Editorial Board
MusicWeb International
Founding Editor Rob Barnett Editor in Chief
John Quinn Contributing Editor Ralph Moore Webmaster
David Barker Postmaster
Jonathan Woolf MusicWeb Founder Len Mullenger
Bernd
Alois ZIMMERMANN (1918-1970) Requiem für einen jungen Dichter (1967/69)
Claudia
Barainsky (soprano); David Pittman-Jennings (baritone);
Michael Rotschopf (sprecher I); Lutz Lansemann (sprecher
II)
Tschechischer Philharmonischer Chor Brno (chor I); Slowakischer
Philharmoniker Chor (chor II); Europachorakademie (chor
III)
Eric Vloiemans Quintet (jazz quintet); Jan Hage (orgel);
Joao Rafael (klangregie)
Holland Symfonia/Bernhard Kontarsky
rec. 23 June 2005, Concertgebouw Haarlem and Dutchview,
Hilversum. CYBELE
860.501 [63:10]
Bernd Alois Zimmermann is a name to be
reckoned with in music of the 20th century and
beyond. It stands for something rather apart from the modernist
Darmstadt trends in post-war Germany with which it might
most immediately be associated. Zimmermann encountered
the music of Stravinsky and Milhaud while serving in the
army. After being invalided out of the army in 1942 he
was able to return to studies with Philipp Jarnach, also
attending courses given by Fortner and Leibowitz at Darmstadt
in 1948-50. From 1957 he taught at the Cologne Musikhochschule.
He ultimately rejected serialist orthodoxy, though his
opera Die Soldaten (1965), generally reckoned to
be his masterpiece, brings to a climax and by some accounts
closes the non-tonal Alban Berg line of operatic musical
history. The Requiem für einen jungen Dichter was
his last large-scale work. After its completion he suffered
a breakdown, eventually committing suicide in August 1970.
This recent SACD recording is significant
for a number of reasons. As the extensive score and stage
plans in the excellent booklet notes show, there are eight
tape channels - one on each side and corner of the performing
space. There are four choirs, front, back, and each side,
and the orchestra is widely spaced on the front podium.
My experience of such concerts is that one is always lumbered
with a seat too far from the ideal equidistant position
from each of these elements, and as a worst case, parked
under one or other speaker. With this recording you at
least have the luxury of knowing you have the best seat
in the house - every time. Even in stereo the music is
haunting, monumental, complex, dramatic, threatening, multifaceted,
many layered: the booklet notes promise those unfamiliar
with the work that “you will experience something never
experienced before”, and I have no intention of denying
this.
This piece is a deeply linguistic one,
and with Zimmermann’s tapes newly restored the voices and
effects on the tape create a chilling, impersonal atmosphere.
There are too many sources to list, but include Molly Bloom’s
Monologue from James Joyce’s Ulysses, papal addresses,
political speeches by Dubcek, Hitler, Chamberlain, Camus,
Schwitters. The literary or political quotes are in read
in German, but the surrealism of context, fragmentation
and juxtaposition creates its own atmosphere even where
the language might be beyond comprehension. There are moments
which remind one of that Number Nine track on the
Beatles’ White Album, and indeed, there is a fragment of ‘Hey
Jude’ towards the end of the movement. All of these quotes
and fragments are very usefully listed and time-checked
in the booklet notes. The disproportionately long Prolog/Requiem
I expresses the conflict between desire and reality
through quotations of the West German Basic Law set against
Mao Zedong’s Red Book. Freedom, ideology, liberation, human
dignity, struggle and death – all of these issues dealt
with in a vast dramatic canvas give some idea, it is to
be hoped, of the state of mind you will reach on experiencing
this initial Requiem.
The first Prolog/Requiem I is almost
equal to the time of the other five movements put together. Rappresentazione continues
the elongated choral chords, but has its emphasis on the
live musicians rather than the tape. The soloists sing
an Ezra Pound text concerning a threatened paradise on
earth, and pianos and brass push grand and dramatic sonic
gestures through static choral textures. This is followed
by a short Elegia, an island of peace in which the
soprano is accompanied by the jazz quintet. There is a
transition, Tratto, which brings us back into more
troubled musical worlds in the Lamento. Here another
apparent contradiction is at work, with an ecstatic expression
of the text, ‘Obituary for Sergey Yesenin’, which tells
of an ongoing suicide, or one about to happen. Rising choral
textures topped by sustained notes from the soloists and
percussion punctuation create a vast wave of sound which
has tremendous impact.
The Lamento is a powerful movement
in its own right, but also exists as a prelude to the concluding Dona
Nobis Pacem which re-introduces the fragmented and
overlapping speeches and musical fragments on the tape.
Some of these are World War II speeches which have their
own difficult associations, and add to an atmosphere of
violence and fear. The Dona Nobis Pacem or ‘call
for peace’ comes as a plea from the choirs, and the whole
thing builds to an incredible climax of quotes, cries and
imprecations both live and recorded, musical and spoken.
A montage of the sounds of political demonstrations frames
and dissolves this chaotic crisis, and is only followed
by a coda, a text from Konrad Bayer - repeated and thrown
around the auditorium, “..as everyone knows..” “Question:
What to hope for?” - not just these words, but a gradual
transformation of meaning like the traversal of a panorama
by M.C. Escher. The last questioning words are answered
with a final tutti, ‘Dona Nobis Pacem.’
As far as I can see, the only other recordings
of this work previously available were the 1989 Wergo WDR
co-production conducted by Gary Bertini, and the 1995 Sony
version conducted by Michael Gielen, to my shame neither
of which I know. What I do know is that on SACD
surround-sound stakes alone this recent Cybele recording
takes the laurels, revealing the all-important spatial
aspects of this piece to the greatest extent possible in
a domestic environment. This is not a piece for the faint-hearted,
and I could feel my face growing perceptibly longer as
the work progressed. Nobody is suggesting that the Requiem
for a Young Poet exists to bring cheer on a rainy day.
The spiritual and intellectual journey on which one is
taken is one from which the listener emerges somewhat wasted,
but emotionally moved and empowered. There aren’t that
many musical works and recordings which can lay claim to
being life-changing experiences, but this one certainly
holds that power for me. The performance is high-octane
and totally committed, and the recording in the Haarlem
Concertgebouw conveys the musical vibrancy of the performance
as well as the scale of the venue. This is no easy listen,
and you are free to ignore this release as being beyond
your usual brew. As a place to be, I will certainly be
picking my moments to ‘go there’ with care, but this kind
of thing was tailor-made for SACD surround fans who appreciate
powerful contemporary music. If you fancy giving your consciousness
a deeply serious kick up the backside then this is a tremendous
place to explore beyond the beige.
Reviews
from previous months Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the
discs reviewed. details We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin
Board
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to
which you refer.