This remarkable oratorio was commissioned in 2001 by the Roman
Catholic Basilica of Saint Mary, Minneapolis, as a gift to
Temple
Israel Synagogue in Minneapolis. It was to be in time to be
performed in commemoration of the sixtieth anniversary of
the
liberation of the Nazi concentration camps in 1945. It was
also to mark the fortieth anniversary of the publication
of the papal
encyclical, Nostra Aetate ('In our Times') in
which the Vatican condemned the practice of blaming the Jews
for the death of Christ. The moving spirit behind this highly
symbolic gesture of reconciliation was Fr. Michael O'Connell
rector of the Basilica from 1991 to 2008 and noted for his work
in fostering Jewish-Catholic dialogue,
Before going further, can I commend to readers an extensive
on-line study guide
to the piece, which includes detailed essays, the full libretto
and a selection of audio extracts from the work? You won't
need to read it all - some of it is clearly designed to broaden
the knowledge of school-children about the Holocaust, for example.
However, the guide presents more information about the piece
than is contained in the booklet note - for example, I resorted
to the on-line search that led me to this guide because it's
not really clear from the booklet how much of the libretto is
Mr Browne's original text and how much of it is a synthesis
of other writings, say from scripture. The inclusion of audio
extracts in the on-line guide also offers an unusual 'try
before you buy' facility for prospective purchasers of this
CD.
To Be Certain of the Dawn was premièred in St
Mary's Basilica in 2005 by many of the forces that subsequently
took part in this studio recording, though only Christina Baldwin
among the present solo quartet took part in the first performance.
It's an ambitious work, both in terms of subject matter
and forces involved, though the full ensemble is rarely deployed
together. The idiom of the music is accessible and anyone who
responds to the music of composers such as Britten, Copland
or Tippett will have little problem with the musical language.
Tippett's name is particularly relevant because there are
distinct parallels between this new work and A Child of Our
Time.
The use of a chorus of children is a particular feature of the
work for, as Michael Dennis Browne writes in his booklet note,
the work commemorates the huge numbers of Jewish children who
were murdered in the Holocaust. I think that one of the greatest
successes - if I may use that term - in the work is the touching,
innocent music that Paulus writes for the children's chorus.
It's very moving to hear the children sing passages that
portray the innocence of the Jewish youngsters, who were often
ignorant of the fate that awaited them. It's clear from
the study guide that one important aim of this whole project
has been to increase awareness of the Holocaust among the young
of today.
In the second of the work's three sections, the four vocal
soloists have extended passages in which they assume the characters
of Jewish youths. These sections, which I suspect set original
words by Browne, are more variable in their impact. One such,
'Old Man, Young Man', a duet for baritone and tenor,
impresses but I'm less comfortable with an earlier duet
for the two female soloists, 'Two little girls in the street',
not least because the singers come across as grown ups trying
to sound like children. Perhaps 'Old Man, Young Man'
benefits because the excellent baritone Philip Cokorinos is
easily the pick of the solo team.
The adult choir has some powerful and dramatic music to deliver,
for example in the short chorus 'This we ask of you'
in Part II. The chorus sings well and incisively throughout
the work. Paulus uses a large orchestra, including what sounds
like a sizeable percussion section, and the Minnesota Orchestra
plays excellently, enhancing the strong reputation they have
built in recent years. The orchestra includes a shofar,
the ancient Jewish ram's horn instrument, which is heard,
briefly but tellingly, at the very beginning and near the end
of the work. Osmo Vänskä welds the substantial ensemble
together expertly and leads a committed and assured performance.
The work is rich in symbolism, as may be imagined, but one example
is especially potent. At three key points in the piece the words
'You should love your neighbour as yourself' are sung.
These words have huge significance because, as Paulus tells
us, they were inscribed in Hebrew and in German on the
only stone left standing when the Nazis razed a Berlin Synagogue
to the ground. Each time the words occur the same simple, eloquent
and very touching music is employed. The first appearance is
at the conclusion of Part I when the cantor intones them in
Hebrew over a soft orchestral accompaniment. The next time the
words occur is midway through Part II when the cantor's
intonation is accompanied by the main chorus singing them in
German: that's an ironic gesture and a moving moment. And,
perhaps inevitably, it's with a third appearance of the
words, sung by the choirs and the cantor, in Hebrew only, that
Paulus brings the work to a close. The peaceful, consoling way
in which these words are treated at the conclusion of the oratorio
holds out the hope of reconciliation. It's made all the
more moving because in the section that immediately precedes
it each of the solo quartet has a brief solo in turn in which
they sing a short phrase written by a Holocaust survivor.
As I said earlier, this is an ambitious piece. It's also
an eloquent and sincere work of art. At this stage, having only
listened to it a few times, I think that composer and librettist
have succeeded in achieving their aims but more listening is
required to make me sure of that. I am already sure,
however, that it's a thoughtful and thought-provoking piece.
I suppose the acid test will be the extent to which other performers
take it up and I certainly hope that happens because it's
clear that this deserves to be regarded as much more that a
pièce d'occasion. Its cause can only be helped
by this splendid and committed recording, captured in excellent
sound, and BIS are to be congratulated on their enterprise and
vision in issuing it. I urge you to hear it.
John Quinn