Editorial Board
MusicWeb International
Founding Editor Rob Barnett Editor in Chief
John Quinn Contributing Editor Ralph Moore Webmaster
David Barker Postmaster
Jonathan Woolf MusicWeb Founder Len Mullenger
Charles WUORINEN (b.
1938) Cyclops 2000 (2000) [23:29]* A Reliquary for Igor Stravinsky (1974-5) [17:12]
London Sinfonietta/Oliver
Knussen
rec. 16 May 2001, Queen Elizabeth Hall, South Bank Centre,
London*; October 1994, Henry Wood Hall, London. DDD LONDON SINFONIETTA
SINFCD4-2006 [40:41]
This
performance of Wuorinen’s Reliquary for Igor Stravinsky was
previously issued on Deutsche Grammophon DG 447 068-2GH
in 1995, when it was coupled with performances of several
late
Stravinsky works - The Flood, Abraham
and Isaac, Variations: Aldous Huxley in Memoriam and
the Requiem Canticles, all conducted - very well -
by Oliver Knussen. A reliquary is, of course, a container
- large or small - for one or more religious relic, a container
which is usually a well-made work of art in its own right.
The ‘relics’ here consist of musical fragments on which Stravinsky
had been at work at the very end of his life; for the most
part these were what Wuorinen describes as “hexachordal-rotational
arrays of the sort first developed by Krenek in the 1940s
and later appropriated by Stravinsky as crucial constructive
material for his 12-tone works”. Wuorinen’s reliquary is
arranged in six sections. It begins with the material most
closely modelled on Stravinsky’s surviving notes, orchestrated
and filled-out in a very passable imitation, thoroughly respectful,
of Stravinsky’s last musical idiom. There follows a variation
on these materials in a more fully Wuorinen-like manner,
interrupted by a powerful ‘Lament’ for solo violin. The fifth
movement recapitulates the Stravinskyan materials and the
work closes with a short coda. Wuorinen’s use of the orchestra
is everywhere vivid and alert, his invention of a high order.
This is a work both highly skilled and decidedly moving,
effecting the kind of homage which wise composers have always
paid to their significant predecessors. Works such as this
are an enactment of what the word ‘traditional’ means in
the most positive of its many senses. Knussen and the London
Sinfonietta are thoroughly at home in this music and this
re-release makes available a significant recording of a significant
piece. The choreographer Peter Martins later used the music
as the basis for a ballet created for New York City Ballet – so
it is perhaps with the advantage of hindsight that one is
struck by the work’s indebtedness to the patterns of dance – patterns
very well brought out in this performance which well predates
Martins’ adoption of the music.
Cyclops 2000
is presented in a recording of the work’s premiere, given
in London in 2000, the work being written to a commission
from Risk Publications, a financial publishing and events
company in London, on the tenth birthday of its magazine Risk.
Cyclops was one of the primordial giants, of whom there was,
in Greek mythology, an entire race. The creatures had only
one eye and their most famous exemplar was perhaps Polyphemus
who appears in Book IX of Homer’s Odyssey, and who
imprisons Odysseus and a number of his men, before being
outwitted (and blinded) by the cunning ruler of Ithaca. Perhaps
not too much of this is directly relevant to Wuorinen’s piece,
which is certainly no simple programme music, but the sense
of narrative movement, speeding up and slowing like a story
in the hands of a good narrator and with a decided ‘twist’ at
the end, does seem to be there in the music. Certainly this
single movement work, which Wuorinen himself describes as
having its “monomaniacal aspect”, has a real sense of scale;
its textures are constantly varied, different instruments
are allowed temporary prominence as soloists, and there are
changing patterns of duetting between individual instruments
and between whole sections of instruments, which make for
a sense of dialogue which feels more like internal subdivision
than an interchange between separate identities. The Cyclops
is big, indeed, and for all its ponderous insistence on moving
forward in a single direction (“atypically for me”, writes
Wuorinen, “the piece has come out in a single constant meter”),
it finds room for a network of interacting elements. It is
a work which rewards repeated hearings and, like the earlier
work, it gets as fully committed and intelligent performance
as the high standards of Knussen and the London Sinfonietta
have led one to expect in the now almost forty years (astonishingly!)
of the orchestra’s existence.
Glyn Pursglove
Reviews
from previous months Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the
discs reviewed. details We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin
Board
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to
which you refer.