Editorial Board
MusicWeb International
Founding Editor Rob Barnett Editor in Chief
John Quinn Contributing Editor Ralph Moore Webmaster
David Barker Postmaster
Jonathan Woolf MusicWeb Founder Len Mullenger
Music of the Reformation Martin LUTHER (1483-1546) Nun bitten wir [0:50] Mitten wir im Leben sind [1:31] Nun bitten wir [0:50] Nun bitten wir [0:50] Nun bitten wir [0:50] Durch Adams Fall [0:54] Mit Fried und Freud [0:43] Caspar OTHMAYR (1515-1553) Ein feste Burg a 4 [2:17] Ein feste Burg Bicinium [1:00] Ein feste Burg a 4 [2:24] Verba Lutheri ultima [4:37] Mitten wir im Leben sind Bicinium [1:55] Epitaphium D Martin Lutheri [8:54] Durch Adams Fall Bicinium [1:19] Mit Fried und Freud [0:57] Verleih uns Frieden [1:41] Johann WALTER (1496-1570) Nun bitten wir [1:46] Nun bitten wir [1:43] Nun bitten wir [1:46] Der christliche Glaub [2:59] Mitten wir im Leben sind [3:08] Das Vater unser Vater [2:38] Durch Adams Fall [2:20] Mit Fried und Freud [1:03] Verleih uns Frieden [1:54]
Himlische
Cantorey: (Veronika Winter (soprano); Henning Voss (alto);
Henning Kaiser (tenor); Jan Kobow (tenor);
Ralf Grobe (bass)); Michel Freimuth (lute); Gregor Hollmann
(organ)
rec. 28 August, 1-2 September 2003, Markt Nordheim, Schloß Seehaus,
Germany. DDD CPO 777
275-2 [49:12]
This could be a CD of greater historical than musical significance. It
can often be useful to see the state of affairs ‘before and
after’ such a major change as the German Reformation: to
be immersed for a rather ungenerous 50 minutes or so in the
liturgical, poetic and devotional works at its centre contributes
to our understanding of how and why the changes that one
of the figures on this three-composer CD, Martin Luther,
had such a huge impact.
So there
is an element of historical explanation; some of the works
admirably performed here by the Himlische Cantorey
are present for comparative purposes… to hear how each of
Luther, Othmayr and Walter treated the likes of Mitten
wir im Leben sind, Durch
Adams Fall and Mit Fried und Freud is instructive.
But the works – and their inspired performances – are more
than merely intriguing; they are enjoyable and uplifting
in their own right. So, yes, there is a purely historical
point to ‘Music of the Reformation’, but it’s also
a musically very rewarding CD.
Of course there was a period of half a dozen years or so
between the momentous events at Wittenberg in 1517 and the
appearance of the first Protestant hymnal in 1523/24. Then
there was a veritable flood of all kinds of sacred songs,
psalmodies, cantica, cantiones, enchiridions and so on. It’s
actually quite surprising that a purely protestant feel and
sound was established so quickly – largely thanks to the
way in which the German language was substituted for existing
Latin texts (contrafactum).
Luther himself, probably familiar with the Flemish repertoire
and with Josquin, paid – it seems - little attention to composition
until after about 1523, although he was thoroughly educated
in musical technique. A chief motivation of his musical work
was surely to bring the theology to which he was so devoted
straight to believers in the vernacular and in an idiom wholly
accessible to them.
Johann Walter, younger than Luther, worked with him to establish
a Mass in German form while he was court composer in Saxony;
while Caspar Othmayr comes from the second generation being
over 30 years Luther’s junior. He held a number of clerical
and teaching positions throughout his short life; his collections
of hymns show affinity both stylistically with Josquin and
philosophically with the achievements of Luther. Some of
Othmayr’s music on this disc is exceptionally beautiful and
further exploration of his work would pay huge dividends;
sadly no CD dedicated exclusively to him is current in the
catalogue.
Works by each of these three gentle and intense composers
are interleaved on the CD in such a way – generally – that
we get up to three successive treatments and versions of
the same work. They are low-key and restrained hymn settings;
there is not the exuberance or extroversion of a Schütz or
Scheidt in the works of Luther and Othmayr in particular.
Much less polyphonic writing than was current in the Catholic
south at this time. Rather a controlled and inward-looking,
intimacy that the members of the Himlische Cantorey bring out very well. They achieve
this mainly by an acute attention to tempi and just the right
blend of unself-conscious solo virtuosity and ensemble work.
Most of the pieces on this disc consist of performances by
between two or three and seven of the soloists accompanied
softly and yet expressively by the lute, organ or both. The
effect is somewhat magical – a quiet family gathering around
the fireside in the twilight to make music to and for their
God. That’s not to say that performance techniques are absent
or relaxed: listen to the delivery of Jan Kobow (with Gregor
Hollmann) when declaiming Othmayr’s Ein Feste Burg,
for example; it’s clear, pure and direct with neither spurious
understatement and nor undue Puritan reticence. The music’s
joy and celebratory elements Himlische Cantorey convey by
attention to detail and apt clarity of intonation. This lets
what must have sounded like extraordinary piety at the start
of the sixteenth century carry the weight of what is a consistently
felicitous marriage of words and music.
The acoustic is a rich and reverberant one – the beautiful
and isolated Schloß Seehaus in the small Upper Bavarian town
of Petting – and adds to the listening experience. The notes
and text are reproduced in German, English and French in
a simple little booklet, making this a welcome, self-contained
addition to a specialist repertoire that will serve several
purposes – not least, it ought to send lovers of late German
Renaissance choral music in search of more music by these
three unpretentious and melodious composers, warmly and professionally
presented by Himlische Cantorey.
Reviews
from previous months Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the
discs reviewed. details We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin
Board
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to
which you refer.