Mirella Freni (b.
1935) made her professional debut
at the age of twenty in her native
town of Modena as Micaela in Carmen.
By one of those quirks of statistics
she was born in the same town and
in the same year as Luciano Pavarotti.
I have seen it both stated and denied
that they shared the same wet nurse.
In a humorous aside to the suggestion
she declared you can tell who got
most of the milk! After a break
for marriage and childbirth, a spell
in the Italian provinces and a season
with the Netherlands Opera, she appeared
at Glyndebourne in 1960 (Zerlina).
Covent Garden followed in 1961, La
Scala in 1963 and the Met in 1965
as Mimi. The renowned Karajan-Zeffirelli
La Scala production of La Boheme
was filmed and is now available on
DVD (DG 073 4071). Her Mimi is represented
in this collection from her 1964 recording
under Schippers (CD 1 trs.15-16).
She is light-toned and fresh-voiced,
innocent and very believable. Freni
recorded the part again under Karajan
in 1972 where her voice had developed
greater colour and her characterization
deepened. Matched by Pavarotti as
Rodolfo, it is a truly great recording,
being on Decca it could not have been
included here (Decca 421 049-2).
In the tracks of
Freni’s Zerlina from Don Giovanni
in the 1966 issue (CD 1 trs.1-3) her
then richer tone loses something of
the character’s naivety. Susanna stayed
longer in her repertoire, Freni becoming
a leading exponent of the role with
her secure tone, legato and excellent
range of expression all allied to
a pleasing stage presence. She appeared
as Susanna in Jean Pierre Ponnelle’s
Salzburg production conducted by Karajan
and at the Palais Garnier under Solti.
A 1976 performance as Susanna in the
Salzburg production is available on
DVD (DG 073 4034). In this collection
she makes a light-voiced, somewhat
naïve, Countess (CD 2 tr.5).
In the mid-1960s she made a number
of recital and complete opera recordings
for EMI whilst never being signed
to a contract with the company and
despite Walter Legge asking. Very
often these recitals were alongside
Nicolai Gedda as the ubiquitous tenor
and include rarely heard extracts
from La Sonnambula (CD 1 tr.4),
Lucia (CD 2 tr.12) as well
as a complete L’Elisir d’Amore
(CD 1 trs.11-14). Freni never ventured
far in the bel canto repertoire
although she sang in I Puritani
at the Wexford Festival of 1962 and
to acclaim in Rome in 1969 (with Pavarotti).
An excerpt from a 1965 recital is
included here (CD 2 tr.6). If anything
perhaps these reveal why EMI, perhaps
looking for a Callas replacement,
or happy with what they had on tape,
did not sign her. Whilst revealing
an easy grasp of the music and appealing
characterisation, Freni does not have
the dramatic bite, or vocal flaws
it must be said, of her predecessor.
Freni moved too quickly
to Violetta under Karajan. It was
a step too far too soon in a fach
that was not to be her metier.
With both conductor and soprano at
sea Anna Moffo was substituted for
her after a disastrous first night.
Freni returned to the role under Giulini
at Covent Garden in 1967 to modest
success. Although the role was never
one of her calling cards she recorded
it in 1973 with Franco Bonisolli as
Alfredo and Sesto Bruscantini as Germont
under the baton of Lamberto Gardelli,
who, like Giulini had the music in
his bones. The famous act 1 scene,
recorded in 1965 (CD 2 tr.7) exhibits
good characterization but not the
easy and wholly secure florid coloratura
the best interpreters bring to the
role. In the year of her Covent Garden
Violetta she recorded her first French
opera, Roméo et Juliette
with Franco Corelli (CD 1 trs
18-20). She is most appealing in her
phrasing and characterisation whilst
Corelli throws his voice at the role
more in the Italian manner than that
of a French tenor. The French repertoire
was to become a significant part of
Freni’s repertoire in the late-1960s
and early 1970s. For a period she
became the Marguérite of choice
in stagings of Faust. The extracts
here (CD 3 trs. 4-5) are taken from
the 1979 recording where she sang
alongside Domingo and her then husband
Ghiaurov. I prefer her even, girlish,
light-toned interpretations from a
1968 recital under Votto that was
included in EMI’s earlier collection:
The Very Best of Mirella Freni
(see review).
A true French tenor is heard with
Freni on her recording of Gounod’s
Mireille (CD 2 tr.17). More
from that 1979 recording could have
gainfully been included in this collection.
A standard recital item Depuis
le jour from 1964 and Manon’s
Adieu notre table from three
years later (CD 3 trs.12 and 3) are
appealing albeit that her French is
not perfect.
Despite the La
Traviata débacle Freni
never lost faith in Karajan and under
his guidance and persuasion she gradually
moved to heavier roles. He first tempted
her into Verdi with the offer of Desdemona
in Otello at Salzburg and the
associated recording made in 1973.
Knowing her own strengths, and keen
to preserve them and her career, she
asked for a year to prepare - and
with the right to refuse at the end!
The results are superb. Her Willow
Song and Ave Maria (CD
2 trs 1-4) with purity of tone and
legato convey outstanding characterization
of Desdemona’s uncertainty; frustration
and desperation pour out of every
bar. It is one of her finest achievements
vocally and histrionically. Perhaps
emboldened by her achievement Freni
sang Maria under Abbado in Strehler’s
memorable 1977 production of Simon
Boccanegra at La Scala (DG 415
692-2). Karajan tempted her further
into the lirico spinto repertoire
at Salzburg in 1978 and 1979 singing
Elisabetta in Don Carlo (CD
4 trs.1-2) and as the eponymous Aida
(CD 4 trs 4-11 and see review))
both featuring Carreras in the tenor
parts. Despite the conductor holding
the orchestra on a tight rein, both
soprano roles demand vocal heft a
little beyond Freni’s natural capability.
Being blunt, the only really true
Verdi singing in both those recordings
comes from Piero Cappuccilli as Rodrigo
and Amonasro respectively even though
Freni’s capacity with a Verdian phrase
is appealing. Perhaps unwisely, Freni
was tempted to sing Leonora in La
Forza del Destino for Muti at
La Scala in 1986 where her lack of
sheer vocal strength is exposed; her
phrasing became choppy and abbreviated
and the legato line broken (CD 3 trs.6-9).
Early in her career,
Freni’s concern in respect of appropriate
repertoire was evident in her attitude
to Puccini roles. Despite La Boheme
being her calling card, she was firm
in refusing countless appeals to perform
Butterfly on stage. She considered
it far too heavy for her and never
performed the role on stage; likewise
with the eponymous roles in the composer’s
Manon Lescaut and Tosca.
She did record arias from all
three in the mid-1960s (CD 2 trs.15-16),
(CD 3 tr.15) and (CD 3 tr.14). All
are vocally appealing without having
any particular dramatic distinction.
More appropriate to her, and far more
expressive in characterisation, are
her renderings of O mio babbino
caro from Gianni Schicchi
and Chi il bel sogno di Doretta
from La Rondine recorded in
1966. Also worthy of her skill is
Liu’s Signore ascolta and Tu,
che di gel sei cinta from the
1977 complete recording of Turandot
with Caballé and Carreras inappropriately
cast in the title role and Calaf respectively
(CD 3 Trs.16-17). Freni did make studio
recordings of Manon, Tosca
and Butterfly for DG and
Decca, the latter with Karajan and
alongside Pavarotti as Pinkerton (Decca
417 577-2). The only recording the
two made together for EMI was Mascagni’s
lightweight L’amico Fritz (CD
2 trs.8-11). The Modenese pair, both
in good lyric voice, make the trifle
more appealing than it might otherwise
be..
As Hugh Canning notes
in his informative and concise introductory
essay, in the last stage of her career
Freni did take on some verismo roles:
Cilea’s Adriana Lecouvreur
and Giordano’s Fedora. He also
learnt the three Russian parts of
Tatyana in Eugene Onegin, Joan
of Arc from the Maid of Orleans
and The Queen of Spades, all
under the tutelage of her then husband
Nicolai Ghiaurov. At the fiftieth
anniversary of her debut at the Met
she sang the final scene from Onegin.
Regrettably, her husband died shortly
before he could essay Gremin alongside
her. Freni’s awareness of her vocal
limitations greatly helped her long
and illustrious career on record and
in the opera house. Decca, for whom
she also recorded extensively, have
also issued collections of her singing
although none seem currently available.
Canning refers to
an interview with Freni on her 75th
birthday. In fact, at the time of
writing (2008), Freni born in 1935,
has not yet reached that milestone.
The essay is reproduced in German
and French translation. Most recording
details are given except in respect
of some of the 1966 and 1967 recital
recordings making me worry about record-keeping
at EMI. The La Sonnambula, Lucia
and Lodoletta recordings
are newly digitally remastered and
I believe appear on CD for the first
time. Worryingly, for the 1969 recording
of Mireille no venue is given
with producer and engineer marked
as unknown. I know EMI was a big player
with devolved decision-making to the
German and French branches. However
a look at the last marketing material
for the complete opera, and albeit
I had to get mine from America, would
reveal the venue as the Halle-aux–Grains,
Toulouse, with Eric Macleod in charge
and Serge Rémy the engineer.
The varying venues and their individual
acoustics are clearly defined with,
thankfully, no attempt at disguising
them.
The four CDs are
in cardboard slip-cases contained
in a rugged fold-over box faced with
a photo of the young Freni as Mimi.
Robert J Farr
Detailed track-list
CD 1 [75.43]
Wolfgang
Amadeus MOZART (1756-1791)
Don Giovanni,
Act 1. La ci darem
la mano…Batti, batti o bel Masetto
Act 2. Vedrai
carino
With Nicolai Ghiaurov
New Philharmonia
Orchestra/Otto Klemperer
rec. June 1966. No
1 Studio, Abbey Road, London [11.44]
Vincenzo
BELLINI (1801-1835)
Bellini: La sonnambula,
Act 1 – Son geloso del zefiro errante
with Nicolai Gedda
New Philharmonia Orchestra/Edward
Downes
rec. February/June/July/August, 1966,
location not known. [6.41]
Gaetano DONIZETTI
(1797-1848)
Don Pasquale,
Act 1. Quel guardo il cavaliere
... So anch'io la virtù magica
Act 3. Signorina, in tanta fretta
dove va ... È finita, Don Pasquale…
Via, caro sposino... Tornami a dir
che m'ami
With Sesto Bruscantini, Gösta
Winbergh
Philharmonia Orchestra/Riccardo Muti
rec. June-July 1982, Kingsway Hall,
London [18.18]
L'elisir d'amore,
Act 1. Chiedi all'aura lusinghiera
Act 2. Eccola ... Oh! quale accresce
...
Act 2. Prendi. Prendi, per me sei
libero… Ebben, tenete. Poiché
non sono amato
with Nicolai Gedda, Orchestra del
Teatro dell'Opera, Roma/Francesco
Molinari-Pradelli
rec. August, 1966, Opera House, Rome
[13.14]
Giacomo PUCCINI
(1858-1924)
La bohème,
Act 1. Sì. Mi chiamano Mimì
Act 3. Addio ... Donde lieta uscì
al to grido
with Nicolai Gedda, Orchestra del
Teatro dell'Opera di Roma/Thomas Schippers
[8.16]
Georges Charles
GOUNOD (1818-1893)
Mirielle, Act 2. La
brise et douce et parfumée
with Alain Vanzo, Chœur & Orchestre
du Capitole de Toulouse/Michel Plasson
rec. November 1979 (no venue given)
[4.36]
Roméo et Juliette,
Act 1. Voyens, nourice, on m'attend!
parle vite! ... Je veux vivre dans
ce rêve
Act 2. O nuit divine! je t'emplore
with Michèle Vilma; Franco
Corelli
Orchestre du Théâtre
National de l'Opéra de Paris/Alain
Lombard
rec. June/July 1968, Salle Wagram,
Paris [13.26]
CD 2 [77.32]
Giuseppe
VERDI (1813-1901)
Otello, Act 1. Già
nella notte densa ... Quando narravi
l'esule tua vita ... Ed io vedea le
tue tempie ... Venga la morte!
Act 4. Mia madre aveva una
povera ancella ... Piangea cantando
nell'arma landa…Ave Maria, piena grazia
with Jon Vickers; Stefania Malagu.
Berliner Philharmoniker/Herbert von
Karajan
rec. April 1973, Philharmonie, Berlin
[24.30]
Wolfgang Amadeus
MOZART (1756-1791)
Le nozze di Figaro,
Act 3. E Susanna non vien! ...
Dove sono [6.42]
Vincenzo
BELLINI (1801-1835)
I puritani, Act 2. O
rendetemi la speme ... Qui la voce
... Vien, diletto [7.38]
Giuseppe
VERDI (1813-1901)
La Traviata, Act 1.
E strano! ... Ah! fors'è
lui ... Sempre libera [7.34]
Orchestra del Teatro dell'Opera, Roma/Franco
Ferraris
rec. August, 1964, Teatro dell'Opera,
Rome
Pietro MASCAGNI
(1863-1945)
L'Amico Fritz, Act 1
– Son pochi fiori!
Act 2. Bel cavaliere, che vai per
la foresta ... Suzel, buon dì
...
Act 3. Non mi resta che il pianto
ed il dolore
with Luciano Pavarotti, Orchestra
of the Royal Opera House, Covent Garden/Gianandrea
Gavazzeni
rec. August-September, 1968, No. 1
Studio, Abbey Road, London [12.52]
Gaetano DONIZETTI
(1797-1848)
Lucia di Lammermoor,
Act 1. Ah! talor del tuo pensiero
... Verrano a te sull'aure i miei
sospiri ardenti
with Nicolai Gedda, New Philharmonia
Orchestra/Edward Downes
rec. February/June/July/August, 1966,
location not known [5.31]
Francesco
CILEA (1866-1950)
Adriana Lecouvreur,
Act 1 – Ecco! respiro appena ...
Io son l'umile ancella
Act 4. Poveri fiori
Orchestra del Teatro alla Scala, Milano/Antonino
Votto
rec. June, 1967, Basilica, Milan [6.19]
Giacomo PUCCINI
(1858-1924)
Madama Butterfly, Act
2. Un bel di, vedremo…. Tu, tu
piccolo iddio!
Orchestra della Radiotelevisione Italiano,
Milano/Leone Magiera
rec. January, 1966, Basilica, Milan
[6.58]
CD 3 [76.19]
Georges BIZET
(1838-1870)
Carmen,
Act 3. C’est des contrebandiers…Je
dis que rien [5.56]
Les pêcheurs
des perles, Act. 2. Me
voilà seule…Comme autrefois
[6.26]
Jules
MASSENET (1842-1912)
Manon, Act 2. Allons!
il le faut pour lui-même ...
Adieu notre petite table [4.07]
Orchestra del Teatro alla Scala, Milano/Antonino
Votto
rec. July, 1967, Basilica, Milan
Georges Charles
GOUNOD (1818-1893)
Faust, Act 3. Je
voudrais bien savoir ... Il était
un roi de Thulé...
Act 3. Un bouquet ! ... O Dieu!
que de bijoux ... Ah! Je ris
Paris Opéra Orchestra/Georges
Prêtre
rec. 19-29 June 1978, Salle Wagram,
Paris [11.17]
Giuseppe
VERDI (1813-1901)
La forza del destino, Act
1 – Ah, per sempre, o mio bell'angiol
... Pronti destrieri ... Ah! seguirti
fino agl'ultimi
Act 2. Sono giunta! ... Grazie,
o Dio… Madre, pietosa Vergine
Act 4. Pace, pace, mio Dio
with Placido Domingo, Francesca Garbi,
Orchestra del Teatro alla Scala, Milano/Riccardo
Muti
rec. 6-15 July 1986, Milan [18.35]
Giacomo PUCCINI
(1858-1924)
Gianni Schicchi, O
mio babbino caro [2.47]
Orchestra della Radiotelevisione Italiano,
Milano/Leone Magiera
rec. 11-12 January 1966, Basilica,
Milan
La Rondine, Act 1. Chi
il bel sogno di Doretta [2.37]
Orchestra della Radiotelevisione Italiano,
Milano/Leone Magiera
rec. 10 June 1966, Basilica, Milan
Gustave CHARPENTIER
(1860-1956)
Louise, Act 3. Depuis
le jour [5.55]
Orchestra del Teatro dell'Opera, Roma/Franco
Ferraris
rec. 7 June 1964, Teatro dell'Opera,
Rome
Pietro MASCAGNI
(1863-1945)
Lodoletta, Act 3. Ah!
il suo nome! ... Flammen, perdonami!
[4.50]
Orchestra del Teatro alla Scala, Milano/Antonino
Votto
rec. 6-7, 12, 14 June 1967, Italy
Giacomo PUCCINI
(1858-1924)
Tosca, Act 2. Vissi
d'arte, vissi d'amore [3.40]
Manon Lescaut, Act 2
– In quelle trine morbide [2.38]
with Orchestra della Radiotelevisione
Italiano, Milano/Leone Magiera
rec. 11-12 January 1966, Basilica,
Milan
Turandot, Act 1 – Signore,
ascolta [2.50]
Act 3. Tu, che di gel sei cinta
[5.07]
with José Carreras, Paul Plishka,
Vicente Sardinero Maîtrise de
la Cathédrale, Chœurs de l'Opéra
du Rhin Orchestra Philharmonique de
Strasbourg/Alain Lombard
rec. August, 1977, Palais de la Musique,
Strasbourg
CD 4 [77.34]
Giuseppe
VERDI (1813-1901)
Don Carlo,
Act 1 – Io vengo a domandar
Act 4 – Tu che le vanità
with José Carreras [15] Berliner
Philharmoniker/Herbert von Karajan
rec. Sept.1978, Philharmonie, Berlin.
[23.35]
Aida,
Act 1, Ritorna vincitor!
Act 3, Qui Radamés verrà!
... O Patria mia… Ciel! mio padre…
Riverdrai le foreste imbalsamate…
Pur ti riveggo, mia dolce Aida… Nel
fiero anelito di nuova Guerra.. Fuggiam
gli ardori inospiti ... La, tra foreste
vergini… Ma dimmi; per qul via
Act 4, La fatal pietra sovra me
sì chuise ... Immensa Ftha…–
O terra addio
With José Carreras and other
cast members, Wiener Philharmoniker/Herbert
von Karajan
rec. May, 1979, Musikvereinsaal, Vienna.
[49.07]
Giacomo PUCCINI
(1858-1924)
Puccini: Suor Angelica
– Senza mamma
with Orchestra del Teatro dell'Opera,
Roma/Franco Ferraris
rec. 8 August, 1964, Teatro dell'Opera,
Roma