MusicWeb International One of the most grown-up review sites around 2023
Approaching 60,000 reviews
and more.. and still writing ...

Search MusicWeb Here Acte Prealable Polish CDs
 

Presto Music CD retailer
 
Founder: Len Mullenger                                    Editor in Chief:John Quinn             

 

BUY NOW 

AmazonUK  

Franz SCHUBERT (1797-1828)
Quintet in C major D956 (1828) [46.19]
Isaac Stern and Alexander Schneider (violins), Milton Katims (viola), Pablo Casals, Paul Tortelier (cellos)
Symphony No.5 in B flat major D485 (1816) [29.10]
Prades Festival Orchestra/Pablo Casals
rec. Prades, 1952 (Quintet) and 1953 (Symphony)
SONY CLASSICAL 82876 787592 [76.00]

Error processing SSI file

 

One classic - and one slight disappointment. That’s always seemed to me the right balance between these two Casals performances, the one directed by him, the other featuring him with a galaxy of like-minded string players.

I’ve always admired his later 1970 Marlboro performance of the B flat major symphony. Here he kills it with kindness rather as he, Stern and Primrose collaborated in killing Mozart’s Sinfonia Concertante at Prades at around the same time.  This earlier Prades symphony performance is without first movement repeat and is rather scrappily played. Casals lacks Beecham’s ineffable lightness and élan and Bruno Walter’s sweetness – you can find the latter’s 1960 Columbia Symphony performance re-released in the same series, coupled with the Unfinished. Part of the problem is the rather turgid basses, and the dragging rhythm generally. The horn fluffs in the second movement are of passing significance only – though doubtless Reiner-esque pedants will find them excruciating.

One feature of the performance I’d not noticed quite as much as in this transfer, which is a tribute to its slight increase in definition and clarity, is the omnipresence of Casals’s grunting. Whilst one might admire the almost theatrical intensity Casals brings to bear in the slow movement the fact remains that Walter is no less expressive and he takes two and a half minutes less, in this movement alone. The finale is certainly not turgid, possessing a rather patrician control though it lacks once again that subtle rhythmic lift that gives zest and animation to the this movement.

The Quintet performance is cut from a different quality of cloth. The tension, the rubati and the caesurae are all part of the intense expressive commitment brought by these five stellar musicians. Obviously one can take a different point of view and many newcomers may be unconvinced by those moments of rhetorical drama that are so plainly on view. Few could really argue with the subtly liquid portamenti the violinists employ nor the highly romanticised phrasing in the slow movement. The ensemble is not watertight and neither is the intonation but the spirit is laden with feeling and generosity and don’t neglect the dynamism of the Scherzo with its powerfully lyric central section; the bronzed seriousness of the phrasing, the rapt passion of the whole enterprise.

I don’t find the DSD and SBM remastering has been able to clarify things quite as impressively as was the case in the Szell Mozart Symphony re-issue in this same series but this is partly to do with the respective ages of the recordings. It’s slightly clarified and improved, no question, but the differences aren’t so major.

Jonathan Woolf

BUY NOW 

AmazonUK  

 


Return to Index

Error processing SSI file