Editorial Board
MusicWeb International
Founding Editor Rob Barnett Editor in Chief
John Quinn Contributing Editor Ralph Moore Webmaster
David Barker Postmaster
Jonathan Woolf MusicWeb Founder Len Mullenger
Regionals 2008 Eric BALL (1903-1989) Festival Music [15:22] Gilbert VINTER (1909-1969) James Cook – Circumnavigator [10:45] Kenneth DOWNIE (b.
1946) Three Part Invention [11:21] Paul LOVATT-COOPER The Dark Side of
the Moon [12:46] Rodney NEWTON (b.
1945) Four Cities Symphony [11:25]
Black Dyke
Band/Dr. Nicholas Childs
Cory Band/Dr. Robert Childs
Whitburn Band/Duncan Beckley
rec. Morley
Town Hall, 12 July 2007 (Festival Music and The
Dark Side of the Moon); Ysgol Gyfun Rhydywaun, Aberdare,
3 June 2007 (James Cook – Circumnavigator and Four
Cities Symphony); The Regal Theatre, Whitburn, 1 July
2007 (Three Part Invention). DDD DOYEN DOYCD238 [62:07]
Every year five test pieces
are played by the competing bands in the annual round of
Regional Brass Band Championships. If there is one thing
that is virtually guaranteed for specialist brass band label
Doyen, it is that its year on year release of the five pieces
will be one of its most successful CDs of the year in terms
of sales.
Every
competitive band in the country is eager to gain a regional
qualification spot for the finals of the National Brass Band
Championships of Great Britain later in the year. It is a
sure bet that bandsmen and women up and down the country
will be keen to hear what is in store for them as rehearsals
for the March “regionals” begin in earnest following the
customary Christmas sabbatical.
A
quick glance at the website of Doyen’s parent company, World
of Brass, confirms that for some time after its release,
this year’s Regionals 2008 topped its sales chart
both in terms of the CD itself as well as downloads from
the recently launched World
of Brass download site.
A
good part of the attraction is the opportunity to hear the
pieces played (including those for the lower sections) by
bands of world class repute. This year is no exception with
politically correct three nation representatives from England,
Wales and Scotland in the form of Black Dyke, Cory and Whitburn
respectively.
The
Championship Section work, Eric Ball’s Festival Music,
was written as the test piece for the National Championship
Finals in 1956. For a Salvationist composer whose somewhat
backward-looking language was generally steeped in Elgar,
it is Mozart that Ball here turned to for his inspiration,
in what was the bicentennial year of Mozart’s birth. Cast
in three movements, Overture, Romance and Impromptu,
the work is not entirely pastiche, still retaining Ball’s
trademark Elgarian harmonic palette. In keeping with Ball’s
almost legendary skill in scoring for band, the work is beautifully
crafted. Over fifty years after its composition it will still
prove a stern test to bands in its expressive and musical
demands, despite its oddly quaint aura. Black Dyke here gives
a characterful reading that emphasises the exceptional quality
of the band’s soloists.
Outside
the world of brass bands Gilbert Vinter was closely linked
with the BBC, where he was employed as a conductor with the
BBC Light Orchestra for many years. Throughout this period
he wrote a steady stream of works for brass band including
numerous test pieces as well as a number of appealing, shorter
concert pieces. James Cook – Circumnavigator was the
last of his pieces for band, written in celebration of the
Captain Cook Bicentenary and completed just months before
his death. Of all Vinter’s major band works this is arguably
his most overtly pictorial in its imaginative, seafaring
scene painting. Robert Childs and the Cory Band are certainly
the masters of the seas in the excellent performance committed
to disc here. As a work for First Section bands, James
Cook could well prove to be a very tough proposition
indeed. The piece is still capable of testing bands at the
very highest level.
Like
Eric Ball, Kenneth Downie is a composer whose roots lie within
the Salvation Army. Also like Ball, his “traditional” language
has broad appeal within the brass band movement. His output
includes a large amount of devotional music in addition to
his expanding catalogue for brass band. In comparison to
several of Downie’s recent major works for band including St.
Magnus, Visions of Gerontius and The Promised Land, Three
Part Invention is a somewhat quirky, light-hearted affair.
It should prove to be an enjoyable test to prepare for the
Second Section bands involved, albeit with relatively little
for the respective band’s solo instrumentalists to get their
teeth into. Duncan Beckley and Whitburn Band capture the
spirit of the music well, in particular the affecting central Romance that
is very much the heart of the work.
Paul
Lovatt-Cooper is a member of the Black Dyke percussion section,
as well as being a composer with a fast growing reputation
in the brass band world. The Dark Side of theMoon is
the only work amongst this year’s regional test pieces that
was not written specifically for contest performance. It
draws heavily on the influence of film music, notably John
Williams, with melodies that recollect the big tunes from
scores such as Jurassic Park frequently coming to
the fore. The big-boned style of the piece will appeal to
the Third Section bands preparing it. This could well be
the first of other Lovatt-Cooper scores to appear in contest
performance in the near future. Appropriately it is the composer’s
own band, Black Dyke that gives the stirring performance
here.
Commissioned
from Rodney Newton specifically for this year’s Regional
Fourth Section contests, Four Cities Symphony paints
musical impressions of London, Paris, Rome and Moscow. Its “bespoke” approach
has enabled the composer to create a piece that effectively
tests the basics of intonation, ensemble and musicality in
a way that should give the competing bands plenty to think
about as well as enjoy. Newton is a composer capable of producing
music of far greater sophistication than this, although writing
for bands at this level of ability is an art that not all
possess by any means. Cory and Robert Childs enjoy a close
working relationship with Rodney Newton and the competing
bands should learn much from listening to the stylistic elements
of Cory’s recording.
If
there is a disconcerting element to this recording it is
the stark contrast between the acoustic qualities of the
various recording venues. It would be a task beyond practicality
to bring the various bands together in one venue although
it must be said that the option remains to record just one
band, in one venue playing all of the pieces. The most startling
contrast is between Black Dyke, in the acoustically spacious
surroundings of Morley Town Hall and Cory, whose bright opening
bars of James Cook – Circumnavigator will have many
reaching for the remote in shock immediately after the distant
strains of Festival Music.
It
will not however dampen the enthusiasm of the many brass
players nationwide that will be keen to hear the five top-drawer
performances of the “regional” test pieces as their own band’s
rehearsals gather momentum in the run up to the contest day.
Reviews
from previous months Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the
discs reviewed. details We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin
Board
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to
which you refer.