Editorial Board
MusicWeb International
Founding Editor Rob Barnett Editor in Chief
John Quinn Contributing Editor Ralph Moore Webmaster
David Barker Postmaster
Jonathan Woolf MusicWeb Founder Len Mullenger
Giuseppe
VERDI (1813-1901) La Forza del Destino (1869 version)
Violetta Urmana (soprano) – Leonora
Marcello Giordani (tenor) – Don Alvaro
Carlo Guelfi (baritone) – Don Carlo
Julia Gertseva (mezzo) – Preziosilla
Roberto Scandiuzzi (bass) – Padre Guardiano
Bruno de Simone (baritone) – Fra Melitone
Duccio dal Monte (bass) – Il Marchese di Calatrava
Antonella Trevisan (mezzo) – Curra
Orchestra and Chorus of the Maggio Musicale Fiorentino/Zubin
Mehta
Piero Monti (Stage Director)
rec. live, Teatro Comunale, Florence, 2007
Region Code: 0; Aspect Ratio: 16:9; LPCM Stereo; Dolby Digital 5.1; DTS 5.1 Surround TDK DVWW-OPFORZA [189:00]
This fabulous DVD captures
one of those rare evenings when everything worked. The
singing and playing are fantastic, and the production is
faithful and unobtrusive. If you’ve ever found yourself
despairing for today’s lack of big Verdi voices or for
the horror of modern production styles then get your hands
on this for the perfect antidote.
Forza has always been a problematic
opera with its vast ranges of time and location. Any production
treads a fine line between believable characters and preposterous
melodrama. Zubin Mehta and Piero Monti present Forza as
a full-on, blood-and-thunder melodrama and the result is
powerfully compelling. The production is naturalistic
and traditional, updated to be contemporary with the 1860s
when Verdi was writing. The Marquis of Calatrava has a
quietly sumptuous bourgeois home in the first act, and
there is no doubt that we are in the Spanish mountains
for the tavern scene in Act 2 – we get authentic gypsy
costumes and even a gorgeous sunset behind the mountains. The
monks wear traditional habits in a monastery dominated
by an image of Christ Pantocrator, and the soldiers in
Act 3 wear uniforms consistent with the wars of the Risorgimento. To
under-score the point, Preziosilla finishes Act 3 waving
a massive Italian tricolour. In the final scene Leonora’s
hermitage is a cage which she cannot leave: she holds Alvaro’s
hand through the bars but even at the end they can never
be together. It all works tremendously well. There is
nothing here to distract you from the music, and plenty
to enrich your enjoyment of what you hear – and what you
hear is quite wonderful.
Those who think the
art of Verdi singing is dead will be silenced by this disc. Heading
the pack is the glorious Leonora of Violetta Urmana. Though
she began her career as a mezzo, she first sang the full
soprano role of Leonora at Covent Garden in 2004, and by
the time this was recorded she had the full measure of
the role. Her tone is ravishingly beautiful throughout. Her
Act 1 aria is rich and moving, and her prayer outside the
monastery is glorious: the rich arc of Deh, non m’abbandonar is
truly ecstatic, as is the way she rides over the chorus
of monks at the end of Act 2. Her intensely dramatic scene
with Guardiano shows desperation giving way to heavenly
consolation, while Pace mio Dio convinces that her
agony is still there, and she achieves a heavenly pianissimo
on her climactic top note. Opposite her is Marcello Giordani
making his debut in the killer role of Alvaro. His acting
is non-existent, but his singing more than makes up for
it. He is ringingly heroic in the Act 1 duet, and he scales
the arduous heights of O tu che in seno agli angeli with
clarity and focus. Opposite him is a young, exciting Carlo
Guelfi as the malevolent Don Alvaro. His voice is clear
and noble with impeccable diction, and his acting is surprisingly
convincing. We actually feel his character changing as
he goes through the whole gamut of emotions in the opening
scene of Act 3: Urna fatale even makes us sympathise
with him! He sings the part with dark malevolence, but
also an understated nobility which matches his character’s
misplaced notions of honour. The two men blend magnificently
in the three baritone/tenor duets, with Solenne in quest’ora particularly
moving. Bruno de Simone’s thunderous bass brings fitting
authority to Padre Guardiano, and there is a magisterial
grandeur to both his scene with Leonora in Act 2 and the
final trio. Gurtseva’s husky mezzo makes Preziosilla sharply
distinct from the other character, entirely appropriate
for this gypsy outsider. Simone’s antics as Melitone get
a bit tedious, but that’s more Verdi’s fault than his. All
the comprimario roles are cast from strength, even down
to the Mayor and the Doctor. The chorus sing and act most
convincingly: they make the move convincingly from raucous
gypsies to humble pilgrims in Act 2, and the scene in Army
Camp in Act 3 is good fun, enlivened by a full ballet,
amongst other things. Their singing contains Italianate
conviction and power, as well as inherent musicality.
Over all is the commanding
presence of Zubin Mehta in the pit. He conducts a forceful
and thrusting account of the overture, especially in the
surging strings, and this raises the temperature for a
full-blooded, headlong reading that barely lets up all
evening. Quite right too! If you’ve heard his classic
RCA Trovatore with Price, Domingo and Milnes then
you’ll know the excitement that Mehta brings to this kind
of music. The orchestra play out of their skin for him
and the score crackles with electricity. You can expect
the highest standards and not be disappointed.
The DVD production values
are very high, though there are no extras. Camera direction
is focused and appropriate, barring a couple of rather
ridiculous “arty” shots which distract only slightly. The
voices sound pretty close in DTS, with a lot of focus on
the centre speaker, while the orchestra tend to inhabit
the left and right channels. They are never less than
clear and you can hear everything that goes on, even some
irritating coughs in the quieter moments of O tu che
in seno agli angeli.
This, then, is a Forza for
our time,and one to come back to again and again. The
Leontyne Price/Levine collaboration from the Met on DG
will always hold a special place in collector’s hearts,
but Urmana is the better actor, and her voice is caught
younger and fresher than Price in 1984. There is also
an irreplaceable 1958 DVD of Tebaldi, Corelli, Bastianini
and Christoff from Naples. It’s like a message coming
from another world and is an unforgettable experience,
not least for the thrillingly heroic, if endlessly vulgar
singing of Corelli, but it’s not really one to return to
for repeated viewing. To my mind this set now leads the
field and takes its place as one of the great Verdi
DVDs. Buy it and revel in it: it deserves to become a
classic.
Reviews
from previous months Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the
discs reviewed. details We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin
Board
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to
which you refer.