Often
the spontaneity that results from a live performance more
than compensates for any minor fluffs or less than ideal
recording conditions. This is certainly the case here with
the Philharmonia Orchestra on sparkling form for its Principal
Guest Conductor, Sir Charles Mackerras. And this records
just one performance, not an edit of a few. Accordingly it
has absolute integrity of continuity. The opening horns’ theme
is smooth but pacy, setting the tone for a sunny, smiling
Andante introduction
yet with a lithely expressive violas and cellos’ expansion.
The grand ensuing
tuttis are firm but the woodwind
responses still genial and the progression never falters.
The violins’ accompanying triplet figures are zesty and the
crescendo leading
into the
Allegro main body of the movement (tr. 1
2:54) is exciting. The first theme is disciplined but not
solid, so invigorating flares of sound are created. The second
theme (3:48) is purposeful. The significant trombones’ presentation
at 4:58 of a motif based on the horns’ theme in the introduction
begins warm and soft against skipping strings. Everything
evolves stimulatingly and the gradations of the long
crescendi and
climaxes are finely judged. The coda (13:55), marked faster,
is not notably so but does begin pleasingly lightly while
the return of the horns’ theme is admirably firm,
ben
marcato indeed. It’s just a touch more measured and the
closing triplets on horns and trombones are splendidly emphatic.
I
compared Mackerras’s 1987 studio recording with the Orchestra
of the Age of Enlightenment (Virgin 5618062), the first recording
on period instruments. Here are the comparative timings,
the bracketed ones are the actual music time before applause
Timings
|
I
|
II
|
III
|
IV
|
Total
|
Signum
2006
|
15:58
|
14:08
|
13:40
|
15:16 (14:46)
|
59:04 (58:34)
|
Virgin
1987
|
16:24
|
13:58
|
13:38
|
15:25
|
59:35
|
The
1987 Mackerras, recorded in the more glowing ambience of
the EMI Abbey Road Studio 1 than the 2006 Queen Elizabeth
Hall, has a more stately manner in the introduction while
the
Allegro is similarly a more majestic, formal parade.
The trombone entries are more sombrely pointed. The elements
of the build-up in the development are admirably clear and
after its climax there’s an appreciably reflective becalming
to the recapitulation. In the coda the return of the opening
theme is presented at a spanking pace without change of tempo,
which I prefer. Overall, however, the 2006 account is more
animated with more emphasis in the introduction on melody
and flow, more energy in the
Allegro, a more chirrupy
second theme, a more dramatic though less clearly analytical
development. The recapitulation has a softer focus, stealing
in quietly, almost unobtrusively at 10:26. In the coda the
tiered build ups have more edge. But the approach is essentially
the same. The period trombones are more penetrating, the
modern ones blend more smoothly with the other brass, but
Mackerras obtains precise articulation from both orchestras.
The
slow movement (tr. 2) comes across as a journey of different
moods and reflections more clearly in 2006 than I can remember
having heard before. Whereas the 1987 opening is stealthy
and followed by an attractively curvaceous oboe solo, the
2006 opening is more inviting with a more carefree, less
knowing oboe, yet with a momentarily tender later, quieter
element before a brusque very loud
tutti interruption
colourfully delivered here. The 2006
tuttis are more
boisterous than in 1987. The second theme (3:12) is more
homely, with more relaxed warmth than in 1987 and its tendency
to a more rapt mood is crystallized in a horns’ duet (5:08),
slightly broader than in 1987, in which Mackerras seems almost
able to suspend time. The return of the opening theme is
transformed into something comelier now with first violins’ dancing
accompaniment but the
tutti retorts have still greater
vigour with added exchange of fanfares between trumpets and
horns, grimmer and more exciting than in 1987, before a different
suspension of time, a stunning and frightening silence at
8:39. The ensuing theme for cellos derived from the opening
theme is a soberly expressive response, sketching more eloquent
feeling and wistfulness than the more simply mournful 1987,
before a chastened and thoughtful return of that opening.
In the meantime, however, Mackerras has fully savoured the
delicious violins’
pizzicato from 11:06 below the
woodwind melodic focus. This sensitivity to Schubert’s varied
and added detail as the movement evolves much enhances your
experience of it.
The
third movement almost becomes an anthology of dance. To its
Scherzo (tr. 3) Mackerras brings a vigorous dance to start
with the strings’ proposal and cheery woodwind response,
but from 0:23 a graceful mini waltz tag with violins tailed
by cellos in sinuously supple articulation. In the second
section at 1:36 a nonchalant waltz snippet is pitted more
directly against the clodhopping elements before a much freer
and airier one from 1:50 and from 3:10 the earlier mini waltz
returns at its most dainty and luxuriant. The whole has a
vibrant pulse and again finely graded dynamics, not just
a matter of interpretive exactness but relished as a key
element of the life of the music.
There’s
a sense of sumptuousness and greater glow about the Trio
which, while at the same basic pulse, seems more measured
because of its slower rhythms and in particular absence of
the Scherzo’s running quavers. The Trio is the most extended
waltz with the sunshine created by light brass backing. And
Mackerras’s scrupulous attention to dynamics shows gentleness
to be at its heart. Another lovely detail enjoyed is the
double basses’ chromatic descent combined with
crescendo and
then sudden
piano (8:07). Again this 2006 Mackerras
has more liveliness, more feel of movement and atmosphere
about it. The 1987 is more a neat distillation of the dance
elements and transparent evolution of the movement with the
short waltzes more laid-back. Indeed you’re more aware in
the second section of the Scherzo of the paring down to basic
rhythm before the return of the mini waltz.
From
the outset of the finale (tr. 4) taken at a true
Allegro
vivace Mackerras enjoys the contrast of exuberant brass
and feathery violins, the latter nevertheless soon starting
a great swirl of activity in triplets. The 2006 opening has
more bounce and weight and there’s more of a feel of sheer
flight when the triplets start yet the 1987 opening has an
attractive fizz and whirligig abandon in its lighter but
penetrating articulation. The second theme, the one beginning
with four identical notes (1:41), is blithely presented in
2006 by woodwind and horns against fetchingly skittering
first violins and violas and Mackerras makes the whole seem
to evolve so naturally, again by carefully observing its
tiering of dynamics. From the Philharmonia this is both a
festive and virtuoso display with more swing than the smoother
OAE here, though they find a joyous lilt. The quotation on
clarinets at the beginning of the development of Beethoven’s
Ode
to joy (7:25) is smooth yet rather rarefied but the following
crescendo soon
finds the brass pounding away at Schubert’s repeated note
motif. It’s the strings who have the last spotlight on this
and their stomping
sforzando Cs from 13:47, backed
by horns and bassoons, are splendidly firm without being
stodgy and again weightier than in 1987, though in elan there’s
little to choose between the two performances. 1987 has an
attractively lucid presentation of the recapitulation in
terms of its place in the scheme of things, in 2006 the emphasis
is rather on its irresistible energy.
In
sum the 1987 Mackerras is clearer for studying the elements
of the work and its structure, but this 2006 Mackerras gives
you a more rounded experience of the whole symphony, its
effectiveness, life and colour. Here is everything you’d
expect from Indian summer Mackerras: lively, rhythmically
crisp, melodically well shaped, precise in dynamics and with
all repeats observed except, as normal practice, not those
in the Scherzo
da capo. The recording is fresh and
clear, very bright in the brass but not glaring. Only when
the music stops do you become aware of the audience. You
are grateful for this but even more for a performance of
consummate skill.
Michael
Greenhalgh