Editorial Board
MusicWeb International
Founding Editor Rob Barnett Editor in Chief
John Quinn Contributing Editor Ralph Moore Webmaster
David Barker Postmaster
Jonathan Woolf MusicWeb Founder Len Mullenger
Buy
through MusicWeb for £12.50 postage
paid World-wide.
Diversity - Amrywiaeth John METCALF (b.1946)
Light Music (1997) [11:04] Alun HODDINOTT (1929-2008)
Sonata (2004) [13:18] Brian HUGHES (b.1938)
Arithmetical Bagatelles (1999) [9:32] Jeffrey LEWIS (b.1942)
Night Fantasy (1996) [16:39] John HEARNE (b.1937)
Solemn and Strange Music (1998) [10:27] Pwyll ap SION (b.1968)
Emyn (Hymn) [12:10]
Helen
and Harvey Davies (piano, four hands)
rec. Ty Cerdd, Millennium Centre, Cardiff, 17-18 September
2007 CAMPION
CAMEO 2073 [73:40]
This is another one of those discs from Campion which gives
a good feeling right from the start, and carries on giving,
beyond the lovely photo of Abermenai Point by Glyn Davies
on the cover and into an invigorating programme from start
to finish. As the booklet notes declare with some accuracy,
the piano duet is a rather neglected medium for contemporary
composers. Long gone are the days when family and friends
made music around the piano together in the drawing room,
and long gone are the days when composers wrote the kind
of music family and friends would want to, or be able to
play. Helen and Harvey Davies are helping to revive the
concert piano duet by commissioning duets by composers
who are Welsh, or have connections to Wales.
The title Light Music ironically refers to a general
sense of ‘lightness of being’, and while John Metcalf casts
a spell of classically transparent, bright and rhythmic
music over its 11 minutes, the composition is serious in
intent. There are five variations here, which run continuously
and have a refined sense of continuity. As a welcome mat
for the rest of the programme, this is an invitation which
is very hard to resist indeed.
Alun Hoddinott’s seven solo piano sonatas are powerful statements
in their own right, and the 2004 Sonata for Four Hands has
plenty of that grand depth of purpose which characterises
his best work. While the work is one of great substance
and intensity, none of the four movements go beyond an
early-classical proportion of relative brevity and compactness.
The significant themes and harmonies of a mysteriously
developing first movement are taken over by fast second,
which is scherzo in character, and demands considerable
virtuosity from the players. With a conclusion of this
movement which refers back to the opening moderato, the
sense of architecture in the piece takes on a Palladian
clarity of proportion. The conclusion of this first ‘arch’ is
like the base of one column, introducing an Adagio third
movement which forms the emotional core of the piece. The
finale, a ‘con brio’, draws together threads from each
of the previous movements, and places us firmly on a triumphant
pinnacle.
Like Ligeti’s ‘Bagatelles’, Brian Hughes’s six Arithmetical
Bagatelles explore intervals. While the opening and
closing repeated notes might recall the Hungarian master’s
work, the rest is of course in Hughes’s typically attractive
personal idiom, which has an essential lyricism at its
heart. Hughes takes the opportunity to work with the
rhythmic potential of the piano, and there are some superbly ‘funky’ movements
which drive on with striking energy, though the metre
and pulse of the music is, as the title suggests, often
broken up and rendered unpredictable. The ‘bluesy’ central
movement has a great sense of space, and a subtle swagger.
One movement involves no notes at all, the wood of the
instrument being tapped in a nice rhythmic invention.
This is a marvellous collection, and entirely approachable.
Night Fantasy by Jeffrey Lewis seems to expand the piano almost from the start, some
of the gestures utilising the entire range of the instrument.
Lewis’s music is described “a celebration of harmony” by
Harvey Davies, and the steadily developing and shifting
chords certainly have a potent resonance, though easy tonalities
are masked by ambiguities and modal obstacles. The nocturnal
elements are provided by a kind of hypnotic, if unpredictable
repetition of a kind of rich and ever-varying passacaglia,
and the night is certainly not one without event – the
tolling of a massive bell for one. The atmosphere of this
piece is to a certain extent continued in John Hearne’s Solemn
and Strange Music. This piece, as its title announces,
has references to Shakespeare’s ‘The Tempest’ at its centre,
and the ‘Solemn and Strange Music’ is a famously enigmatic
stage direction in Act III. The subsequent quotations are
given in the booklet, and Hearne’s purpose and design is
both effective and clear. Hearne plays with psychological
effects, such as stretching the octave in the upper voice
against the bass – confusing the ‘innocent ear’ into thinking
it is in tune. The programmatic nature of the music doesn’t
make it less valid without knowledge of the literary references,
but the ‘educated ear’ would no doubt suspect that some
kind of commentary is going on. The piece is full of intriguing
sonorities and effects, and stands very well in its own
right.
Pwyll ap Sion freely states that his music is “based on,
or inspired by, music written by other composers.” In this
case Emyn, or ‘Hymn’ has its origins in John Hughes’ hymn ‘Arwelfa’,
although this tune is only really glimpsed in a fragmentary
sense. The idiom might be said to have some relation to
the American styles of John Adams, and even that of Aaron
Copland in the open harmonies and intervals of the slow
central section. The final section has some of that funky
rising bass that we love in the final section of Steve
Reich’s ‘Electric Counterpoint’, the excitement being heightened
by some energetic page turning caught by the microphones.
The technical and musical vibe in this programme is second
to none, and the recording is also excellent. Cardiff’s
quayside has been entirely transformed since I saw it last
in the grim 1980s, and the Millennium Centre proves to
have excellent facilities when it comes to recording. This
is a superb disc, and world class in terms of production,
programme and performance.
Reviews
from previous months Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the
discs reviewed. details We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin
Board
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to
which you refer.