone else shaking their heads in disbelief.
Be that as it may, I must admit that all the music here is more
likely to be attractive to the non-specialist than my two examples.
Henry Eccles, whose dates are so uncertain, was the youngest
significant member of a family of English musicians, including
his near-contemporary John Eccles who composed the Judgment
of Paris, recently recorded on Chandos Chaconne (CHAN0759,
strongly recommended in my May, 2009, Download Roundup). A violinist
by trade, he had moved to Paris by 1720, where he published
a number of Violin Sonatas. Sonata No.11, presented here in
a transposition, includes one of his numerous 'borrowings'
from the music of Bonporti - a common enough practice then,
though composers such as Avison at least had the decency to
transform the music which he adapted from Scarlatti. It's
attractive enough music, as is the de Fesch Sonata which follows,
though neither is going to set the world on fire, even in such
fine performances.
No recording on the Red Priest label would be complete without
music by the Red Priest himself, Vivaldi. His sonatas for cello
and basso continuo (c.1740) may be less adventurous and less
immediately interesting than his concertos, but still very attractive.
Angela East's notes explain the difficulties of interpreting
these sonatas and the solution which she has adopted. I'm
not qualified to comment academically on her solutions, merely
to say that the result sounds convincing enough to make these
tracks (9-12) almost as much a highlight of the recording as
the Bach which completes it. The jaunty performance of the allegro
second movement is already a favourite in our household.
The music by François Couperin has needed the most adaptation,
in that the originals were intended for the viola da gamba,
though they are often performed, as here, on the cello. East
employs her own effective adaptation of Bazelaire's reworking
of five of the pieces. With considerable assistance from Howard
Beach's harpsichord, these tracks, too, are very entertaining
(trs.13-17). I suggested above that Red Priest should find a
replica tromba marina and record Vivaldi's concerto
for that obsolete instrument; East has forestalled me by imitating
that very instrument in La tromba, the third piece from
the Couperin collection. The Air de Diable (tr.17) brings
the set to a close with something like the panache which marks
the Couperin adaptations on the Pirates recording.
Detective work has been involved in determining whether Sammartini
or Berteau was the composer of the Sonata on tracks 18-21, and
which Sammartini. East concludes logically that collaboration
was involved - the sonata has been ascribed to both contenders
- and that the Sammartini in question is most likely to have
been Giuseppe. It isn't likely to make it into Classic FM's
rather pointless top 100, but it's attractive music and
it receives as good a performance as it's ever likely to
receive.
With good recording throughout and an attractive presentation
- but did Howard Beach have to pose in such an 'interesting'
manner? - this recording will clearly find a market with cello
teachers and pupils, to whom it is offered on Angela East's
website at a special discount price for bulk purchases, with
a promise of the sheet music to follow. The notes are exemplary,
which should also help to broaden its appeal to the general
music-lover. Go for the Pirates and the other Red Priest
recordings by all means, but don't forget this equally valuable
CD.
Red Priest - Pirates of the Baroque: Stolen Masterworks
and Forgotten Musical Jewels
We seem to have received several review copies of this CD; it's
already been reviewed here by Robert Hugill - see review
- and by Jonathan Woolf, in the latter case alongside three
other Red Priest recordings - see review.
The three other recordings, on RP001, RP002 and RP003 are reissues
of CDs originally issued on the Dorian label but Pirates
of the Baroque is a new recording.
I'd heard several extracts on Radio 3 before receiving the
review copy and was expecting something a little too over the
top in places but, in the event, I very much enjoyed hearing
the complete recording - what may seem OTT heard out of context
fits seamlessly into the general treatment of the whole programme,
though that's not to say that this is a disc for the faint
hearted or the purist, despite the use of a Carcassi violin
(1741) and a Walmsley cello (1725).
The original Red Priest was Vivaldi; I think that he would have
been surprised at two aspects of modern musical criticism: the
separation of the 'popular' and the 'classical',
with the invention of a third 'crossover' category to
bridge the gap, and our obsession with deciding between performances
on modern and original instruments. There is evidence that he
re-invented some of his own music for different occasions -
several of the Op.10 flute concertos, for example, exist in
pre-Op.10 guise and music from The Four Seasons finds
its way into his opera Montezuma. Handel and Bach, of
course, went further, regularly 'borrowing' from their
own earlier works and rehashing; there is no one definitive
form of Bach's St Matthew Passion, much less of Handel's
Messiah or Il Trionfo del Tempo e del Disinganno/The
Triumph of Time and Truth.
Not all the music here is strictly baroque. There's a very
good reason why no dates are given for Simonetti, the composer
of the 'Sea storm' sonata (trs.2-5); the real composer,
as the booklet explains, is a contemporary early music specialist,
Winfried Michel. It's a pretty good spoof of a baroque trio
sonata with, as the notes say, 'an irresistible logic to
it', which is hardly surprising when his pseudo-Haydn piano
sonatas convinced even the great Haydn authority H.C. Robbins
Landon.
Nor is the 'Albinoni' Adagio a genuine baroque
work; in its present form it's a considerably elaborated
work for organ and orchestra by the twentieth-century Giazzotto
of an original which may or may not exist - probably not. Here
it's further elaborated by Red Priest, though in the process
they have removed a great deal of the overdone sentimentality.
The notes express the opinion that the new arrangement removes
the work yet further from any genuine baroque association, but
I'm not sure that I agree - removing the schmaltz,
I think, brings it closer to the spirit of the baroque.
Indeed, the whole recording is in some ways more 'authentic'
than the lumpen versions of baroque music which used to be the
norm. The various sins which Red Priest have committed in creating
these arrangements and performances are outlined in the booklet;
consider absolution granted, at least from this listener. I
just wish that those notes hadn't been printed on varying
shades of orange, which makes them hard to read.
I especially enjoyed the third combination of ancient and modern,
the suite which gives its title to the whole collection, Pirates
of the Baroque. If I'm honest I have to admit that Couperin's
copious books of Ordres for the harpsichord are best
taken in small doses and become rather tedious in CD-size chunks.
Howard Beach's arrangements for this recording are entertaining
yet faithful to the spirit of the originals; the performances,
complete with vocal renditions, are just right. On second hearing,
though, these vocal interjections become a little tedious, as
do the 'noises off' in Tartini's Senti lo mare
(tr.24).
The two Vivaldi works go well, too, in these souped-up performances.
I especially enjoyed the way in which the instruments scurry
after and around one another in the Allegro of RV565
on track 20 and the balalaika-like sound in the Largo
on the next track. The Concerto in G, RV433, which concludes
the programme, even has a nautical connection, since its title
is la Tempesta di Mare, or Storm at sea. If Red
Priest decide to do a Pirates of the Baroque revisited -
and why not? - they might well include the other Tempesta
di Mare concerto, RV253. And why not get hold of a working
version of that obsolete instrument the tromba marina -
literally 'sea trumpet', but actually a huge string
instrument - and record Vivaldi's concerto for that instrument,
RV555?
With forward recording to match the vitality of the performances,
being boarded by these pirates is a Jolly Roger of an experience.
Edward Teach, better known as Blackbeard, used to board ships
with burning fuses woven into his beard; this is the musical
equivalent.