Editorial Board
MusicWeb International
Founding Editor Rob Barnett Editor in Chief
John Quinn Contributing Editor Ralph Moore Webmaster
David Barker Postmaster
Jonathan Woolf MusicWeb Founder Len Mullenger
Solo
Rumores
Arturo
MÁRQUEZ (b.1950)
Solo Rumores [3:50] Marcela RODRÍGUEZ (b.1951)
Entre las ramas rotas [6:58] Ramón MONTES DE
OCA (1953-2006)
Ecos del llano [4:03] Juan Fernando
DURÁN (b.1963)
Entonces el cielo se adueñó de la noche... [6:03] Hilda PAREDES (b.1958)
Sobre un páramo sin voces [5:12] Joaquín Gutiérrez
HERAS (b.1927)
Canto lejano [3:47] Paul BARKER (b.1956)
Pedro’s Progress [11:47] Laurie ALTMAN (b.1956)
Pedro’s Story [5:51] Alex SHAPIRO (b.1962)
Luvina [5:27] Zulema DE LA
CRUZ (b.1958)
Arenoso: No. 2 de Estudios sobre la tierra
[5:58] Silvia BERG (b.1958)
Dobles del Páramo [8:08]
Ana
Cervantes (piano)
rec.August 2007 QUINDECIM RECORDINGS
186 [66:06]
The
Mexican pianist Ana Cervantes, if not especially well
known on this side of the Atlantic, has won, in her own
country and in the USA, a good deal of praise for her
work, especially (but not only) in terms of her interpretation
of contemporary repertoire.
The music on this present CD is part of a project planned and carried
out by Cervantes which, with the support of various bodies,
has allowed her to commission a set of short works from
a number of contemporary composers. The project is centred
around the 1955 novel Pedro Páramo by the Mexican
novelist Juan Rulfo (there is an English translation
by Margaret Sayers Peden). Rulfo’s novel – his only one – is
one of the masterpieces of modern Latin American literature,
one that has been very influential. The novel is brief,
an account (though it is a novel of mood more than story)
of how one Juan Preciado returns to the hometown of his
dying mother, a town called Comala. He hopes to find
his father (Pedro Páramo) there, but finds himself in
a town inhabited entirely by ‘ghosts’; the bulk of the
narrative is carried by these spectral voices. Mixing
fantasy and an oblique kind of realism, the novel has
a very distinctive and special atmosphere. By the time
the novel ends one suspects that Juan Preciado himself
is also dead. The novel was much admired by Gabriel García
Márquez and was a clear influence on One Hundred Years
of Solitude.
Cervantes commissioned a group of composers to write solo piano pieces
in response to the novel. A first set of such compositions – including
works by Mexican composers such as Georgina Debrez, Eugenio
Toussaint and Federico Ibarra Groth, Americans such as
Charles B. Griffin and Anne LeBaron and Stephen McNeff
from the U.K – were gathered on a CD (which unfortunately
I haven’t heard) called Rumor de Paramo (also
issued by Quindecim). Now this second set has appeared,
drawing on the work of six Mexican composers (the first
six as listed at the head of this review), two composers
from the U.S.A. (Altman and Shapiro) and one each from
Spain (De La Cruz), Brazil/Denmark (Berg) and the U.K.
(Barker).
Some of the composers respond to the general mood or method of the
novel, such as Montes de Oca in his Ecos de llano (Echoes
of the Plain), with its imprisoning circularity,
challenged now and then by sudden bursts of energy, each
contained or defused by the music’s larger circle of
return; or Barker’s Pedro’s Progress, which the
composer himself describes as related to “the halting
and teasing structure” of the novel, as seeking to find
musical parallels for what Barker aptly describes as “the
sense of wonder without explanation” which characterises
Rulfo’s novel.
Other composers offer a response to particular details of the novel,
as in Marcela Rodríguez’ Entre las ramas rotas (Among
the broken branches) which articulates a musical
response to a single sentence in the novel, “Not a drop
of air, only the noise he had made echoing among the
broken branches”), doing so through some insistently
reiterated triplets and some expressive silences.
A third group of composers – such as Zulema de la Cruz and Joaquín
Gutiérrez Heras – seek inspiration in other areas of
Rulfo’s work, such as his short stories and his photographs.
In all his work, Rulfo’s vision is hardly easily comforting
or comfortable. Death and absence, desolation and poverty,
silence and ruin are his dominant modes and images. Most
of the music necessarily reflects such themes and attitudes,
so that listening to the CD right through can leave one
strongly seeking some ‘light’, literal or musically metaphorical.
Taken one by one, however, pretty well all of these pieces
have – certainly as played by Cervantes – an intensity
which compels attention. My own favourites included the
compositions by Rodriguez (the use of rhythm and of silence
particularly gripping) and Heras (visually evocative),
Barker (full of organic and accumulative power) and De
La Cruz (earthy in texture, with some aptly spectral
dance rhythms).
Ana Cervantes plays with a kind of audible concentration which compels
attention, playing with both power and delicacy as required
and with what sounds like a deep felt involvement with
the whole project. Perhaps this CD works best for those
with some knowledge of Rulfo’s work (and those who haven’t
any such familiarity could do worse than seek out Pedro
Páramo) but it isn’t, I think, dependent upon such
knowledge – it can be recommended to any adventurous
spirits who want to get off the beaten track, musically
speaking. This is profoundly Latin American music which
is yet largely free of the elements we normally think
of as characterising Latin American music.
Glyn
Pursglove
Reviews
from previous months Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the
discs reviewed. details We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin
Board
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to
which you refer.