Editorial Board
MusicWeb International
Founding Editor Rob Barnett Editor in Chief
John Quinn Contributing Editor Ralph Moore Webmaster
David Barker Postmaster
Jonathan Woolf MusicWeb Founder Len Mullenger
Wolfgang Amadeus
MOZART (1756–1791) Don Giovanni (1787)
Simon Keenlyside
(baritone) – Don Giovanni; Alfred Muff
(bass) – Il Commendatore; Eva Mei (soprano) – Donna Anna;
Piotr Beczala (tenor) – Don Ottavio; Malin Hartelius (soprano) – Donna
Elvira; Anton Scharinger (bass-baritone) – Leporello; Reinhard
Mayr (bass) – Masetto; Martina Janková (soprano) – Zerlina
Chor des Opernhauses Zürich, Orchester der Oper Zürich/Franz
Welser-Möst
Director: Sven-Eric Bechtoff; Set Designer: Rolf Glittenberg;
Costume Designer: Marianne Glittenberg; Lighting Designer:
Jürgen Hoffmann; Choreographer: Stefano Giannetti
Directed for TV and Video by Felix Breisach
rec. live 14, 16 and 18 May 2006
Colour NTSC System 16:9; Audio Content: LPCM Stereo; Dolby
5.1 Digital Surround; DTS 5.1 Surround EMI CLASSICS
5009709 [2
DVDs: 185:00]
Wherein lies the greatest difference between a live opera
performance and buying a production on DVD? Of course the size
of the
stage picture and the atmosphere – of being there – but also
the different ways of consuming. Mostly, I believe, we go
to the opera house and see a performance once, while we buy
DVDs to return to. Or maybe we don’t. Financially speaking
a visit to the opera house, even when we have the house next
door, is far more expensive than buying the production on
DVD, so maybe we buy and consume only once and if that’s
the case it doesn’t matter if we like it or not. We can throw
it away or give it away or just store it somewhere, where
we are not likely to find it again.
I write this preamble since this is a production that gave me
some pleasure to watch but I don’t believe I will ever want to
return to it. Well, there are certain numbers I would like
to listen to, because they are well sung and in that
case I have to take EMI to task for not providing a tracklist
so I can use it in my CD player.
Let’s come to the point: what was it I didn’t like? The production
is of that modernistic kind with rather abstract stage pictures,
modern costumes and sometimes quite absurd things happening
that have little relevance or connection with the text. When
the curtain raises in the middle of the overture all the
characters are on stage in motionless postures and there
are other characters there too. Sometimes mime artists in
the background illustrate what is being told in the arias,
for instance when Donna Anna tells Don Ottavio about Don
Giovanni’s attempt to seduce her just before the play starts.
Props are sparse: some sofas, in the party scene towards
the end of the first act a curved bar. I have to admit that
the production has its humorous points and that the director
has created sharply etched characters, sometimes surprisingly
so. Don Giovanni himself, brilliantly acted by Simon Keenlyside,
isn’t only the callous, scheming and callous libertine – he
is also soft and caring – or is that just a trick too? In
the first scene, when he has stabbed Il Commendatore, he
takes care of the dying man, dabs his forehead and seems
honestly sorry. Likewise at the end of the act, after having
tried to rape Zerlina off-stage he is so considerate. There
are innumerable ways of portraying this enigmatic character
and I am not sorry to have seen this production but I don’t
believe I will want to revisit it very often.
Musically it is also an uneven performance. Franz Welser-Möst can
be a quirky conductor and here he leads his forces in a reading
that is curiously stodgy and heavy-footed. At least the first
act is almost unbearably sluggish. The overture is dark and
forbidding, Leporello’s aria at the opening of the act slow
and with heavy ritardandi – just as his catalogue aria a
little later. The point is of course to give Anton Scharinger
time to be expressive, but this is also supposed to be a
virtuoso aria. The Don Giovanni – Zerlina duet La ci darem
la mano is also extremely slow. Thank God that Simon
Keenlyside is allowed to sing his Champagne aria at something
similar to the normal tempo. The second act fares better
and at least partly saves the evening.
There is some highly inventive and entertaining choreography
and the playing and singing of chorus and orchestra is up
to expected
standards. I have already mentioned Simon Keenlyside’s detailed
Don Giovanni and his singing I assured and beautiful with
his second act serenade probably the pick of the whole performance.
Anton Scharinger is a splendid actor and makes Leporello
very human. Unfortunately his singing isn’t of the same calibre
- he sounds worn and dry. Reinhard Mayr is a constantly jealous
and hectoring Masetto and Alfred Muff is a physically powerful
Commendatore who is so furious that one suspects that he
is going to win the duel with Don Giovanni. As Don Ottavio
Piotr Beczala sings well and he embellishes the reprise of Dalla
sua pace quite liberally.
Eva Mei is a vibrant Donna Anna, a little too heavy at times but her
second act aria Non mi dir is movingly sung. Both
as actor and singer Malin Hartelius is a superb Donna Elvira
and Martina Janková is a charming Zerlina, innocent looking
and with pure, crystalline tone.
To sum things up: this production has its points if one can
accept the abstract setting, the cast are good actors and
much of
the singing is good but Welser-Möst’s heavy-handed conducting
lets it down seriously.