In this year’s
(2008) concert series the Langroise Trio gave us mostly
works of the Classical period — Brahms and Hummel
Piano
Quartets, the complete Beethoven
String Trios,
even a Herzogenberg
Trio. for
their fourth CD
1 (see
review of
an earlier release) they
are back, by popular request, with their more frequently
heard modern music repertoire (see a
concert
review including the Bartholomew and Earnest works
on this release). More
than half the music presented on this disk was written
in the
21st
Century,
and most of that is recorded here for the first time.
David Johnson’s
transcriptions for the Trio of works for two violins and
viola have always met with considerable success; the works
seem to blossom out with the additional lower sonorities. Such
works were often originally written for students so they
will have something to play along with their classmates,
so the music in its original form is admittedly compromised
and there is no primal sonic integrity in the original
version to be preserved. This particular work was played
in the second concert by the Langroise Trio that I ever
attended, and it doesn’t particularly “sound like” Martinů apart
from exhibiting that author’s typical lyricism and fresh
originality. The played it for us again last evening and
I was struck by the rarefied and cleverly parodied folk
music flavour of the last movement. Like all the music
on this disk the structure is basically tonal and, again
like most of the music on this disk, there are at times
a quirkiness, rhythmic innovation, and freshness that actively
engage the listener.
Greg Bartholomew (born 1957) studied at
the College of William and Mary and at University of Washington. His
sole direct contact with George Crumb appears to be his
participation in a composition workshop. Of his
String
Trio for George Crumb, Mr. Batholomew writes that it
was commissioned by the Oregon Bach Festival composers’ Symposium
in honor of George Crumb
2 on the occasion of
his 75th birthday and was premiered by the Third Angle
New Music Ensemble at Beall Concert Hall, Eugene, Oregon,
3 July 2004. A revised score was premiered in Chicago
on 20 April 2005.
The composer explains
that the first movement is constructed almost entirely
from the initial and final letters of Crumb’s name, the
pitches G,E,C and B (“
GEor
GE Crum
B”). The
second and third movements each extend 75 bars, marking
Crumb’s 75 years. The second movement is based on the “Sarabanda” theme
from Crumb’s extended work for electric string quartet
Black
Angels. The G E C B motif recurs in the third movement
but this time it is G# E C# B, “as the piece concludes
with a bit of fun.”
None of this gematria
would seem to be very musical, but the result is quite
beautiful, better than much of Crumb’s music. “G E C” is
the descending C major triad (G# E C# is the descending
C# minor triad), and much of the music sounds remarkably
as if it were written in the Renaissance. You will enjoy
this work immensely and want to hear more by this “youthful” (50
years old!) composer.
Pierre Max DuBois
won the first of two Prix de Rome awarded for music in
1955 which puts him in company with Berlioz, Bizet, Debussy,
Dutilleux, Ibert, Dupré; and Ernest, Lili, and Nadia Boulanger. He
studied at the Conservatoire in Tours, later at the Conservatory
in Paris with Milhaud; and still later taught analysis
there.
This
Suite
en Trio in four movements is reminiscent of Françaix
in its wacky humour and solid craftsmanship. There are
certain echoes of Milhaud also, but the work has a fundamental
originality and is very entertaining as well as being
stimulating and moving. The strong unison rhythms may
have influenced David Earnest, particularly in his
Third
String Trio.
Caldwell, Idaho,
in 2008 may not be quite so exciting musically as Vienna
in 1790 but the comparison is not so far fetched as you
might imagine. Here we have two world class composers
in David Alan Earnest and Jim Cockey regularly premiering
stunning new works. The Langroise Trio and its world class
virtuoso members are at the centre of this phenomenon performing
these new works both as the Trio, as the Trio augmented
with other soloists, sometimes accompanying Idaho Dance
Theater performances, as section leaders in the Boise Philharmonic
Orchestra, and individually as soloists in concertos. Recently
we have had works for string trio from Earnest, three Symphonies
from Cockey, Earnest’s Cello Concerto with Sam Smith as
soloist, and we look forward to soon hearing Cockey’s Violin
Concerto for Geoffrey Trabichoff. The interplay between
composers and performers is electrifying and mutually reinforcing. On
this disk we have recording premiers of two chamber works
recently premiered in performance by the Trio.
Most of us think
of “bathos” as meaning something absurd or vulgar. Specifically,
the Webster dictionary says “a ludicrous descent from the
lofty … to the commonplace ...” But in titling his piece
Isle
of Bathos David Alan Earnest is playing a game with
us, using bathos more in its original sense where
it merely meant descent from complex to simple or an abrupt
emergence of simplicity out of complexity. Admittedly
to those who don’t have the opportunity of hearing the
composer explain or read the program notes, the joke must
remain a private one, and Mr. Earnest is apparently satisfied
with that, letting most people think he is simply making
light of himself and his music. He explains that while
composing the work he was bombarded by too many ideas and
only by taking himself very lightly, humorously, could
he resolve them into a coherent structure. A further hint
at what this music is about are early titles for the work:
El
Extrano Espagnol, or
The Eccentric. But in
the end, music is music, and we expect too much if we demand
an explanation from the composer in non-musical terms because,
as Mendelssohn said, “…music is too explicit for words” and
a title is after all just something to put on the cover
of a score. And, however much the preceding may have assisted
the composer in overcoming obstacles, the result is a relatively
straightforward sonata movement based on rhythmic as well
as melodic motifs. In this as in the next work you will
at times find it impossible to believe you are only hearing
three instruments; this music has the sonic depth and textural
complexity you associate with string quartets or larger
ensembles. The Langroise Trio have an amazing ability
to produce a tremendously powerful sound without in the
least sacrificing beauty of tone.
Earnest was born
in rural Canyon County, Idaho, and obtained a Bachelor
of Music Composition degree from Wheaton College
3. He
writes music for a living in an amazing variety of forms,
including commercials, film and television scores, and
a very successful New Age electronic album, “Visit the
Blue Planet.” To listen to excerpts or for information
on purchase of his recordings, go to his
website.
Jim Cockey was
born in Baltimore, Maryland, but has spent most of his
life in Idaho. He holds a degree in Musical Composition
from the University of Oregon where he studied with Homer
Keller and Hal Owen. Cockey has worked with the Moody
Blues and the Carson City Symphony; his
First and
Third
Symphonies were premiered by the Boise Philharmonic
Orchestra and his
Second Symphony by the Billings,
Montana, Symphony Orchestra
4. Jim’s brother
Tim is the author of two series of popular crime novels.
The first piece
by Jim Cockey that I heard was his
String Trio #1:
Elegy
to an Ancient Battlefield performed at a Langroise
Trio concert. The composer had in mind the heroic struggles
of daily life as mirrored in great literature, specifically
The
Iliad. The overwhelming beauty and emotional power
of this work absolutely knocked my socks off. I immediately
wrote to the composer and subsequently obtained the only
recording of his music then available
5, a CD
of his first two
Symphonies which I also admire
very much. When Cockey received a commission to produce
a work for the Langroise Trio to play while accompanying
a performance at the Idaho Dance Theater, he decided that
since he had “done”
The Iliad, he would now “do”
The
Odyssey, a parable for life’s journeys as
The Iliad is
a parable for life’s struggles.
The result is
this work,
String Trio #2,
To the Wandering Hero
of Distant Lands. Its origin as dance music is evident
in all the movements. (I never saw the dance performance,
I was too ill to attend.) In the first movement, “???????” (“of
the man, tell me, muse,” the opening lines of
The Odyssey)
I see a vivid picture of Odysseus before the War, dancing
with his Greek male friends; everything is stirring, virile,
joyous, optimistic. They probably wouldn’t be wearing
white skirts and pompoms, perhaps wearing nothing at all. The
second movement, “Farewell Calypso,” is a lovely, sad adagio,
some of the composer’s most melodic music. “The Many Adventures
of Our Hero,” not the longest movement, is a vigorous,
active, musical picture, a sort of
En Saga for trio. “Ithaca,” the
longest movement is another adagio, uncertain anticipation,
tinged with a sense of nostalgia, perhaps homesickness. Finally “The
Hero Returns” is a vigorous, joyous polyrhythmic celebration
containing curious interruptions. The three strings manage
to sound like a full orchestra of instruments; you’ll swear
you hear brass and percussion. This is due not only to
the profound skill of the performers but also to the composer’s
experience with teaching violin and directing a string
orchestra.
At their first
concert this season the Trio played Cockey’s trios No.1
and No.2 in concert in succession as an experiment in collaboration
with the composer. The possible result of this will be
the publication of the two works bound together as a single
two-part string trio on “Homeric” themes. In the meantime,
by means of recordings you can listen to them this way
and make up your own mind. My own feeling is that the
works are best played and appreciated separately.
What distinguishes
these three pieces of 21
st Century music? Your
first reaction might be that they could just as easily
have been written in 1923. For some passages, yes, but
then some passages in Beethoven sound Rococo, some passages
in Bach sound High Renaissance. The musical experience
of the late 20
th century included late Shostakovich
(Earnest proudly acknowledges influence from Shostakovich,
but there is in his music none of Shostakovich’s pessimism,
only the wit, song, brilliance, and structural integrity),
late Stravinsky, and Philip Glass - Earnest and Cockey
might be surprised to have it pointed out how much their
most lyrical moments resemble Glass at his most lyrical. And,
the absolute death of dodecaphonic dogma has left modern
composers free to dally with tonal ambiguity, polymodalism,
and torturously complex polyrhythmic canons with an assurance,
confidence, a sense of
déja vu impossible in 1923. Also
there was a pervasive sarcasm in music in 1923 that is
now gone. Finally the recent explosion in interest in
World Music has re-established the connection to the Earth
which music requires at regular intervals. Think of [Gilbert
and] Sullivan’s music rejuvenated by the sounds from the
Japanese exhibition in London, Debussy bowled over by the
gamelan music at a Paris exhibition, Liszt’s and Brahms’ adventures
with Hungarian cabaret music, Carl Orff’s elaborations
on medieval manuscripts from Burana, Mahler’s exaltation
of the
ländler; and now Bollywood, Africa, and Heavy
Metal are in the mix. Also, we have returned to the direct
relationship between composers and their audience that
prevailed 300 years ago; these three composers will sell
their music directly to you and want you to tell them directly
what you think of it. The 21
st Century promises
to be musically extravagant and brim-full of greatness.
Paul Shoemaker
Footnotes
1. The first three recordings are in print and available for purchase from
swsmith@collegeofidaho.edu.
2. Besides
Black Angels, famously recorded by the
Kronos Quartet of San Francisco, George Crumb is known
for his orchestral work
Echoes of Time and the River for
which he won a Pulitzer Prize in 1968; I don’t have to
hear this work because the way you win a Pulitzer Prize
is to sound exactly like Elliot Carter. In 2001 a recording
of his
Star Child won a “Grammy” award for Best
Contemporary Composition. The Naxos website describes
his music as “hauntingly beautiful;” my observation is
that this is true of the
Three Early Songs (1947)
and
Dream sequence (Images II) of 1976.
Ancient
Voices of Children (texts by Federico Garcia Lorca
who is no longer around to complain) sounds to me exactly
like a mouse ran up the soprano’s leg and got into her
knickers.
A Little Suite for Christmas sounds to
me like a three-year-old doing terrible things to a piano
while crawling all over it. Perhaps Mr. Bartholomew’s
joke is that George Crumb would never have written a piece
so tonal and relaxed as his.
3. Wheaton College 25 miles west of Chicago is a Christian
Protestant evangelical university whose motto is “For
Christ and His Kingdom.” The music school stresses performance
is world renowned for excellence.
4. Many Europeans and Eastern Americans are probably bewildered
by much of what I have just written. When they were in
school the US Pacific Northwest was, at least musically,
a blank spot on the map. Never mind that violinist Louis
Kaufmann was born in 1905 in Portland, Oregon, and received
his early training there; or ditto with Yehudi Menuhin
in San Francisco in 1916. The (Portland) Oregon Symphony
was established in 1896 and the Seattle Symphony gave its
first performance in 1903. The Boise City Orchestra was
established in 1884, changing its name to the Boise Civic
Symphony in 1915. The Billings, Montana, Symphony Orchestra
was established in 1950. Compare these dates to those
of the Atlanta Symphony Orchestra (founded 1945), Utah
Symphony Orchestra (1922), Los Angeles Philharmonic Orchestra
(1919), Cleveland Orchestra (1918), and the Lahti Symphony
Orchestra (1910).
5. Since then the Langroise trio has released their recording
of
Ancient Battlefield on their third CD, “Pensiero.”