Editorial Board
MusicWeb International
Founding Editor Rob Barnett Editor in Chief
John Quinn Contributing Editor Ralph Moore Webmaster
David Barker Postmaster
Jonathan Woolf MusicWeb Founder Len Mullenger
The Essential José Carreras CD 1: Giuseppe VERDI (1813–1901) La traviata: 1. Libiamo [2:57] Umberto GIORDANO (1867–1948)
Fedora:
2. Ma dunque è amore? … Amor ti vieta [2:44] Giacomo PUCCINI (1858–1924)
Tosca:
3. Dammi i colori… Recondita armonia [4:12] 4. E lucevan le stelle [3:18]
5. O dolci mani [1:44]
Turandot:
6. Non piengere, Liù [2:24]
7. Nessun dorma [3:15] Gaetano DONIZETTI (1797–1848)
Poliuto:
8. Tu sei commosso!... [3:31]
9. D’un’alma troppo fervida [1:59] 10. Ah! fuggi! da morte … [3:31] 11. Fia vero! ... Di! [1:37] Umberto GIORDANO Andrea Chenier: 12. Un dì all’azzurro spazio [4:22]
13. Come un bel dì di maggio [7:00] Jules MASSENET (1842–1912)
Werther:
14. Orchestral introduction … [2:28]
15. Il faut nous séparer … [1:59]
16. Mais vous ne savez rien de moi … [3:36]
17. Rêve! Extase! [3:31] Pietro MASCAGNI (1863–1945)
Cavalleria rusticana: 18. Tu qui, Santuzza? … [9:41]
19. La tua Santuzza [2:19] Georges BIZET (1838–1875)
Carmen:
20. V’est toi! C’est moi … [4:22]
21. Mais moi, Carmen, je t’aime encore [4:53] CD 2: Richard RODGERS (1902–1979)
South Pacific:
1. Some enchanted evening [3:15]
2. Twin soliloquies: This is how it feels [1:47]
3. This nearly was mine [3:45]
4. Finale ultimo: Dites-moi … Some enchanted evening [4:15]
Edvard GRIEG (1843–1907)
5. T’estimo (I love Thee) [2:38] Federico MOMPOU (1893–1987)
6. Damunt de tu, només les flors (Above you, nothing but
flowers) [4:02] Trad. (arr. Joan Casas)
7. Els contrabandists (The smugglers) [2:18] Eduard TOLDRÀ (1895–1962)
8. Festeig (Courtship) [2:57]
9. A l’ombra dell lledoner (In the shadow of the nettle tree)
[4:19]
10. Canço de passer cantant (Pass by singing) [2:45] Vincenzo BELLINI (1801–1835)
11. La ricordanza (Recollection) [5:45]
12. Malinconia, ninfa gentile (Melancholy, gentle nymph)
[1:58]
13. Vaga luna (Lovely moon) [3:19]
14. Per pietà, bell’idol mio (In pity, my fair idol) [2:36]
15. Il fervido desiderio (Ardent desire) [2:42]
16. Dolente imagine di Fille mia (Sad image of my Phyllis)
[3:30] Fermin Maria ALVAREZ (1833–1898)
17. Pregarìa(El cant de l’anima a la verge) [4:24]
Richard STRAUSS (1864–1949)
18. Wiegenlied (Cradle song) [4:10] José FELICIANO (b. 1945)
19. Feliz navidad [2:58]
José Carreras
(tenor)
Agnes Baltsa (mezzo) (CD 1 tr. 1 & 14-21), other soloists incl.
Katia Ricciarelli, Kiri Te Kanawa, Placido Domingo and Luciano Pavarotti;
Martin Katz (piano) (CD 2 tr. 11-16); orchestras conducted by Placido
Domingo, Giuseppe Patané, Michael Tilson Thomas, Lorin Maazel and
others
rec. 1983 – 1999 SONY CLASSICAL
88697214412 [76:19 + 65:03]
To be honest “The Essential José Carreras” is to be found elsewhere.
By 1983, when the earliest recordings on this compilation were
made, his originally beautiful lyric tenor had already started
to deteriorate. There was a harder, coarser tone at forte and
above and much more strain than before. His lyrical qualities
can still be enjoyed in his honeyed mezza-voce singing, which
he employs skilfully and elegantly. Try the opening of E lucevan
le stelle and O dolci mani (CD 1 tr. 4-5). There is
a lot of sensitive phrasing throughout the two discs, paired with
his deep involvement and dramatic intensity. In many ways his
career came as a latter day parallel to that of Giuseppe Di Stefano.
Both were the possessors of extremely beautiful voices, cut out
for singing bel canto roles and the lighter Verdi and Puccini
roles. Both chose to tackle heavier roles far too early and the
effects in the case of Carreras can be heard here. The results
are not bad but considering how much better they could have been
if he had chosen repertoire more discriminatingly they can be
dispiriting.
Among
the better items are the arias from Turandot, which
are also the earliest recordings. There he still has some
youthful sap in the voice. He sings with a great deal of sensitivity
in the excerpts from South Pacific, better I would
say than in West Side Story that he recorded a couple
of years earlier for DG, also with Kiri Te Kanawa and with
Bernstein conducting. Principally, though, it is the wrong
voice since the role was conceived for a bass and the original
Emile de Becque was Ezio Pinza no less. He also
sings with feeling in some of the Spanish songs on CD 2, especially
those by Catalan composer Eduard Toldrà. The Bellini songs,
with stylish piano accompaniments by Martin Katz, also have
something to offer, not least La ricordanza, which
is a reworking of the soprano aria Qui la voce from
I puritani. Unfortunately he too often indulges in
shouting towards the end and that is a recurring feature of
his singing but in general he is fairly stylish in these songs.
Hearing Grieg’s Jeg elsker dig (I Love Thee), sung
in Spanish and with an orchestral arrangement by Carreras
himself, is more a matter of curiosity but he sings it wholeheartedly
and with feeling.
In the operatic excerpts on CD we hear some impressive singing from his
partners: Eva Marton’s big-voiced Fedora, and an involved
and nuanced Katia Ricciarelli in Poliuto and Agnes
Baltsa is splendid as Charlotte in Werther, Santuzza
in Cavalleria rusticana and truly formidable as Carmen.
Here Carreras is also at his dramatic best but he is preferable
on the complete recording of the opera on DG with Karajan
conducting and Baltsa again his Carmen. The excerpts from
Werther involve a continuous scene from the orchestral
interlude – well conducted by Domingo – to the end of act
1. It is always good to have longer scenes like this instead
of isolated arias but in some instances I must question the
producer’s choice. Why, for instance, continue the track with
Recondita armonia another full minute with the Sacristan’s
mutterings? And why, in Andrea Chenier, continue for
several minutes after Come un bel di di maggio; we
hear nothing from Chenier – he has already left the stage
– but a dialogue with Gérard and Schmidt and later Maddalena?
It is supposed to be a portrait of Carreras, isn’t it? On
the other hand the aria In dì all’azzurro spazio, according
to the track-list, is supposed to be preceded by Colpito
qui m’avete ov’io geloso, where Chenier actually sings,
but here it is omitted. A bit slip-shod, isn’t it?
The final tracks on CD 2 are a couple of excerpts from a concert in Vienna
in December 1999 with The Three Tenors but we hear
more of Domingo and Pavarotti than Carreras.
Fans of Carreras should disregard anything negative I have said so far
but others are advised to sample before buying. People should
be aware that “The Essential José Carreras” is to be found
in the Philips catalogue of the 1970s supplemented by a selection
of items in the DG and EMI catalogues of the late 1970s and
early 1980s. There are no texts and no comments on the music.
The sound is variable and there are some clumsy cuts in excerpts
from complete operas.
Reviews
from previous months Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the
discs reviewed. details We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin
Board
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to
which you refer.