Celebrations in honour
of St Cecilia, patroness of music, have
a long tradition. In England in the
17th century the 'Gentlemen Lovers of
Musick' organised a celebration on St
Cecilia's Day, 22 November, every year.
Poets were asked to write texts and
composers to set them to music. The
text which Handel used for his Ode,
'From harmony, from Heav'nly harmony',
was written by John Dryden for St Cecilia's
Day in 1687, when it was set to music
by Giovanni Battista Draghi (1640? -
1708). Handel's Ode dates from 1739,
when it was first performed on St Cecilia's
Day in Lincoln's Inn Fields. It was
performed together with a previous setting
of another text by John Dryden, also
for St Cecilia's Day: Alexander's Feast.
The text of the Ode
is a mixture of sacred and mythological
elements. It starts with a reference
to the creation of the world. The chaos
has changed into a harmonic order because
of the power of music. In the next sections
this power is celebrated: "What passion
cannot music raise and quell!", the
soprano sings in her first aria. Then
the diverse musical instruments are
characterised: "the trumpet's loud clangour
excites us to arms", which is an aria
for tenor with trumpet, and which is
followed by a march. Then follows a
beautiful aria with solo parts for the
soprano and the flute: "The soft complaining
flute in dying notes discovers the woes
of hopeless lovers". The next aria is
for tenor with strings only: "Sharp
violins proclaim their jealous pangs
and desperation". Then in another aria
the soprano turns to the organ: "But
oh! what art can teach, what human voice
can reach the sacred organ's praise?"
It starts with a long passage for organ
solo with supporting strings. Handel,
being such a celebrated organ virtuoso,
must have felt special attraction to
this text.
The next aria refers
to Orpheus and his lyre. In only the
second and last recitative of the Ode
the attention is turned to the myth
of Cecilia: "But bright Cecilia rais'd
then wonder high'r, when to her organ,
vocal breath was giv'n, an angel heard,
and straight appear'd mistaking earth
for Heav'n."
Considering the quality
of text and music it is rather surprising
there are not that many recordings to
choose from. From that perspective this
disc is most welcome. But I don't think
it can fulfil all expectations.
The general level of
singing and playing is satisfying. The
soprano and the chorus are native German
speakers, and that considered their
pronunciation isn't bad at all, although
one can hear some vowels which are not
quite idiomatic.
The main problem is
a lack of passion: the performance as
a whole is a little subdued and detached.
In the orchestral playing I miss the
grandeur one associates with Handel,
in particular his compositions for special
occasions. The sound of the orchestra
is a little too thin. I would have liked
more dynamic accents, for instance in
the march, and the tempi are sometimes
a little too slow (in particular the
interlude, which follows the overture).
The instrumental solo
parts, in particular the trumpet, transverse
flute and organ, are played very well
by members of the orchestra, who are
not mentioned by name.
Dorothee Mields has
a lovely voice, although I don't like
the slight tremolo, and her diction
could be better. (I would like to add,
though, that since this recording was
made in 1999 she has become a considerably
better singer). She is singing her arias
well most of the time, especially "The
soft complaining flute" and "But oh!
what art can teach". I am less impressed
by her performance of "What passion
cannot music raise" - the passion isn't
quite there. The cello solo is alright,
but too much down-to-earth.
Mark Wilde is also
doing well, but could have made more
of the text. A stronger declamation
would have given a phrase like "Arise
ye more than dead" (the first recitative)
more impact, and the performance of
both his arias is too soft-edged.
To sum up, this is
an enjoyable and sympathetic recording
of one of Handel's finest works. If
one really wants the whole depth and
full quality of this score to be revealed,
though, one has to look elsewhere.
Johan van Veen
see also review
by Jonathan
Woolf