Editorial Board
MusicWeb International
Founding Editor Rob Barnett Editor in Chief
John Quinn Contributing Editor Ralph Moore Webmaster
David Barker Postmaster
Jonathan Woolf MusicWeb Founder Len Mullenger
Buy
through MusicWeb
from £11.00 postage
paid World-wide. Try
it on Sale or Return You
may prefer to pay by Sterling cheque or
Euro notes to avoid PayPal. Contact
for details
William
BUSCH (1901-1945)
Cello Concerto (1940/1941) [23:27]
Piano Concerto (1937/1938) [28:18]
Raphael Wallfisch (cello), Piers Lane
(piano)
Royal Philharmonic Orchestra/Vernon Handley
rec. details not supplied. DDD
LYRITA SRCD320[51.45]
When I was writing about Natalie Clein’s
fabulous new recording of the Elgar
Cello Concerto (EMI 5014092 - see review)
I moaned at her coupling of symphonic
arrangements of some of Elgar’s salon
pieces. I secretly wished that she had
paired the work with either the Havergal
Brian Cello Concerto – a lovely
piece fully deserving of our attention
- or the William Busch Cello Concerto
which, although I’d never heard it,
I expected to be something fine. Half
of my wish-list is now complete!
William Busch was much admired by Vaughan
Williams, Tippett and Finzi, but just
as he was establishing a reputation
as a composer he died, of a brain haemorrhage,
his body undiscovered for several days,
aged just 43.
I won’t recall his life story for, elsewhere
on this site, there are fine
articles by Julia Cornaby Busch,
the composer’s daughter and by Sinclair
Logan, which are all you could hope
for regarding this interesting composer.
Since his early death one wonders if
perhaps the neglect of his music is
due to the fact that his work is more
cosmopolitan than most English composers
working at this time. He studied in
America and Germany - his parents came
from that country - as well as at the
Royal Academy of Music in London. He
didn’t have the time to fully realise
his potential. Also, only a handful
of his works were ever recorded: four
songs each, by Henry Cummings on 78s
(DECCA m 576 (10”)), Peter Pears (originally
DECCA ZRG 5439/RG 439 (1965) re-issued
on Belart 461 5502 (1997) and one by
Janet Baker (originally HQS 1091 (1967),
re-issued on EMI CDM 565009-2 (2000)).
This latter recording of Busch’s setting
of Æ’s (George William Russell’s) poem
Rest was my introduction to this
composer. In 1990 BBC Radio 3 broadcast
a programme of Busch’s chamber works
– including the magnificent Piano
Quartet in G minor (1938/1939) and
the Nicholas Variations (1942).
The latter was named for his son, who
was, for many years, principal horn
with the London Philharmonic and is
the superb soloist in the recording
of Britten’s Serenade with Ian
Partridge (in fine voice) with the LPO,
conducted by John Pritchard (EMI Classics
for Pleasure 5759782). That is all the
majority of contemporary music-lovers
will know of Busch’s fine art, so this
new disk is all the more valuable.
The Cello Concerto, although
written in wartime, is an intensely
lyrical work, beautifully conceived
for soloist and orchestra. Busch certainly
could orchestrate. The nearest we get
to the English Pastoral school is in
the slow introduction to the first movement,
a stately and elegiac cadenza where
the soloist is joined in his musings
by the orchestra. It’s not long before
we’re on a roller-coaster ride where
themes flit to and fro - not long singable
melodies but fleeting ideas of a few
notes duration. The music dances, jig-like,
tinged with a hint of sadness. The slow
movement is a pastoral meditation, but
not a specifically English pastoral,
more, I feel, a meditation for the loss
brought about by war, and a remembrance
of things past. One brief climax interrupts
the cello’s sorrowful song. Much of
the music of the finale is under clear
skies, boisterous and virtuosic, with
only the occasional cloud obscuring
the view. Then a race to the end. It’s
all over far too quickly. This Concerto
is a masterpiece and we must give great
thanks to Lyrita for giving it to us.
The Piano Concerto is a different
matter and it comes as a shock after
the Cello Concerto. The first
movement is full of delightful chatter,
starting with, and returning to, neo-classical
- no fat on the meat, as John Amis writes
in his notes - passagework for the soloist.
It’s full of high spirits, and again,
is not without the odd moment where
dark clouds obscure the landscape, but
it all ends in good humour. The slow
middle movement is another pastorale,
with beautiful dialogue between soloist
and orchestra – and some ravishing oboe
solos. The finale is a set of variations,
which contains some very challenging
music and events. It’s also a very serious
affair, which puts it at odds with the
other two movements, but it’s the right
movement for the work: this Concerto
couldn’t end any other way.
As with the Cello Concerto, Busch’s
conception is highly intelligent and
very well conceived, and, although it’s
obviously a virtuoso piece, the solo
writing is never “showy” for its own
sake.
Might I make one suggestion? The emotional
power of the Cello Concerto is
such that playing the Piano Concerto
immediately after does the latter work
a great disservice. When you’ve listened
to the cello work, stop the disk, give
yourself some breathing space, make
a cup of tea, drink it, then listen
to the Piano Concerto – you will
enjoy it all the more. That certainly
worked for me.
This is music of a highly personal nature.
True, there are moments - and only moments
- where one might say, “Oh that sounds
like…” but Busch has forged his own
style and he transcends his influences
with ease and his undoubted skill and
talent.
An excellent recording, clean, bright
and clear, with first-rate balance between
the superb soloists and orchestra, which
is in the most capable of hands for
this music. John Amis’s very informative,
and personal, notes in the booklet complete
one of the very best issues ever to
come from Lyrita. Buy it. Cherish it.
Let’s not let this fine composer disappear
from our sights ever again.
Reviews
from previous months Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the
discs reviewed. details We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin
Board
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to
which you refer.