Editorial Board
MusicWeb International
Founding Editor Rob Barnett Editor in Chief
John Quinn Contributing Editor Ralph Moore Webmaster
David Barker Postmaster
Jonathan Woolf MusicWeb Founder Len Mullenger
Maria Callas(1923-1977) - The
Complete Studio Recordings (1949-1969) Detailed contents list at end of review EMI CLASSICS
3959182 [70 CDs]
This seventy
CD set claims to feature everything Maria Callas recorded
in the studio and that is certainly the case in respect
of operas and recitals previously published by EMI itself and
also by Cetra. Material not previously remastered has been
done so specifically for this issue, including the Cetra
recordings that were recently reissued by Warner Classics
under the title Simply Callas (2564 69814-4). The
contents are listed at the end of this review and include
twenty-six operas and fourteen recitals, most of the latter
as they were originally issued in LP form. The seventy
CDs of this collection are contained in cardboard sleeves
within
an ornamental box, which slides in a outer case bearing
the singer’s portrait. The CDs are numbered sequentially
according to recording date except for CDs 68 and 69. the
first of
which contains recordings made between 1953 and 1961 and
not included elsewhere. Likewise the second is of recordings
made between 1962 and 1969. The final CD (70) is a ROM
with libretti and ‘Callas Picture Gallery’. The
libretti are given as separate files grouped by composer.
Each libretto
is given with translation in English, German and French.
The picture gallery comprises a set of black and white
photographs of Callas in various roles or in the recording
studio. In
view of the comments, in this review and elsewhere, about
her weight loss and its possible effect on her singing,
the difference between her figure in the early 1950s and
by 1955
are notable. The accompanying booklet gives all details
including venues and dates for each recording and a brief
essay in
English, German and French about the singer and her recording
career. It is not easy to find the contents from this booklet
and purchasers might do better to print off the list at
the end of this review and keep it in the box.
It is often said that the
great Italian tenor Caruso made the gramophone or, alternatively,
the gramophone made the tenor’s reputation. Certainly his
singing made a big impact on the sale of the new fangled
phonographs and record playing devices that became the vogue
in many homes. Cometh the day, cometh the man, or woman.
With the advent of the 33rpm long playing record, every recording
company saw the opportunity that the new playing length offered
for the recording of opera. What had previously taken eighteen
sides or more on 78rpm shellac discs could now be accommodated
on a mere five or six of 33rpm vinyldiscs. Each recording
company rushed to sign up known stars from the operatic stage
for their roster of planned, or to be thought about, repertoire.
Audiences in the major houses of Milan’s La Scala and New
York’s Metropolitan Opera, as well as in the Italian provinces,
were thick with recording company executives. Some of the
singers on stage were well known, being involved with the
complete operas already available on 78s. Otherwise the
executives were alert for new talent. The British Columbia
label, Angel
in America, and its chief record producer Walter Legge,
were very much on the look out. Making a big impact was
an American-born
singer of Greek origin called Maria Callas, who opened
the La Scala season in 1951, the ultimate accolade. Legge
thought
her histrionic and vocal skills were what his company needed;
skills around which to build their opera catalogue. The
problem for Legge was that Callas had already been signed
up by Cetra-Sorio,
an Italo-American company to record four operas La Gioconda, La
Traviata, Manon and Mefistofele. Dario
Sorio, Cetra’s President had noted Callas’s Verona debut
in 1947 and later broadcast recital.
Born in New York of Greek
parents, at age 14 Callas returned to Greece in 1937 for
her musical education, and sang the role of Santuzza in a
student production when only 15 years old! She joined the
Athens Lyric Theatre singing Tosca, the Fidelio Leonore,
and Santuzza again. However, it was not until 1947 when she
sang La Gioconda in the vast Verona Arena that she
attracted attention and was engaged by Tulio Serafin to
sing Isolde - in Italian. In 1949, having sung Brünnhilde eleven
days earlier, she sang Elvira in Bellini’s I Puritani in
Venice. To learn and perform two operas of such diverse
fach in such a time-scale was a formidable achievement
of intellect
and vocal skill. Each role is formidably challenging for
a mature well-established singer let alone one at the start
of a career. Dario Sorio did not lose sleep over such issues
and in 1949 the Cetra label issued recordings based on
radio performances in Turin. These constitute the first
recital
disc of this collection. This recital (CD 1) includes Callas’s
deeply impressive singing of the Liebestod from
Wagner’s Tristan
und Isolde, Casta Diva from Norma and three
arias from I Puritani. What a selection! No wonder
Legge was to get interested. But, two years later, in October
1951, on her way back to Italy from Rio, Callas stopped off
in New York and signed the Cetra contract. She made her first
complete opera recording for the company, La Gioconda, in
Turin one year later (CDs 2-4). This recording, together
with the Cetra recital and the La Traviata that Callas
was to record for the company are included in this collection
in new remasterings under licence from Warner-Fonit.
At this stage in Callas’s
burgeoning performance career, fate took a turn in Legge’s
favour. Dario Sorio moved to Angel Records, the American
arm of EMI, its relationship with RCA Victor having come
to an end. After an assiduous courtship Callas followed
Sorio, and Legge had his artist; Callas signing an exclusive
contract
in July 1952. By then Callas was making considerable waves
in the long neglected bel canto repertoire. She had broken
into international recognition singing Norma in South
America in 1949. Whilst Norma was to be her calling-card
at Covent Garden, La Scala and the Met, it was her portrayal
of the title role in Lucia de Lammermoor that caused
waves round the operatic establishments in the early 1950s.
This became her first recording under her new Columbia/Angel
contract. Before that could take place Callas fulfilled
the first of her obligations to Cetra with a recording
of Ponchielli’s La
Gioconda. In fact Callas only ever sang the part of
Gioconda thirteen times on stage, including her Italian
operatic debut
at Verona in 1947. The 1952 recording reprises the tenor
and conductor from the Verona performances. The demanding
and highly complex character of the eponymous heroine requires
just the skills that the diva evinced in abundance at this
point in her career (CDs 2-4) She recorded the part again
in 1959 (CDs 52-54). Many Callas enthusiasts contend that
in this later recording, despite manifest vocal shortcomings,
her interpretation is more vivid than found here. That
is as maybe. Personally, I find that the first recording,
with
Callas’s voice fresh and even, some movement between registers
in Suicidio apart, to be preferable. Her singing is
tender, passionate and fiery, as the interpretation variously
demands; in its totality her performance constitutes a formidable
portrayal. I review the whole of this first recording in
the Naxos remastering (see review).
Despite my admiration for the Naxos realisations, taken
from LP pressings by Mark Obert-Thorn and Ward Marston,
with the
advantage of access to the master tapes the versions under
consideration here have a sonic advantage in respect of
clarity and impact. To my ears these advantages are shared
by all
such parallel releases. However, I must point out this
is a contentious issue and relates to the pitch of the
transfers.
This matter is discussed in some detail in a postscript
to a colleague’s review of
the first Callas Tosca recording on Naxos. In my own review of
the parallel remasterings by Naxos and Regis of the Callas Rigoletto, I
touch on the influence of remastered pitch on the audible
output. Apart from that between Naxos and Regis, the differences
between these various reissues are not so great as to worry
any except those with perfect pitch, the highest quality
audio reproductive systems and reference speakers.
The Columbia contract was
intended to combine the use of La Scala with its august orchestra
and chorus. This did not prove possible for three of the
first five operas recorded as the sessions were scheduled
during the theatre season. With Callas’s
performances of the title role in Lucia de Lammermoor in
Italy in 1952 being described as revelatory it
was the first to be recorded - but not the first released
- of the Columbia/Angel recordings (CDs 5-6). It was recorded
in the Teatro Communale in Florence, a friendlier recording
acoustic than the ever-problematic La Scala. The orchestral
and choral forces are under the eloquent baton of Callas’s
guide and mentor Tullio Serafin. He had prepared Rosa Ponselle
in 1927 as well as Callas for their debuts in the role, and
in 1959 he did likewise for Joan Sutherland for her memorable
performances at Covent Garden. It was Serafin who persuaded
Callas to bring the bel canto repertoire into her own when
she seemed heading towards Wagner (Kundry, Isolde and Brünnhilde)
and the heavier Italian roles (Turandot) all of which she
had sung in the theatre.
Legge also signed Giuseppe Di Stefano and Tito Gobbi to constitute a core triumvirate with Callas
for many of the complete opera recordings that he and the
soprano were to set down together over the next seven or
so years. Both male singers make
outstanding contributions to the success of the Lucia recording
(see review). Gobbi
with his incisive biting tone is a suitably bullying Edgardo,
whilst as Lucia’s lover, Enrico, Di Stefano gives one of
his best performances in the series of collaborations with
the soprano. In this recording Callas concentrates on the
words and the evolution of the unfolding drama and uses a
great variety of colour and tone to portray Lucia’s various
situations, emotions and ultimate madness. In the Mad Scene
itself she goes through her full vocal repertoire. Starting
with covered, even occluded, half voice and then moving,
via a high girlish tone, into full spinto richness and
then clear toned coloratura with pin-point accuracy before
concluding
with a pure high E flat note that runs down the spine.
In the totality of her interpretation there are times when
a
slight tonal unevenness between the registers is evident,
but this is far superior to the 1959 stereo remake where
her voice no longer does her bidding and where her tenor
partner, Tagliavini, is well past his best (CDs 50-51).
A major problem with many
of Serafin’s opera recordings, including those with Callas,
was his predilection for the then current performing practice
in respect of traditional cuts. Their work together suffers
in that respect. In general there were several more years
to wait before absolutely complete recordings of operas,
particularly in the bel canto repertoire. That being said,
and although much is made of Callas’s contribution to the
so-called bel canto revival, it owes just as much to Serafin’s
work with her and others. He had the idiom of the genre
in his bones as is well illustrated in this Lucia recording,
and elsewhere on disc, with his pacing and support for the
singers and the moving forward of the drama. He is the conductor
of the following I Puritani, (CDs 7-8) (see review)
and Cavalleria Rusticana (CD 10), both being recorded
in the Basilica di Santa Eufemia in Milan. Although the
resonant acoustic of the venue certainly muddied the sound
of the
Bellini in its LP days, it is much clearer in these remasterings.
Callas is still in good form in the bel canto Bellini whilst
the drama of Santuzza’s predicament brings out the vocal
strengths in her dramatic lower register; Di Stefano shows
some vocal limitations in both. It is worth noting that
Callas took on the role of Santuzza for the recording a
few weeks
before the scheduled Tosca sessions when another singer
withdrew.
In August 1953 came the first
recordings in the La Scala theatre itself, Puccini’s dramatic Tosca was
chosen with the theatre’s redoubtable Music Director himself,
Victor de Sabata, on the rostrum (CDs 10-11). Recorded
complete, anecdote and legend surround the recording and
particularly
the number of re-takes the perfectionist conductor and
Legge demanded. Although when first issued the performance
was
not greeted with unalloyed joy, it has become recognised
as one of the all-time greats. By absolute standards, none
of the three principals is vocally perfect. Callas herself
does not always sustain a perfect legato, Gobbi has raw
patches in his tone and Di Stefano is stretched at climaxes.
However,
it has to be said that these failings are more than adequately
compensated for by the strengths of the performance. Di
Stefano sings with ardent lyrical beauty in his great solo
pieces
and particularly in the Act 3 duet with Tosca. No Scarpia
on record has been so threatening, or snarled so effectively,
as Gobbi; his taunting of Tosca in the Church, prior to
the Te
Deum, is chilling But, above all, what makes this performance
truly great is Act 2, where Gobbi and Callas, as they did
in so many theatres, act off each other. The sparks of the
drama, aided by the orchestral tension built up by de Sabata,
really fly. There are moments of involvement and identification
of singer and role rarely caught on a recording. It is the
vocal acting and dramatic tension built up in Act 2 that
justifies the iconic status of this recording (see review).
The issue of the first Callas
opera sets on the Columbia/Angel labels, and their reception,
must have seemed like free publicity for the smaller Cetra
label. They took Maria into the RAI studios in Turin to record
her Violetta in La Traviata in September 1953, eighteen
months before her acclaimed performances in the renowned
Visconti production conducted by Giulini at La Scala in
1955. With a relaxed Santini on the rostrum, and alongside
relatively
routine colleagues, she shines. It is her only studio recording
of the role. To considerable frustration currency restrictions
meant that Britain was not able to import copies from the
Italian source. The performance has all the Callas hallmarks
and the 2007 EMI remasterings sound far superior to the
LPs I eventually owned after Manchester’s Rare Records
franchised the Cetra catalogue, albeit nearly bankrupting
themselves
in the process! My review of
the performance on remastering for Naxos indicates the poorer
recording quality obtained by Cetra compared with Columbia
and I am pleased to report sonic improvement here (CDs 12-13).
It was back to the Metropole
Cinema in Milan in April 1954 for Callas’s first recording
of Norma. Strangely, at La Scala itself Renata Tebaldi,
Decca’s and Callas’s personal diva rival, was singing Tosca.
Why Legge waited so long to record here as Norma I do not
know. It would have been a better choice than I Puritani the
year before as evinced by her vocal freshness in Lucia.
In the 1952 performances at Covent Garden under Gui she had
bowled over the critics. This live performance has been issued
by EMI (562668-2). On this studio recording Callas and Stignani,
as Adalgisa, are in less fresh voice whilst Fillipeschi is
routine as Pollione. Despite these reservations, as I indicate
in my review of the Naxos remasterings (see review),
Callas’s Norma in this performance has an overwhelming
impact (CDs 14-16). She re-recorded the work in stereo
in September
1960 in her last opera recording at La Scala with Serafin
again the conductor (CDs 55-57). In this later recording,
Corelli, as Pollione, and Zaccaria are infinitely better
than their predecessors, whilst Christa Ludwig is a vocally
secure but unidiomatic Adalgisa. Callas, however, is vocally
uneven. Her lifestyle and her inappropriately heavy repertoire
of ten years before had taken their toll on a significant
interpretation of one of the greatest of bel canto roles
for the soprano voice.
In June 1954 diva and producer
Legge were back in La Scala for Pagliacci; Serafin
again the conductor (CD 17). I find Callas’s voice too big
for Nedda and she tries, unconvincingly, to lighten her tone.
Gobbi is, however, first rate. Two months later, Legge and
Callas were again in La Scala for the first of five Verdi
recordings that were made over the next twenty-seven months.
Perhaps aware of Decca’s plans for Tebaldi, the opera chosen
was La Forza del destino (CDs 18-20). It would be
foolish to state that Callas could soar above the orchestra
with an even line like Tebaldi let alone Milanov in this
work. But despite moments of vocal unsteadiness in a sotto
voce diminuendo or at the top of the voice as she floats
a phrase, overall hers is a performance of high standard.
Legge, wisely cast the bigger voiced Tucker for the spinto
role of Alvaro. For her last La Scala recording of the year,
set down in the August, the opera chosen was the then rarely
performed, except by Callas, bel canto work by Rossini, Il
Turco in Italia. This was badly received at its premiere
in La Scala in August 1814 but under Gavazenni, and alongside
Gedda as Narcisco, Callas works wonders with its fioratura
and humour (CDs 21-22).
September 1954 saw Callas
in the different setting of Watford Town Hall and embarking
on two - her first - recital discs titled Puccini Arias (CD
23) and Lyric and Coloratura Arias (CD 24). Her trusted
mentor, Serafin, was on the rostrum. On the Puccini disc
her rendering of Donde lieta usci from La Boheme is to die for whilst her Si. Mi chiamano
Mimi from the same opera is less convincing. As well
as her Butterfly arias, of note also is her singing
of Liu’s two poignant arias from Turandot that tear at the heartstrings.
In contrast her rendering of In questa reggia is unsteady.
She never sang Mimi on the stage whilst her Turandot was
heard widely in Italy a few years before this recording.
In the second recital, her singing of L’altra notte
in fondo al mare from Boito’s Mefistofele makes one
regret that the contracted Cetra recording was never realised
and her La mamma morte from Andrea Chenier is
really her metier. In a period when coloratura technique
seemed lost Callas’s craft was much admired. Over 50 years
later with many singers with which to compare her coloratura
skills, hers can be faulted in many respects, technical as
well as interpretive. An example is her singing of Lakmé’s Bell
Song; much admired at the time of its issue it now
seems thin and wiry with Callas’s coloratura lacking tonal
body and flexibility. The lower pitched Una voce poca fa, recorded
the year before her La Scala performances, which were only
moderately well received, it is significantly more technically
adroit and with her characterisation showing Rosina’s viperish
persona.
The year 1955 was the era
of Callas at La Scala. She appeared in no fewer than six
productions varying between Rossini’s comedy Il Barbiere
di Siviglia to verismo and also including the memorable
series of La Traviata performances conducted by
Giulini and produced by Visconti. In the two years previously
she
had shed over twenty-five kilos of weight. To her divadom
at La Scala Callas added other facets of the diva lifestyle
and behaviour. With her newly svelte figure she began to
be concerned about the ‘correct’ social circles and her picture
appeared in the newspapers beyond the review pages. Her first
recording of the year was a recital made in the La Scala
theatre (CD. 25) under Serafin and taking in repertoire varying
from Cherubini’s Medea, Spontini’s La Vestale to
Bellini’s La Sonnambula and produced by Walter Jellineck
who seemed to take on the duties when Legge was not available.
Despite Callas’s great season at La Scala that year, Legge,
to her chagrin, chose to record La Traviata with another
singer rather than wait another two years for her restrictions
under the Cetra recording to lapse. One wonders if the ever-perceptive
Legge was hearing things in her sung performances, or seeing
warning signs in her lifestyle, that caused him concern.
That may be just contentious conspiracy theory. Certainly
he continued to cast her in a widely varying repertoire,
some of which she had never sung on stage, whilst neglecting
to record some of her greatest roles such as Lady Macbeth.
For him repertoire was sales bound whilst for her part she
was comfortable in the recording studio and seemed willing
to record whatever was proposed.
What Legge had in mind was
a renewal of Callas’s association with Karajan with whom
she had worked to great acclaim in Lucia di Lammermoor that
same year. The chosen opera for the June recording was Madama
Butterfly (CDs 26-27) with Nicolai Gedda as Pinkerton.
Callas only ever sang the role on stage three times, but
together with Karajan she creates a very individual performance
being able to represent Butterfly’s evolving maturity,
soon-to-be-dashed joy and the move to her destiny, in a
manner few have equalled.
The rest of the cast are mediocre and Gedda a disappointment.
Two months after the Butterfly recording
Callas returned to Verdi for her next three recordings, all
made in La Scala with its particular acoustic problems. The
first two, Aida (CDs 28-29) and Rigoletto (CDs
30-31), have Serafin on the rostrum and Gobbi as the father.
Callas had not sung Aida on stage since 1953, perhaps
recognising it was no longer a role for her in the theatre.
On record her performance is vocally varied. In my review of
the Naxos remastering, I note her lack of vocal security
in O patria mio while acknowledging her better Ritorna
Vincitor and enjoying the visceral excitement and drama
of her confrontation with Barbieri’s Amneris in Fu la
sorte dell’armi and with Gobbi’s Amonasro in the Nile
scene. Richard Tucker is a robust Radames. In the September
it was the turn of Rigoletto with Di Stefano returning
to the recording roster as the Duke. Callas never sang
Gilda on stage and although she manages convincing coloratura
she
never gets under the skin of the role and her affecting
of a girlish tone does nothing for her dramatic gifts or
the
opera. This issue really belongs to Gobbi’s dramatic interpretation
of the jester (see review).
.
The final instalment of the
Verdi trio took place at La Scala in August 1956. It was
one of Callas’s longest gaps from studio recording at that
time. With Karajan again on the rostrum the work was Il
Trovatore (CDs 32-33). Legge had wanted the vocally robust
Tucker for the role of Manrico. Tucker,
a devout Jew, preferred not to be associated with Karajan
whose connections with the Nazi regime in World War II were,
to say the least, questionable and the part went to di Stefano. In
the lyrical passages he sings and phrases well, but lacks
the vocal heft that the role really requires. Inevitably
this is evident in Manrico’s big scena in act 3, Ah si,
ben mio and Di quella pira when the voice takes
on a bleating character rather than a full-toned attack.
Callas exhibits not dissimilar weaknesses as Leonora. That
she could and does inflect insights into the facets and dilemmas
of the character is indisputable but as in her Aida there
is a downside. Perhaps the best illustration
of the strengths and drawbacks can be heard in Callas’s
singing of the two main soprano arias in the opera, Tacea la notte
in placida and D’amor sull’ali rose and in the
more dramatic outbursts when pressure is put on the voice
above the stave and unsteadiness ensues. Rolando
Panerai’s assumption of De Luna fields a rounder tone than
Gobbi might have done but is rather monochrome and his Tace
la notte …Il Trovador! Lo tremo and Il balen are
better heard elsewhere. Fedora Barbieri’s Azucena, whose Stride
la vampa and Ai nostri monte are achieved with
seemingly effortless sonority and expressive characterisation,
is one of the strengths of the performance. Karajan makes
minor excisions (see full review).
A fortnight after her Trovatore Leonora
Legge had Callas go back to Puccini and another role, Mimi,
in La Boheme, a role she never sang on stage. That
seems no limitation and Callas is a very appealing Mimi.
Panerai is a better Marcello than he was as Luna in Trovatore whilst
Moffo, in one of her earliest recordings, is an appealing
Musetta (CDs 34-35). Votto is the conductor as he is in the
following Un Ballo in Maschera (CDs 36-37) recorded
a month after Boheme and with the usual partnership of
Di Stefano and Gobbi. It was Callas’s last Verdi recording
and finds her in better all-round voice than in Il Trovatore.
Her declaration of love in act 2 is memorable while the love
duet with an ardent Di Stefano is one of the best on record.
But it is her rendering of the dramatic Morro, ma prima
in grazia that remains in the mind. Yes, there is the
odd thin or curdled note, but this is one of the soprano’s
best Verdi assumptions on record, her Violetta excepted,
and where singers who are her equal surround her. The role
of Riccardo suits Di Stefano well and his voice is not over-stretched,
allowing him to phrase and express the emotions of the role.
Gobbi’s Renato is heard best in Eri tu, whilst Barbieri
is ideal as Ulrica and Eugenia Ratti a perky Oscar.
Legge was only too aware
that Decca in particular was leaving his company behind
in the technology of the emerging stereophonic recordings.
In
June 1956 he had assembled a star-studded cast at London’s
Kingsway Hall and overcoming the complications of the new
technology recorded Verdi’s Falstaff in the new
medium. It seems it was not so easy to set up the necessary
microphones
and equipment in La Scala, so for Callas’s next recording, Il
barbiere di Siviglia (CDs 38-39) the singers moved
to the London venue in February 1957. With the orchestra
under
an idiomatic Alceo Galliera and with Gobbi dominant and
charismatic as the eponymous barber, it is a thoroughly
enjoyable performance.
Callas had sung the role at La Scala in the winter of 1956
when the claque was vociferous and unsettling. In this
recording, with a well selected tessitura suiting her vocal
state she
characterises well. The recent re-issue of the recording
in EMI’s Great Recordings of the Century series is
reviewed in detail by a colleague (see review).
Back at La Scala for Bellini’s La
Sonnambula the following month (CDs 40-41). Callas
is in good voice although not as light-toned or as fresh
as she needs to be in act one as the young Amina. Later
her veiled and occluded tone conveys the character’s dilemma.
Nicola Monti as Elvino tends to put too much pressure on
his voice at times, producing an unfortunate bleating.
A complete contrast in respect of repertoire (CDs 42-43)
came with the following recording in the July of Puccini’s Turandot.
Callas had made a big impression in the title role in the
early 1950s before concentrating on the bel canto repertoire.
However, in her first recital disc for Legge of Puccini
arias (CD 23), recorded in 1954, she sounds strained singing In
questa reggia (tr. 10). By the time of this complete
recording her high notes are a strain on the listener.
Less than a week later she recorded the composer’s Manon
Lescaut (CDs.44-45). Both complete operas featured
Serafin on the rostrum. Callas’s Manon is full of vocal
drama, particularly in the final scene, whilst she is less
successful with the character’s fickleness.
Later in 1957, in a let-out
clause in her EMI contract, but with Serafin and the La
Scala forces and recorded in the theatre, she sang Cherubini’s Medea for
Casa-Ricordi (CDs 46-47). Her interpretation of the title
role has been described as classic. That may be so, and certainly
her characterisation is superb, but it does not disguise
the changes, for the worse, in her vocal state. As she increasingly
became famed for diva tantrums and her social and love life,
so her vocal state was deteriorating. This was, perhaps,
the last of her opera recordings when she could adequately
disguise, even overcome, the problems that were becoming
increasingly manifest in her stage and studio performances.
The male principals are not in her class despite the limitations
referred to.
After the Medea recording
it was another year before Callas returned to the studio.
As her social life among the international jet set drew attention,
so performances in the opera house declined. To a degree
she compensated with recitals and was to record another two
recital discs, her first since June 1955 (CD 25). The first,
devoted to Verdi Arias (CD 48) was recorded in the
Abbey Road Studio 1 in October 1958 and overlaps the second
recorded in Kingsway Hall the same and following days. The
difference is the provision, of the Philharmonia Chorus for
the disc entitled Mad Scenes (CD 49). The Verdi
Arias 1 includes Lady Macbeth’s three big arias. This
was a role that Callas had sung on stage ten or more years
before and she really spits character and venom in her interpretations.
Verdi had stated that he wanted character and definitely
not a beautiful voice for the role and Callas’s performance
here would have pleased him immensely. She really bites
the drama in Nel di della (CD 48 tr.1) whilst not being
able to disguise vocal unsteadiness in the following La
luce langue and adopting a characteristic occluded tone
in the sleep walking aria, a mono version of which is included
on CD 68. Overall, her interpretations of Lady Macbeth here
do make one regret that Legge was too conservative and under
the prevailing thumb of the popularity of the opera. Nowadays
collectors would love a studio recording of Callas and Gobbi,
as King and Queen, made around 1953. EMI has issued a live
recording from La Scala made in 1952 under De Sabata and
that is some compensation (CMS7 64944-2). The same is true
for Nabucco in respect of the lack of a studio recording.
Callas only ever sang the role of Abigaille in 1949 in Naples.
None the less, her representation of Ben io t’ invenni (CD
48 tr.4) is imperious, albeit the movement from chest voice
upwards in the stave is not without vocal faults and the
final note is not easy on the ear. Elvira in Ernani was
a role she never sang on stage and her interpretation in Ernani, Ernani,
involiami (tr.5) has no virtues in her then vocal state,
whilst her Elisabetta from Don Carlo has perhaps too
much character, as well as unsteadiness, for the lovely final
aria of the young Queen, Tu che le vanita (tr.6).
In the following recital,
entitled Mad Scenes (CD 49), Callas sings with abandon
and the effects are thrilling as long as the listener can
live with the her vocal frailty. This is increasingly the
state of affairs as she and Legge repeated Lucia di Lammermoor in
London in March 1959 (CDs 52-53) and La Gioconda at
La Scala in September 1960 (CDs 53-54), both in stereo. Callas
enjoyed a major success in Lucia under Karajan in Berlin
in 1955. As with Macbeth, a recording of a performance
from that series has been issued by EMI (CMS7 63631-2) but
it was an opportunity lost for a studio recording. As with
their first Lucia recording (CDs 5-6), Serafin butchers the
score whilst the singing of both Callas and Tagliavini is
as severe a disappointment to me now, as it was fifty years
ago. The young Pierro Cappuccilli as Enrico shows the promise
amply fulfilled in the theatre and on record in the following
thirty years. It is he, Ivo Vinco as Alvise, Pier Miranda
Ferrraro as a virile voiced Barnaba and the young Fiorenza
Cossotto as La Cieca who provide the enjoyment in the La
Gioconda remake (CDs 52-54). Others find Callas’s interpretation
preferable to the earlier Cetra recording. For me the vocal
flaws weigh heavily. Callas’s stereo remake of Norma followed
at La Scala a year after in September 1960 (CDs 55-57). In
the role that was for so long her calling-card, it is again
a shadow of her greatest interpretations in the theatre,
some of which are available on disc as live recordings.
After the remake of Norma,
and with her private life continuing to impose strain on
her operatic work, Callas made some recordings in London
conducted by Antonio Tonini who, as assistant Music Director
at La Scala, had helped to prepare many of her roles at the
theatre in the mid-1950s. These are contained on CDs 68 and
69 and are dealt with below. In spring 1961, autumn 1963
and again in May 1964, Callas ventured into the warm acoustic
of the Salle Wagram in Paris to record recitals with Georges
Prêtre on the rostrum. She felt the acoustic
suited her voice at that time and the results were issued
as Callas à Paris 1 and 2 (CDs
58-59). Her choice of repertoire is interesting and must
reflect her own awareness of some vocal limitations at the
top of the voice although Depuis le jour requires
a legato beyond her vocal state. All the arias are sung in
French with the three from Samson et Dalila on the
first disc being the most successful and where she also essays
the two arias from Carmen. The following three recital
discs (CDs 60-62) were recorded, again in the Salle Wagram
but with Nicola Rescigno on the rostrum at sessions in December
1963 and early 1964. They are titled Mozart, Beethoven
and Wagner, Verdi Arias II and Rossini and
Donizetti Arias. Of these Salle Wagram recitals, items
such as Ah! perfido from Oberon suit her
vocal state better than others, certainly better than Donna
Anna’s
or Elvira’s arias from Don Giovanni (CD 60. trs
1 and 4-6). On the Verdi disc her rendering of Desdemona’s
act four arias from Otello (CD 61 trs. 2-3) are full
of characterful insights but are also marred by the occluded
tone that she had, of necessity it seems, adopted as standard.
Lack of steadiness that is nothing short of a wobble is also
a feature that intrudes into the bel canto arias of CD 62.
These vocal characteristics are also found on the third Verdi
recital disc (CD 67) where it is painful, to me at least,
to compare her singing of Tacea la notte (tr. 5) from Il
Trovatore and Ecco l’orido campo and Morro,
ma prima in grazia from Un Ballo in Maschera (tr.
7-8) with her singing on the complete recordings. Like the
so-called Tonini sessions, recorded in London in 1960, 1961
and 1962 and a last session in 1969 under Rescigno, all contained
on CDs 68 and 69 these are perhaps for Callas enthusiasts
and masochists only. Maybe Callas herself was aware of their
limitations and only agreed to the release of some of them
several years after their recording.
Callas had returned to perform
at La Scala in the seasons 1960-62 and to Covent Garden
for Zeffirelli’s production of Tosca in 1964 where
the queue waited and slept on the pavements for days beforehand.
She was still seen as a great singing actress despite her
evident vocal limitations. Aware of her selling potential,
EMI cast her as Carmen in a Salle Wagram recording of the
opera made in August 1964. With the polyglot Nicolai Gedda
as José, and a Francophone cast in the other roles, and
with Georges Prêtre on the rostrum. The company issued the
three LPs in a crimson luxury box with the motto Callas
is Carmen (CDs 63-64). It was a role she had never sung
on stage. The central tessitura suits her and she is more
of the tigress than the sexy vamp. However, her vocal unevenness
is problematic on repeated hearings.
With sessions split over
Christmas 1964, and with an unrealised film dubbing in prospect,
Callas recorded her last complete opera. It was to be Tosca again
(CDs 65-66). Despite the harshness at the top of the voice
she and Gobbi had been magnetic at Covent Garden, particularly
in act two, a black and white recording of which exists.
Some of that vitality is lost under Prêtre’s flaccid baton; he nowhere approaches the De Sabata class of
the 1953 recording, but is a mere ‘routinier’. Apart from
the sound, the only improvement on the mono 1953 recording
is Bergonzi who is a vocally tasteful and strong, but not
overly ardent, Cavaradossi.
In conclusion, no singer in the twentieth
century divided critical opinion like
Maria Callas. There is a big, big, problem
facing any critic when reviewing a Callas
collection. For the past fifty years,
there has been a cohort of critics reviewing
her recorded performances who saw her
on stage. She was, without doubt, one
of the greatest singing actresses ever
to adorn the operatic stage. Her Violetta
at La Scala in Visconti’s 1955 production
of Il Traviata, with Giulini
on the podium, were legendry great nights
of opera albeit not vocally perfect.
London critics had had similar great
histrionic nights with her Norma and
Aida at Covent Garden. However, too
many critics who were in the theatre
on those great nights have, in my view,
consistently allowed their subjective
memory of the stage diva to influence
their objective analysis of the singer’s
recorded performances; particularly
those made later in her career. Whatever
the reason, be it flawed vocal production
in respect of how the sound was produced
and projected, or singing big parts
at too young an age, or the lifestyle
she adopted as a media celebrity, her
vocal peak was short-lived and her decline
rapid.
Maria Callas died, alone, in her Paris
apartment in 1977. The legend of the
singer lives on. Such was her impact
on operatic performances in the theatre
and on record. She made an ill-advised
return to the concert platform with
her former tenor partner Giuseppe Di
Stefano in early 1973. The duo made
some recordings, in studio conditions
and accompanied by a London orchestra
that have never seen the light of day.
Only the pedantic would deny EMI their
heading for this issue in the year of
the thirtieth anniversary of the diva’s
death and the sixtieth of those Verona
performances that caused such a stir
among the opera cognoscenti. In bringing
all her recognised studio recordings
together, at an attractive price, it
will enable a new generation of opera
lovers to make their own judgement.
In those early years of her career,
when coloratura technique seemed lost,
Callas revived a repertoire consigned
to history. After her Sutherland, Caballé,
Gruberova and the likes have taken on
that repertoire, often with a more secure
vocal technique. That is the way of
progress, but none can take away from
Callas the impact her performances had
in theatres and on the awareness of
opera among the general public. That
is her greatest epitaph. Robert J Farr
CONTENTS
The accompanying
booklet gives all details in sequence of recording, except
for CDs 68 and 69. These CDs are collections from various
dates ranging from 1953-61 on the fist disc and 1962-1969
on the second.
Detailed Contents List
1. The complete studio recitals First Recital - Bellini and Wagner. (CD 1)
(Recorded November
1949 in Turin for Cetra). Remastered. 2007
RAI Orchestra, Turin, Arturo Basile
Puccini Arias. (CD
23)
(Recorded September 1954, London)
Philharmonia, Tullio Serafin Lyric & Coloratura Arias. (CD
24)
(Recorded September 1954, London)
Philharmonia, Tullio Serafin Callas at la Scala. (CD
25)
(Recorded June 1955)
Orchestra of La Scala, Milan, Tullio Serafin Mad Scenes. (CD 49)
(Recorded September 1958, London)
Philharmonia, Nicola Rescigno Verdi Arias volume 1 (CD 48 )
(Recorded September 1958, London)
Philharmonia, Nicola Rescigno Verdi Arias volume 2 (CD 61)
(Recorded December 1963 & February 1964, Paris)
Paris Conservatoire Orchestra, Nicola Rescigno Verdi Arias volume 3 (CD 67)
(Recorded 1964 to 1969)
Paris Conservatoire Orchestra & Paris Opéra Orchestra,
Nicola Rescigno Callas à Paris volume 1 (CD 58)
(Recorded March-April 1961, Paris)
French Radio National Orchestra, Georges Prêtre Callas à Paris volume 2 (CD 59)
(Recorded May 1963, Paris)
Paris Conservatoire Orchestra, Georges Prêtre Rossini & Donizetti Arias (CD
62)
(Recorded April, 1964)
Paris Conservatoire Orchestra, Nicola Rescigno Mozart, Beethoven & Weber Arias (CD
60)
(Recorded December 1963 & January 1964, Paris)
Paris Conservatoire Orchestra, Nicola Rescigno The EMI Rarities (2 CDs) (CDs
68-69)
Recorded 1962
London (The Tonini sessions). 1964, 1965 and 1969 Paris
2. The complete studio opera recordings Vincenzo BELLINI (1801-1835) Norma (CDs
14-16)
(Recorded April 1954) - Mono
Mario Filippeschi, Ebe Stignani
Chorus & Orchestra of
La Scala, Milan, Tullio Serafin
Norma (CDs
55-57)
(Recorded September 1960)
- Stereo
Christa Ludwig, Franco Corelli
Chorus & Orchestra of
La Scala, Milan, Tullio Serafin
I Puritani (CDs
7-8)
(Recorded March 1953)
Giuseppe Di Stefano, Nicola
Rossi-Lemeni, Rolando Panerai
Chorus & Orchestra of
La Scala, Milan, Tullio Serafin
La Sonnambula (CDs 40-41)
(Recorded March 1957)
Eugenia Ratti, Fiorenza Cossotto,
Nicola Monti
Chorus & Orchestra of
La Scala, Milan, Antonino Votto
Georges
BIZET (1838-1870)
Carmen (CDs
63-64)
(Recorded July 1964, Paris)
Nicolai Gedda, Robert Massard
Paris Opéra Orchestra, Georges
Prêtre
Luigi
CHERUBINI (1760-1842)
Medea (CDs
46-47)
(Recorded September 1957),
remastered. 2007
Renata Scotto, Mirto Picchi
Chorus & Orchestra of
La Scala, Milan, Tullio Serafin
Donizetti:
Gaetano
DONIZETTI (1797-1848)
Lucia di Lammermoor (CDs 5-6)
(Recorded February 1953,
Florence) - mono
Giuseppe Di Stefano, Tito
Gobbi
Chorus & Orchestra of
the Maggio Musicale Fiorentino, Tullio Serafin
Lucia di Lammermoor (stereo recording) (CDs
50-51)
(Recorded March 1959, London)
- Stereo
Ferruccio Tagliavini, Piero
Cappuccilli
Philharmonia Chorus & Orchestra,
Tullio Serafin
Ruggero
LEONCAVALLO (1858-1919)
Pagliacci (CD
17)
(Recorded May 1954)
Giuseppe Di Stefano
Chorus & Orchestra of
La Scala, Milan, Tullio Serafin
Pietro MASCAGNI (1863-1945)
Cavalleria Rusticana (CD. 9)
(Recorded August 1953)
Giuseppe Di Stefano
Chorus & Orchestra of
La Scala, Milan, Tullio Serafin
Amilcare
PONCHIELLI (1834-1886)
La Gioconda (CDs 2-4)
(Recorded September 1952,
Turin, for Cetra)
Fedora Barbieri, Gianni Poggi,
Paolo Silveri
RAI Turin Chorus & Orchestra,
Antonino Votto
La Gioconda (Second recording) (CDs
52-54)
(Recorded September 1959)
Fiorenza Cossotto, Piero
Cappuccilli
Chorus & Orchestra of
La Scala, Milan, Antonino Votto
Giacomo PUCCINI (1858-1924)
La Bohème (CDs
34-35)
(Recorded August-September
1956)
Giuseppe Di Stefano, Anna
Moffo, Rolando Panerai
Chorus & Orchestra of
La Scala, Milan, Antonino Votto
Madama Butterfly (CDs 26-27)
(Recorded August 1955)
Nicolai Gedda, Lucia Danielli
Chorus & Orchestra of
La Scala, Milan, Herbert von Karajan
Manon Lescaut (CDs 44-45.)
(Recorded July 1957)
Giuseppe Di Stefano
Chorus & Orchestra of
La Scala, Milan, Tullio Serafin
Tosca (CDs
10-11 )
(Recorded August 1953) -
Mono
Giuseppe Di Stefano, Tito
Gobbi
Chorus & Orchestra of
La Scala, Milan, Victor de Sabata
Tosca (Second recording) (CDs 65-66)
(Recorded December 1964,
Paris) - Stereo
Carlo Bergonzi, Tito Gobbi
Paris Opéra Chorus & Paris
Conservatoire Orchestra, Georges Prêtre
Turandot (CDs
42-43)
(Recorded July 1957)
Elisabeth Schwarzkopf, Eugenio
Fernandi
Chorus & Orchestra of
La Scala, Milan, Tullio Serafin
Gioachino
ROSSINI (1792-1868)
Il barbiere di Siviglia (CDs 38-39)
(Recorded February 1957,
London)
Luigi Alva, Tito Gobbi
Philharmonia Orchestra, Alceo
Galliera
Il Turco in Italia (CDs 21-22)
(Recorded August-September
1954)
Nicolai Gedda, Nicola Rossi-Lemeni
Chorus & Orchestra of
La Scala, Milan, Gianandrea Gavazzeni
Giuseppe
VERDI (1813-1901)
Aida (CDs
28-29)
(Recorded August 1955)
Richard Tucker, Fedora Barbieri,
Tito Gobbi
Chorus & Orchestra of
La Scala, Milan, Tullio Serafin
Un ballo in Maschera (CDs 36-37)
(Recorded September 1956)
Giuseppe Di Stefano, Tito
Gobbi
Chorus & Orchestra of
La Scala, Milan, Antonino Votto
La forza del destino (CDs 18-20)
(Recorded August 1954)
Richard Tucker, Carlo Tagliabue
Chorus & Orchestra of
La Scala, Milan, Tullio Serafin
La Traviata (CDs 12-13)
(Recorded September 1953,
Turin), remast. 2007 (2 CDs)
Francesco Albanese, Ugo Savarese
RAI Chorus and Orchestra,
Turin, Gabriele Santini
Rigoletto (CDs
30-31)
(Recorded September 1955)
Giuseppe Di Stefano, Tito
Gobbi
Chorus & Orchestra of
La Scala, Milan, Tullio Serafin
Il Trovatore (CDs 33-32)
(Recorded August 1956)
Giuseppe Di Stefano, Rolando
Panerai, Fedora Barbieri
Chorus & Orchestra of
La Scala, Milan, Herbert von Karajan
CD 70 CD-ROM (Opera-Libretti & Callas
Picture Gallery in black and white)
Reviews
from previous months Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the
discs reviewed. details We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin
Board
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to
which you refer.