Is this the classical music
DVD of the future? It’s a 54 minute concert
combined with a 52 minute documentary,
one of six featuring a symphony by different
composers. I’m happy to start with the
music. This is a refreshing, invigorating
performance. The famous two opening chords
are arresting and explosive yet the sforzandi
thereafter dance. The second theme (tr.2
1:37) is smoother yet kept animated, its
third element (2:20) allowed to ponder
more, but its fourth (2:52) bounces along.
There’s just sheer relish in the blazing
5 repeated chords. The exposition is repeated.
The development (6:38) has a suitable
sense of mystery and then a keen vigour
as the first and second themes combine
(7:18). The new, third theme (9:13) is
beguilingly presented, well balanced between
its oboes and second violin and cello
elements. Later in the striding string
bass Nagano finds an energizing kick.
At the recapitulation the horn solo is
rather fruity for the marking ‘sweet’
but has a lovely glow with that same first
theme in the coda against delicate violin
tracery. And in the peroration all guns
blaze.
In the Funeral March
Nagano conveys both the formality and humanity of mourning.
On the one hand there’s the vivid carriage drag depicted by
the clarity of the doublebasses, on the other the momentum Nagano
gives the procession. The second theme (tr. 3 18:33) is both
more assertive and faces the reality of death and therefore
becomes more poignant in the grieving associated with it. The
central passage in C major is a happy recollection of what the
hero stood for with a blistering climax soon expunged by the
returning reality of the procession. Nagano makes the fugal
section (24:29) rigorously formal and weighty. This is a mighty
monument, after which the recapitulation is rather warmer.
Nagano begins the
Scherzo in crisp and inviting fashion. This is the music of
rejuvenation, vivacious and resilient with bracing full orchestra
passages. The Trio is taken at a fractionally more comfortable
tempo for the 3 horns’ articulation which is pleasingly jolly
and rotund, full charming measure being given to the slight
lingering character of their final phrase.
By contrast Nagano
makes a gloriously swaggering flourish of the 11 bar introduction
to the finale, but if you want to play the complete finale separately
you’ll have to use your fast reverse and begin at tr. 4 38:33.
Track 5 (38:46) begins at the first appearance of the theme
in the bass. This is smiling but the soft strings’ pizzicato
is rather weighty. The second variation (39:55), on the other
hand, achieves full charm in the measure of its crescendo
and decrescendo. In the third variation (40:30), the
theme is robustly treated by full orchestra after its first
outing on creamy oboe. Nagano presents the fugue of the fourth
variation (41:15) with attractive clarity. In the fifth variation
(42:12) he offers at first a cool repose but in the sixth (42:47)
rugged fervour. Then the seventh (43:32) is smoother, with a
gentler fugue a foil for the heavyweight climax. The eighth
variation (45:05) sees rosy flowering from oboes, clarinets
and bassoons, as marked Poco Andante and con espressione
but without detriment to the momentum nor light touch as the
music progresses. This allows another contrast in the glowing
first horn presentation of the theme in variation 9 (46:51).
To the coda (49:23) Nagano brings a carnival atmosphere of festive
bounce. In sum this is a performance of great clarity of structure
and texture combined with spontaneity of expression inclined
to the raucous. This makes an enjoyable combination and experience.
I compared the 2000
performance on DVD by the SWR Sinfonieorchester/Michael Gielen
(Euroarts 2050609). Here are the actual music comparative timings:
Timings
|
I
|
II
|
III
|
IV
|
Total
|
Nagano
|
16:26
|
14:53
|
5:37
|
11:24
|
48:20
|
Gielen
|
15:24
|
12:58
|
5:42
|
10:00
|
44:04
|
Gielen’s opening
is clean cut but not as arresting as Nagano’s. Gielen favours
a clean, finely balanced line whereas Nagano prefers a startling
and at times abrasive clarity aided by excellent surround sound.
Gielen spotlights the lyrical aspects more, so the second theme
is more mellifluous and charming in its interplay of woodwind
and strings. He blends and can be seen toning down the sound
at times, a rather Olympian presence directing the music. But
the coda is expertly and effectively scaled up. Nagano, on the
other hand, you see more spontaneously involved in the present
music making. Not using a baton he can be more expressive with
his hands. His opening has immediately more impact and there’s
more bite to all the loud passages, revolutionary with a capital
R. At the beginning of the development he creates a more palpable
sense of mystery than Gielen and more tension within it. His
slightly slower tempo overall provides for greater internal
contrasts. The camerawork for Gielen is conventional but on
this DVD for Nagano we get close-up overhead shots, zoom and
panning whirring around, not a comfortable view but suited to
a performance which isn’t intended as a comfortable listen.
Gielen’s Funeral
March is dignified but everything is kept neatly in its due
place, the regularity of tempo, faster than Nagano’s, is an
aspect of this. Emotion is clear but kept in check. With Nagano
there’s more rawness, a sense of protest underlying the rigour
of the proceedings which gives them more tension. For example,
the colouring of the cello line from tr. 3 18:58 is very expressive,
in accord with the violins and anticipating the cello espressivo
marking at their solo at 19:14. This is both caring and desolate.
The later fugue is firm yet with a compelling sense of progression
which feeds the splendour of its fulfilment. The trumpet calls
at 27:02 just before the recapitulation seem like the Last Judgement.
Gielen’s Scherzo
is light and sunny. It teems with life. His Trio is notable
for its alert, dancing horns. Nagano’s Scherzo is vivacious
owing to its clarity of texture and powerful sense of progression
with the passages for full orchestra really bursting into life.
Taking the Trio just a shade slower gives its melody a lift
and grace.
Gielen’s pacy finale
has a stylish progression and light touch. The strings’ rhythmic
acuity in the fourth variation fugue is contrasted well with
the brighter flute solo in variation 5. His Poco Andante
variation 8 is a melodious, sunny homage, less emotive than
Nagano’s, before a firm coda. Nagano brings more weight to the
finale. He is less playful than Gielen yet shows some rounded
humour and tone which allows charm in the oboe’s presentation
of the theme. But his presentation seeks out and spotlights
drama and rhetoric, with clear interest in the rhythmic resilience
of the fourth variation fugue, a seriousness underpinning the
movement’s progression and melodious reverence to the Poco
Andante. Gielen shows how Beethoven evolved from 18th
century practice. Nagano presents him trailblazing into the
19th century.
Nagano’s DVD has
a documentary as a bonus. This is based around the concert performance,
much of which you therefore re-experience in the light of Nagano’s
comments, a few contributions from the players and two brief
historical scenes featuring Beethoven as a cartoon character
with an American accent. These latter may appeal to a those
keen on animation. I thought an actor could have got across
the actual Beethoven quotations with more impact. No matter,
the players’ perspectives are a welcome novelty. One cellist
points out Beethoven uses the cello to create a stormy sound
and illustrates both the rhythmic and lyrical aspects of his
writing. Another cellist speaks of Beethoven’s very transparent
writing as a result of which ‘You often feel you are playing
on your own’. You remember this later when a first violinist
talks of the ‘transparent sound’ Nagano achieves. I agree. She
reflects on the ‘bleak colour’ wanted in the Funeral March,
also on the discipline of suppressing your individuality when
playing in a group but psychological satisfaction this brings,
playing together harmoniously. A horn player speaks about the
challenge and adrenalin of the Trio because ‘you never know
how quickly the conductor is going to take it’.
Nagano also offers
plenty of insight gradually, cumulatively introduced and in
an unpretentious manner. For instance, he finds in Beethoven
‘a vertical concept of sound space that we’ve never had before
which gives a dimension of eternity, deeply spiritual and emotional’.
Later you see him in rehearsal of the Funeral March asking for
more emotion. Another link later still is when he talks about
the orchestra being ‘a flexible instrument, courageous and bold’
which ‘has to make sense vertically’ of the music ‘and simultaneously
horizontally have logic to it’ in order to respect the genius
of Beethoven. There’s a particular tension about this work ‘because
it’s about the spirit of humanity, you can’t treat it in a routine
way’. The key elements of the work for him are its sense of
progression and how its heroic ideals allow the individual to
dream positively, that is hope. Also the emphasis on how important
human development is rather than arriving at a stable goal at
the end. In the finale ‘you feel the variations are going through
an eternal sense of development’.
This
fresh and electric performance allows
you to see the Eroica in a new light.
The documentary enhances that experience
by revealing something of what makes
it tick.
Michael Greenhalgh