Editorial Board
MusicWeb International
Founding Editor Rob Barnett Editor in Chief
John Quinn Contributing Editor Ralph Moore Webmaster
David Barker Postmaster
Jonathan Woolf MusicWeb Founder Len Mullenger
Buy
through MusicWeb
for £25/26/28
postage
paid. You
may prefer to pay by Sterling cheque or
Euro notes to avoid PayPal. Contact
for details
Franz LISZT (1811-1886) Great Liszt interpreters play Liszt
Lazar Berman,
Afred Brendel, György Cziffra, Emil Gilels, Vladimir Ovchinikov,
Artur Pizarro, Sviatoslav Richter, Earl Wild, Klára Würtz.
see end of review for details BRILLIANT CLASSICS 93786 [10
CDs: 698:04]
This
is pretty much a case of rounding up the troops. A look
at the head note will show some classic performances, others
rather wizened in years but still long on class, and still
others that are lesser known. Astute discographers will
note
that the process of rounding up also constitutes a sub-group
of Brilliant’s own catalogue. We’ve had the Klára Würtz
performances in a ‘Romantic Piano Music’ disc for example
[92122] and its extraction here is worthwhile; she’s a
much under-appreciated player and these recordings, made
in 2003, reflect well on
all concerned. Further digging shows that the Pizarro Hungarian
Rhapsodies can be found on 92790 and the Brendel Liszt
performances can be found in Brilliant’s huge box set devoted
to the pianist [93761]. And so on.
Earl
Wild’s disc derives from a 1968 Vanguard session called ‘The
Demonic Liszt’ though you wouldn’t know it from the notes
here – though to be fair all the recording dates are noted
throughout the ten discs. It’s predictably brilliant, full
of panache and brio - a fabulously voiced Réminiscences
de 'Robert le Diable' de Meyerbeer: Valse infernale prominently.
The Mephisto Waltz No.1 is every Wildeans ticket to ride
and includes his own sulphurous emendations. No reservations
at all.
The
second disc is shared between Lazar Berman and Richter.
You’ll
find the Richter performance of the Sonata on 92229, intense,
powerful, sepulchral, with passing digital imperfections
but vertiginous dynamic contrasts. Berman made a series of
fantastic Liszt recordings and these 1972 inscriptions are
exceptionally fine as are the ones in the later disc devoted
to him. He is virtuosic but astutely musical and offers
a powerful contrast to the next named musician. Because when
Cziffra comes on the scene fireworks are seldom far behind.
But these are his Hungaratons and not the EMI discs from
the late 1950s. He essays a barnstorming series of transcriptions
and paraphrases. His Grand galop chromatique is blisteringly
madcap, his Tannhäuser of greater clarity but not
necessarily greater warmth or impact than Moiseiwitsch’s,
and there’s a stunning if rather forceful Les Jeux d'eau à la
Villa d'Este.
Vladimir
Ovchinikov recorded his set of the Études d'éxécution
transcendante for EMI in the late 1980s. He has technique
to burn and these are, in the main, highly persuasive performances.
His Preludio is excellent, the A minor Etude dynamic
and intense and here and in Paysage his expansive
romantic cantabile delights the ear. Mazeppa is
impressive from any perspective and there’s commanding
authority in Eroica. Occasionally
he can be too plain – Ricordanza – but as a whole
this is a valuable retrieval. Pizarro’s two discs of Hungarian
Rhapsodies present occasionally father fuzzy recording quality
but good performances. He is splendid in No.5 finding its
hooded soul with unerring eloquence aided by a full and expressive
range of tonal colours. As with Ovchinikov there are times – in
Nos. 6 and 10 for example– when he lacks the kind of Cziffra-like
brio necessary.
Talking
of whom Klára Würtz’s Gnomenreigen is almost as
fast as Cziffra’s and her Mephisto Waltz No.1 is possibly more
searching as a performance than his, though less daemonic.
Her brief contribution to the box is powerful. Brendel’s
entire Vox, Vanguard and Turnabout recordings form the thirty-five
CDs of the ‘Brendel Edition’on Brilliant. They include the
four CDs’ worth of Liszt recordings he set down. Here we
have two but they are quite enough to convince anyone of
Brendel’s authority in this repertoire. Hard edged though
the recordings can be there’s no gainsaying the controlled
eloquence, virtuosity and phrasal assurance of Tremolo from
the Paganini etudes nor the immaculate Petrarch sonnets.
If his Sonata recording had been here as well that would
have been a clincher.
So
ten CDs, variously sourced, form the contents of the box.
The recordings range across the years and the labels. These
things are invariably difficult to adjudicate and recommendation
will invariably be personal. For what it’s worth I found
the box a well-chosen selection.
Jonathan Woolf
Track detail
CD 1
[55:03]
Réminiscences de 'Robert le Diable' de Meyerbeer: Valse infernale
[10:02]
Gnomenreigen [2:49]
Mephisto Polka [3:59]
Mephisto Waltz No.1 [10:39]
Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart (1756-1791)
Réminiscences de 'Don Juan' [17:04]
Charles Gounod (1818-1893)
Waltz from 'Faust' [10:10]
Earl Wild (piano) recorded 1968
CD 2 [65:16]
Années de pèlerinage - Book I: Suisse (Switzerland) - selection
Chapelle de Guillaume Tell [6:54]
Au lac de Wallenstadt [2:36]
Vallée d'Obermann [14:21]
Le Mal du Pays [5:30]
Les Cloches de Genève [6:08]
Piano Sonata in B minor [29:56] ¹
Lazar Berman (piano), recorded 1972
Sviatoslav Richter (piano) recorded 1965 ¹
CD 3 [79:20]
Paraphrases and transcriptions
Tannhäuser (Wagner) [17:35]
Rigoletto (Verdi) [7:27]
A Midsummer Night's Dream: Wedding March & Dance of the Fairies (Mendelssohn)
[9:51]
La Muette de Portici (Auber) [7:50]
Franz Liszt (1811-1886)
Grand galop chromatique [3:12]
Valse oubliée No.1 [2:49]
Waldesrauschen [3:59]
Les Jeux d'eau à la Villa d'Este [7:17]
Gnomenreigen [2:42]
Valse-Impromptu [6:50]
Hungarian Rhapsody No.19 [9:48]
György Cziffra (piano) recorded 1954-56
CD 4 [64:00]
Études d'éxécution transcendante
Preludio [0:58]
in A minor [2:06]
Paysage [5:31]
Mazeppa [7:28]
Feux follets [4:06]
Vision [5:33]
Eroica [5:13]
Wilde Jagd [4:54]
Ricordanza [9:20]
in F minor: Appassionata [4:28]
Harmonies du soir [8:54]
Chasse-neige [5:12]
Vladimir Ovchinikov (piano) recorded for EMI undated
CD 5 [74:36]
Hungarian Rhapsodies
No.1 in C sharp minor [13:04]
No.2 in C sharp minor [10:45]
No.3 in B flat major [5:07]
No.4 in E flat major [5:22]
No.5 in E minor 'Héroïde-Élégiaque' [8:48]
No.6 in D flat major [7:13]
No.7 in D minor [6:02]
No.8 in F sharp minor [6:23]
No.9 in E flat major 'Pesther Carneval' [11:52]
Artur Pizarro (piano) recorded 2005
CD 6 [71:07]
Hungarian Rhapsodies
No.10 in E major [6:09]
No.11 in A minor [5:41]
No.12 in C sharp minor [11:16]
No.13 in A minor [8:52]
No.14 in F minor [12:46]
No.15 in A minor 'Rákóczy March' [6:03]
No.16 in A minor [4:55]
No.17 in D minor [2:41]
No.18 in F sharp minor [2:54]
No.19 in D minor [9:50]
Artur Pizarro (piano) recorded 2005
CD 7 [59:04]
Waldesrauschen [4:04]
Gnomenreigen [2:47]
Liebestraum No.3 in A flat [4:13]
Mephisto Waltz No.1 [11:18]
Les Jeux d'eau à la Villa d'Este [7:40]
Piano Sonata in B minor [29:04] ¹
Klára Würtz (piano) recorded 2003
Emil Gilels (piano) recorded 1949 ¹
CD 8 [77:44]
Opera transcriptions and paraphrases
Lucia di Lammermoor: Sextet (Donizetti) [5:27]
Il trovatore: Miserere (Verdi) [8:13]
Norma Fantasy (Bellini)[15:39]
Oberon Overture (Weber) [9:05]
Benvenuto Cellini: Benediction and Oath (Berlioz) [7:20]
Tannhäuser: Pilgrims' Chorus (Wagner)[5:16]
Franz Liszt (1811-1886)
Paganini Études – Tremolo [4:40]
Octave in E flat [5:49]
La Campanella [5:02]
Arpeggio [2:10]
La Chasse [3:16]
Variations [5:14]
Alfred Brendel (piano) recorded 1955-59
CD 9 [79:55]
Années de pèlerinage - Deuxième Année: Italie
Tre sonetti di Petrarca
No.47 [5:58]
No.104 [6:02]
No.123 [6:59]
Venezia e Napoli – Tarantella [9:17]
Harmonies poétiques et religieuses
Invocation [7:10]
Bénédiction de Dieu dans la solitude [15:38]
Pensées des morts [11:17]
Funérailles [10:56]
Cantique d'amour [6:21]
Alfred Brendel (piano) recorded 1955-59
CD 10 [71:59]
Sonata 'Après une lecture de Dante' (from Années de pèlerinage II: Italie) [16:27]
Mephisto Waltz No.1 [11:09]
É tudes d'éxécution transcendante - selection
Prélude [0:45]
Paysage [4:47]
Feux follets [3:32]
Vision [4:06]
Appassionata [3:56]
Harmonies du soir [0:39]
Chasse-neige [4:40]
Rhapsodie espagnole [12:54]
Lazar Berman (piano) recorded 1950-67
Reviews
from previous months Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the
discs reviewed. details We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin
Board
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to
which you refer.